Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance

R.M. Davison, L.H.M. Wong, Steven Alter, Carol Ou

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionScientificpeer-review

Abstract

We undertake an exploratory case study to investigate how warehouse employees work around an Enterprise Resource Planning software that cannot be used as designed due to work practices required by local conditions. Our research illustrates how long-standing approaches to studying IS innovation,
adoption and diffusion in relation to fixed IT artefacts say little or nothing about important phenomena and practical issues. We draw on theories of work systems and IT innovation, adoption and adaptation to explain both why workarounds are required and how they are enacted. Our context involves the local Hong Kong operations of a global retailer of home textiles. Our 29 interviews at the site reveal many perspectives about how an inadequate information system failed to support essential work practices and how employees at the site responded by creating shadow IS that helped them pursue their business responsibilities and objectives. We draw on a compliance view of technology use to suggest that unreflective compliance can be counterproductive; paradoxically, reflective non-compliance may bring
greater benefit to both the organisation and its customers. We conclude with nine implications of our findings for practitioners and for researchers interested in IS innovation, adoption, and diffusion.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS)
Place of PublicationStockholm, Sweden
PublisherAssociation for Information Systems
Number of pages17
Publication statusPublished - 2019
Event27th European Conference on Information Systems: Information Systems for a Sharing Society - Stockholm, Sweden
Duration: 8 Jun 201914 Jun 2019

Conference

Conference27th European Conference on Information Systems
Abbreviated titleECIS2019
CountrySweden
CityStockholm
Period8/06/1914/06/19

Fingerprint

Innovation adoption
Noncompliance
Employees
Innovation diffusion
Work practices
Hong Kong
Technology use
Software
An enterprise
Enterprise resource planning
Retailers
Information systems
Warehouse
Responsibility

Keywords

  • workarounds
  • compliance
  • IT governance
  • Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)
  • shadow IS

Cite this

Davison, R. M., Wong, L. H. M., Alter, S., & Ou, C. (2019). Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance. In Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS) [19] Stockholm, Sweden : Association for Information Systems.
Davison, R.M. ; Wong, L.H.M. ; Alter, Steven ; Ou, Carol. / Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance. Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS). Stockholm, Sweden : Association for Information Systems, 2019.
@inproceedings{bc186a3ea3814160b9fc15e9726fa0f9,
title = "Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance",
abstract = "We undertake an exploratory case study to investigate how warehouse employees work around an Enterprise Resource Planning software that cannot be used as designed due to work practices required by local conditions. Our research illustrates how long-standing approaches to studying IS innovation,adoption and diffusion in relation to fixed IT artefacts say little or nothing about important phenomena and practical issues. We draw on theories of work systems and IT innovation, adoption and adaptation to explain both why workarounds are required and how they are enacted. Our context involves the local Hong Kong operations of a global retailer of home textiles. Our 29 interviews at the site reveal many perspectives about how an inadequate information system failed to support essential work practices and how employees at the site responded by creating shadow IS that helped them pursue their business responsibilities and objectives. We draw on a compliance view of technology use to suggest that unreflective compliance can be counterproductive; paradoxically, reflective non-compliance may bringgreater benefit to both the organisation and its customers. We conclude with nine implications of our findings for practitioners and for researchers interested in IS innovation, adoption, and diffusion.",
keywords = "workarounds, compliance, IT governance, Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), shadow IS",
author = "R.M. Davison and L.H.M. Wong and Steven Alter and Carol Ou",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS)",
publisher = "Association for Information Systems",
address = "United States",

}

Davison, RM, Wong, LHM, Alter, S & Ou, C 2019, Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance. in Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS)., 19, Association for Information Systems, Stockholm, Sweden , 27th European Conference on Information Systems, Stockholm, Sweden, 8/06/19.

Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance. / Davison, R.M.; Wong, L.H.M.; Alter, Steven; Ou, Carol.

Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS). Stockholm, Sweden : Association for Information Systems, 2019. 19.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contributionScientificpeer-review

TY - GEN

T1 - Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance

AU - Davison, R.M.

AU - Wong, L.H.M.

AU - Alter, Steven

AU - Ou, Carol

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - We undertake an exploratory case study to investigate how warehouse employees work around an Enterprise Resource Planning software that cannot be used as designed due to work practices required by local conditions. Our research illustrates how long-standing approaches to studying IS innovation,adoption and diffusion in relation to fixed IT artefacts say little or nothing about important phenomena and practical issues. We draw on theories of work systems and IT innovation, adoption and adaptation to explain both why workarounds are required and how they are enacted. Our context involves the local Hong Kong operations of a global retailer of home textiles. Our 29 interviews at the site reveal many perspectives about how an inadequate information system failed to support essential work practices and how employees at the site responded by creating shadow IS that helped them pursue their business responsibilities and objectives. We draw on a compliance view of technology use to suggest that unreflective compliance can be counterproductive; paradoxically, reflective non-compliance may bringgreater benefit to both the organisation and its customers. We conclude with nine implications of our findings for practitioners and for researchers interested in IS innovation, adoption, and diffusion.

AB - We undertake an exploratory case study to investigate how warehouse employees work around an Enterprise Resource Planning software that cannot be used as designed due to work practices required by local conditions. Our research illustrates how long-standing approaches to studying IS innovation,adoption and diffusion in relation to fixed IT artefacts say little or nothing about important phenomena and practical issues. We draw on theories of work systems and IT innovation, adoption and adaptation to explain both why workarounds are required and how they are enacted. Our context involves the local Hong Kong operations of a global retailer of home textiles. Our 29 interviews at the site reveal many perspectives about how an inadequate information system failed to support essential work practices and how employees at the site responded by creating shadow IS that helped them pursue their business responsibilities and objectives. We draw on a compliance view of technology use to suggest that unreflective compliance can be counterproductive; paradoxically, reflective non-compliance may bringgreater benefit to both the organisation and its customers. We conclude with nine implications of our findings for practitioners and for researchers interested in IS innovation, adoption, and diffusion.

KW - workarounds

KW - compliance

KW - IT governance

KW - Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)

KW - shadow IS

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS)

PB - Association for Information Systems

CY - Stockholm, Sweden

ER -

Davison RM, Wong LHM, Alter S, Ou C. Adopted globally but unusable locally: What workarounds reveal about adoption, resistance, compliance and non-compliance. In Proceedings of the 27th European Conference on Information Systems (ECIS). Stockholm, Sweden : Association for Information Systems. 2019. 19