A post-secular turn in attitudes towards religion?

Anti-religiosity and anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe

E.C. Ribberink, Peter Achterberg, Dick Houtman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Post-secular theory nowadays critiques the secularization notion that religion has increasingly become a private issue. It does so by pointing out how religion has once again become paramount to public and political debate, central to which are assertively voiced critiques of Muslims and Islam. Therefore, in this paper, we analyse cross-national survey data from Western Europe to study the attitudes of the non-religious vis-à-vis religion in general and vis-à-vis Islam in particular. Consistent with privatization theory and inconsistent with the postsecular theory, we find that the non-religious do not contest religion more in the most secular countries. As to anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe, however, a markedly different pattern emerges. The non-religious are more intolerant towards Muslims in the most secular countries. Rejections of Islam and of religion generally hence appear driven by different logics. Even though that clearly calls for further in-depth research, indeed anti-Muslim sentiment appears to have more in common with ethnic prejudice and xenophobia than with anti-religiosity in general.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)803-830
JournalRassegna Italiana di Sociologia
Volume58
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017

Fingerprint

Western Europe
Muslim
Religion
Islam
xenophobia
secularization
prejudice
privatization

Cite this

@article{bc3468208c524d848d70a41ce0a7ffe2,
title = "A post-secular turn in attitudes towards religion?: Anti-religiosity and anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe",
abstract = "Post-secular theory nowadays critiques the secularization notion that religion has increasingly become a private issue. It does so by pointing out how religion has once again become paramount to public and political debate, central to which are assertively voiced critiques of Muslims and Islam. Therefore, in this paper, we analyse cross-national survey data from Western Europe to study the attitudes of the non-religious vis-{\`a}-vis religion in general and vis-{\`a}-vis Islam in particular. Consistent with privatization theory and inconsistent with the postsecular theory, we find that the non-religious do not contest religion more in the most secular countries. As to anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe, however, a markedly different pattern emerges. The non-religious are more intolerant towards Muslims in the most secular countries. Rejections of Islam and of religion generally hence appear driven by different logics. Even though that clearly calls for further in-depth research, indeed anti-Muslim sentiment appears to have more in common with ethnic prejudice and xenophobia than with anti-religiosity in general.",
author = "E.C. Ribberink and Peter Achterberg and Dick Houtman",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.1423/88795",
language = "English",
volume = "58",
pages = "803--830",
journal = "Rassegna Italiana di Sociologia",
issn = "0486-0349",
publisher = "Il Mulino",
number = "4",

}

A post-secular turn in attitudes towards religion? Anti-religiosity and anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe. / Ribberink, E.C.; Achterberg, Peter; Houtman, Dick.

In: Rassegna Italiana di Sociologia, Vol. 58, No. 4, 2017, p. 803-830.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A post-secular turn in attitudes towards religion?

T2 - Anti-religiosity and anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe

AU - Ribberink, E.C.

AU - Achterberg, Peter

AU - Houtman, Dick

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - Post-secular theory nowadays critiques the secularization notion that religion has increasingly become a private issue. It does so by pointing out how religion has once again become paramount to public and political debate, central to which are assertively voiced critiques of Muslims and Islam. Therefore, in this paper, we analyse cross-national survey data from Western Europe to study the attitudes of the non-religious vis-à-vis religion in general and vis-à-vis Islam in particular. Consistent with privatization theory and inconsistent with the postsecular theory, we find that the non-religious do not contest religion more in the most secular countries. As to anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe, however, a markedly different pattern emerges. The non-religious are more intolerant towards Muslims in the most secular countries. Rejections of Islam and of religion generally hence appear driven by different logics. Even though that clearly calls for further in-depth research, indeed anti-Muslim sentiment appears to have more in common with ethnic prejudice and xenophobia than with anti-religiosity in general.

AB - Post-secular theory nowadays critiques the secularization notion that religion has increasingly become a private issue. It does so by pointing out how religion has once again become paramount to public and political debate, central to which are assertively voiced critiques of Muslims and Islam. Therefore, in this paper, we analyse cross-national survey data from Western Europe to study the attitudes of the non-religious vis-à-vis religion in general and vis-à-vis Islam in particular. Consistent with privatization theory and inconsistent with the postsecular theory, we find that the non-religious do not contest religion more in the most secular countries. As to anti-Muslim sentiment in Western Europe, however, a markedly different pattern emerges. The non-religious are more intolerant towards Muslims in the most secular countries. Rejections of Islam and of religion generally hence appear driven by different logics. Even though that clearly calls for further in-depth research, indeed anti-Muslim sentiment appears to have more in common with ethnic prejudice and xenophobia than with anti-religiosity in general.

U2 - 10.1423/88795

DO - 10.1423/88795

M3 - Article

VL - 58

SP - 803

EP - 830

JO - Rassegna Italiana di Sociologia

JF - Rassegna Italiana di Sociologia

SN - 0486-0349

IS - 4

ER -