A scientific foundation of simulation games for the analysis and design of complex systems

Heide K. Lukosch, Geertje Bekebrede, Shalini Kurapati, Stephan G. Lukosch

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Background. The use of simulation games for complex systems analysis and design has been acknowledged about 50 years ago. However, articles do not combine all salient factors for successful simulation games, and often stem from a clear view of one particular field of science only. With combining multiple disciplines, connect analysis and design as well as research and practice, we provide deep insights in design and use of simulation games. Aim. This article analyzes the design and evaluation process of a variety of game-based projects and activities, using existing scientific concepts and approaches, in order to establish games as a valid research tool. Our focus lies on the approach towards the use of games as design instrument; using them as an intervention in a larger, complex context, in order to design this context. With our contribution, we aim at providing insights and recommendations on the design and use of games as valid research tools, the limitations of this use, possible pitfalls, but also best practices. Method. We carried out a literature review of related work to identify the most important scientific concepts related to our approach of game design. Further use of combined quantitative and qualitative case study analyses highlights the design process and results of our own game studies. Results. The analyses yielded a consolidated conceptualization of simulation games as research instruments in complex systems analysis and design. The results also include methods for the evaluation of simulation games, additional evaluation methods, and limitations to use simulation games as research instruments. Conclusions. We propose guidelines for using simulation games as research instruments that may be of value to practitioners and scientists alike. Recommendation. We recommend practitioners and scientists to apply the guidelines presented here in their efforts to analyze and design complex systems.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)279-314
Number of pages36
JournalSimulation & Gaming: An international journal of theory, design and research
Volume49
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2018

Fingerprint

Large scale systems
Systems analysis
Complex systems
Simulation games

Keywords

  • analytical science
  • complex systems
  • design science
  • research methodology
  • simulation games

Cite this

@article{304eeb08a7d346b79fa827ce16a4b2a0,
title = "A scientific foundation of simulation games for the analysis and design of complex systems",
abstract = "Background. The use of simulation games for complex systems analysis and design has been acknowledged about 50 years ago. However, articles do not combine all salient factors for successful simulation games, and often stem from a clear view of one particular field of science only. With combining multiple disciplines, connect analysis and design as well as research and practice, we provide deep insights in design and use of simulation games. Aim. This article analyzes the design and evaluation process of a variety of game-based projects and activities, using existing scientific concepts and approaches, in order to establish games as a valid research tool. Our focus lies on the approach towards the use of games as design instrument; using them as an intervention in a larger, complex context, in order to design this context. With our contribution, we aim at providing insights and recommendations on the design and use of games as valid research tools, the limitations of this use, possible pitfalls, but also best practices. Method. We carried out a literature review of related work to identify the most important scientific concepts related to our approach of game design. Further use of combined quantitative and qualitative case study analyses highlights the design process and results of our own game studies. Results. The analyses yielded a consolidated conceptualization of simulation games as research instruments in complex systems analysis and design. The results also include methods for the evaluation of simulation games, additional evaluation methods, and limitations to use simulation games as research instruments. Conclusions. We propose guidelines for using simulation games as research instruments that may be of value to practitioners and scientists alike. Recommendation. We recommend practitioners and scientists to apply the guidelines presented here in their efforts to analyze and design complex systems.",
keywords = "analytical science, complex systems, design science, research methodology, simulation games",
author = "Lukosch, {Heide K.} and Geertje Bekebrede and Shalini Kurapati and Lukosch, {Stephan G.}",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1177/1046878118768858",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "279--314",
journal = "Simulation & Gaming: An international journal of theory, design and research",
issn = "1046-8781",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "3",

}

A scientific foundation of simulation games for the analysis and design of complex systems. / Lukosch, Heide K.; Bekebrede, Geertje; Kurapati, Shalini; Lukosch, Stephan G.

In: Simulation & Gaming: An international journal of theory, design and research, Vol. 49, No. 3, 06.2018, p. 279-314.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - A scientific foundation of simulation games for the analysis and design of complex systems

AU - Lukosch, Heide K.

AU - Bekebrede, Geertje

AU - Kurapati, Shalini

AU - Lukosch, Stephan G.

PY - 2018/6

Y1 - 2018/6

N2 - Background. The use of simulation games for complex systems analysis and design has been acknowledged about 50 years ago. However, articles do not combine all salient factors for successful simulation games, and often stem from a clear view of one particular field of science only. With combining multiple disciplines, connect analysis and design as well as research and practice, we provide deep insights in design and use of simulation games. Aim. This article analyzes the design and evaluation process of a variety of game-based projects and activities, using existing scientific concepts and approaches, in order to establish games as a valid research tool. Our focus lies on the approach towards the use of games as design instrument; using them as an intervention in a larger, complex context, in order to design this context. With our contribution, we aim at providing insights and recommendations on the design and use of games as valid research tools, the limitations of this use, possible pitfalls, but also best practices. Method. We carried out a literature review of related work to identify the most important scientific concepts related to our approach of game design. Further use of combined quantitative and qualitative case study analyses highlights the design process and results of our own game studies. Results. The analyses yielded a consolidated conceptualization of simulation games as research instruments in complex systems analysis and design. The results also include methods for the evaluation of simulation games, additional evaluation methods, and limitations to use simulation games as research instruments. Conclusions. We propose guidelines for using simulation games as research instruments that may be of value to practitioners and scientists alike. Recommendation. We recommend practitioners and scientists to apply the guidelines presented here in their efforts to analyze and design complex systems.

AB - Background. The use of simulation games for complex systems analysis and design has been acknowledged about 50 years ago. However, articles do not combine all salient factors for successful simulation games, and often stem from a clear view of one particular field of science only. With combining multiple disciplines, connect analysis and design as well as research and practice, we provide deep insights in design and use of simulation games. Aim. This article analyzes the design and evaluation process of a variety of game-based projects and activities, using existing scientific concepts and approaches, in order to establish games as a valid research tool. Our focus lies on the approach towards the use of games as design instrument; using them as an intervention in a larger, complex context, in order to design this context. With our contribution, we aim at providing insights and recommendations on the design and use of games as valid research tools, the limitations of this use, possible pitfalls, but also best practices. Method. We carried out a literature review of related work to identify the most important scientific concepts related to our approach of game design. Further use of combined quantitative and qualitative case study analyses highlights the design process and results of our own game studies. Results. The analyses yielded a consolidated conceptualization of simulation games as research instruments in complex systems analysis and design. The results also include methods for the evaluation of simulation games, additional evaluation methods, and limitations to use simulation games as research instruments. Conclusions. We propose guidelines for using simulation games as research instruments that may be of value to practitioners and scientists alike. Recommendation. We recommend practitioners and scientists to apply the guidelines presented here in their efforts to analyze and design complex systems.

KW - analytical science

KW - complex systems

KW - design science

KW - research methodology

KW - simulation games

U2 - 10.1177/1046878118768858

DO - 10.1177/1046878118768858

M3 - Article

VL - 49

SP - 279

EP - 314

JO - Simulation & Gaming: An international journal of theory, design and research

JF - Simulation & Gaming: An international journal of theory, design and research

SN - 1046-8781

IS - 3

ER -