An Evaluation of the nFTK

Lei Shu, Bertrand Melenberg, Hans Schumacher

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

87 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

A new regulatory framework for Dutch pension funds came into force in 2015, replacing the earlier system that had existed since 2007. The revision, known as the new Financial Assessment Framework (abbreviated “nFTK” in Dutch), is meant to resolve some of the weaknesses of the earlier system that became apparent in the wake of the financial crisis. We carry out an analysis of the new framework based on a simulation study, focusing on economic scenarios and leaving aside the possible consequences of unanticipated changes in mortality. We use a stylized pension fund that has the same demographic structure as the Dutch population. The fund follows a fixed-mix investment policy and keeps contributions constant, except when reductions are permitted under the nFTK rules. Economic scenarios are generated by a VAR model. We find that although average funding ratios are high, fully wage-indexed pensions are still achieved in only approximately 60% of the scenarios. Under the worst scenarios, replacement ratios can drop to under 40%.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherNETSPAR
Number of pages48
Publication statusPublished - May 2016

Publication series

NameNetspar Industry Paper
VolumeDesign 57

Fingerprint

Scenarios
Evaluation
Pension funds
Economics
VAR model
Demographic structure
Mortality
Wages
Financial crisis
Investment policy
Funding
Pensions
Simulation study
Regulatory framework
Replacement

Cite this

Shu, L., Melenberg, B., & Schumacher, H. (2016). An Evaluation of the nFTK. (Netspar Industry Paper; Vol. Design 57). Tilburg: NETSPAR.
Shu, Lei ; Melenberg, Bertrand ; Schumacher, Hans. / An Evaluation of the nFTK. Tilburg : NETSPAR, 2016. (Netspar Industry Paper).
@techreport{7b43cdd2227842b7834a1fc499d45ed0,
title = "An Evaluation of the nFTK",
abstract = "A new regulatory framework for Dutch pension funds came into force in 2015, replacing the earlier system that had existed since 2007. The revision, known as the new Financial Assessment Framework (abbreviated “nFTK” in Dutch), is meant to resolve some of the weaknesses of the earlier system that became apparent in the wake of the financial crisis. We carry out an analysis of the new framework based on a simulation study, focusing on economic scenarios and leaving aside the possible consequences of unanticipated changes in mortality. We use a stylized pension fund that has the same demographic structure as the Dutch population. The fund follows a fixed-mix investment policy and keeps contributions constant, except when reductions are permitted under the nFTK rules. Economic scenarios are generated by a VAR model. We find that although average funding ratios are high, fully wage-indexed pensions are still achieved in only approximately 60{\%} of the scenarios. Under the worst scenarios, replacement ratios can drop to under 40{\%}.",
author = "Lei Shu and Bertrand Melenberg and Hans Schumacher",
year = "2016",
month = "5",
language = "English",
series = "Netspar Industry Paper",
publisher = "NETSPAR",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "NETSPAR",

}

Shu, L, Melenberg, B & Schumacher, H 2016 'An Evaluation of the nFTK' Netspar Industry Paper, vol. Design 57, NETSPAR, Tilburg.

An Evaluation of the nFTK. / Shu, Lei; Melenberg, Bertrand; Schumacher, Hans.

Tilburg : NETSPAR, 2016. (Netspar Industry Paper; Vol. Design 57).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - An Evaluation of the nFTK

AU - Shu, Lei

AU - Melenberg, Bertrand

AU - Schumacher, Hans

PY - 2016/5

Y1 - 2016/5

N2 - A new regulatory framework for Dutch pension funds came into force in 2015, replacing the earlier system that had existed since 2007. The revision, known as the new Financial Assessment Framework (abbreviated “nFTK” in Dutch), is meant to resolve some of the weaknesses of the earlier system that became apparent in the wake of the financial crisis. We carry out an analysis of the new framework based on a simulation study, focusing on economic scenarios and leaving aside the possible consequences of unanticipated changes in mortality. We use a stylized pension fund that has the same demographic structure as the Dutch population. The fund follows a fixed-mix investment policy and keeps contributions constant, except when reductions are permitted under the nFTK rules. Economic scenarios are generated by a VAR model. We find that although average funding ratios are high, fully wage-indexed pensions are still achieved in only approximately 60% of the scenarios. Under the worst scenarios, replacement ratios can drop to under 40%.

AB - A new regulatory framework for Dutch pension funds came into force in 2015, replacing the earlier system that had existed since 2007. The revision, known as the new Financial Assessment Framework (abbreviated “nFTK” in Dutch), is meant to resolve some of the weaknesses of the earlier system that became apparent in the wake of the financial crisis. We carry out an analysis of the new framework based on a simulation study, focusing on economic scenarios and leaving aside the possible consequences of unanticipated changes in mortality. We use a stylized pension fund that has the same demographic structure as the Dutch population. The fund follows a fixed-mix investment policy and keeps contributions constant, except when reductions are permitted under the nFTK rules. Economic scenarios are generated by a VAR model. We find that although average funding ratios are high, fully wage-indexed pensions are still achieved in only approximately 60% of the scenarios. Under the worst scenarios, replacement ratios can drop to under 40%.

M3 - Discussion paper

T3 - Netspar Industry Paper

BT - An Evaluation of the nFTK

PB - NETSPAR

CY - Tilburg

ER -

Shu L, Melenberg B, Schumacher H. An Evaluation of the nFTK. Tilburg: NETSPAR. 2016 May. (Netspar Industry Paper).