Are tearful individuals perceived as less competent? Probably not

J. Zickfeld, Niels van de Ven, T.W. Schubert, Ad Vingerhoets

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

What are the social signals of emotional tears? This question has fascinated scholars ever since Darwin. Studies have suggested several interpersonal effects of emotional tears. A recent study by Van de Ven, Meijs, and Vingerhoets (2017) presented evidence in three studies that tearful individuals are perceived as warmer, but also less competent than their non-tearful counterparts. However, the competence effect was relatively small, and a recent replication failed to find such an effect in two different populations while the warmth effect was replicated (Zickfeld & Schubert, 2018).This questions the generalizability of the effect of tears on perceived competence. To test whether individuals expressing emotional tears are really perceived as less competent and what boundary conditions such an effect might have, we specified a decision tree of three different studies in which we test differences between the original reference study and the replication. We replicated previous findings of the perceived (in)competence in Study 1 (n = 531)but observed a considerably smaller non-significant effect when proceeding to Study 2 (n = 471), which increased the number of stimuli. The earlier and now repeated replication failure can therefore likely be attributed to an increased variation in stimulus material. We conclude that there is not enough evidence to argue that one social outcome of tears signals a relative lack of competence as the effect seems to depend on the specific stimuli used.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)119-139
JournalComprehensive Results in Social Psychology
Volume3
Issue number2
Early online dateSep 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

stimulus
evidence
lack

Keywords

  • competence
  • emotional tears
  • stereotype content model

Cite this

Zickfeld, J. ; van de Ven, Niels ; Schubert, T.W. ; Vingerhoets, Ad. / Are tearful individuals perceived as less competent? Probably not. In: Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology. 2018 ; Vol. 3, No. 2. pp. 119-139.
@article{6ef04362323647a6ab5e4e9225e1b1bc,
title = "Are tearful individuals perceived as less competent? Probably not",
abstract = "What are the social signals of emotional tears? This question has fascinated scholars ever since Darwin. Studies have suggested several interpersonal effects of emotional tears. A recent study by Van de Ven, Meijs, and Vingerhoets (2017) presented evidence in three studies that tearful individuals are perceived as warmer, but also less competent than their non-tearful counterparts. However, the competence effect was relatively small, and a recent replication failed to find such an effect in two different populations while the warmth effect was replicated (Zickfeld & Schubert, 2018).This questions the generalizability of the effect of tears on perceived competence. To test whether individuals expressing emotional tears are really perceived as less competent and what boundary conditions such an effect might have, we specified a decision tree of three different studies in which we test differences between the original reference study and the replication. We replicated previous findings of the perceived (in)competence in Study 1 (n = 531)but observed a considerably smaller non-significant effect when proceeding to Study 2 (n = 471), which increased the number of stimuli. The earlier and now repeated replication failure can therefore likely be attributed to an increased variation in stimulus material. We conclude that there is not enough evidence to argue that one social outcome of tears signals a relative lack of competence as the effect seems to depend on the specific stimuli used.",
keywords = "competence, emotional tears, stereotype content model",
author = "J. Zickfeld and {van de Ven}, Niels and T.W. Schubert and Ad Vingerhoets",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.31234/osf.io/asje7",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "119--139",
journal = "Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology",
issn = "2374-3603",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "2",

}

Are tearful individuals perceived as less competent? Probably not. / Zickfeld, J.; van de Ven, Niels; Schubert, T.W.; Vingerhoets, Ad.

In: Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology, Vol. 3, No. 2, 2018, p. 119-139.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Are tearful individuals perceived as less competent? Probably not

AU - Zickfeld, J.

AU - van de Ven, Niels

AU - Schubert, T.W.

AU - Vingerhoets, Ad

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - What are the social signals of emotional tears? This question has fascinated scholars ever since Darwin. Studies have suggested several interpersonal effects of emotional tears. A recent study by Van de Ven, Meijs, and Vingerhoets (2017) presented evidence in three studies that tearful individuals are perceived as warmer, but also less competent than their non-tearful counterparts. However, the competence effect was relatively small, and a recent replication failed to find such an effect in two different populations while the warmth effect was replicated (Zickfeld & Schubert, 2018).This questions the generalizability of the effect of tears on perceived competence. To test whether individuals expressing emotional tears are really perceived as less competent and what boundary conditions such an effect might have, we specified a decision tree of three different studies in which we test differences between the original reference study and the replication. We replicated previous findings of the perceived (in)competence in Study 1 (n = 531)but observed a considerably smaller non-significant effect when proceeding to Study 2 (n = 471), which increased the number of stimuli. The earlier and now repeated replication failure can therefore likely be attributed to an increased variation in stimulus material. We conclude that there is not enough evidence to argue that one social outcome of tears signals a relative lack of competence as the effect seems to depend on the specific stimuli used.

AB - What are the social signals of emotional tears? This question has fascinated scholars ever since Darwin. Studies have suggested several interpersonal effects of emotional tears. A recent study by Van de Ven, Meijs, and Vingerhoets (2017) presented evidence in three studies that tearful individuals are perceived as warmer, but also less competent than their non-tearful counterparts. However, the competence effect was relatively small, and a recent replication failed to find such an effect in two different populations while the warmth effect was replicated (Zickfeld & Schubert, 2018).This questions the generalizability of the effect of tears on perceived competence. To test whether individuals expressing emotional tears are really perceived as less competent and what boundary conditions such an effect might have, we specified a decision tree of three different studies in which we test differences between the original reference study and the replication. We replicated previous findings of the perceived (in)competence in Study 1 (n = 531)but observed a considerably smaller non-significant effect when proceeding to Study 2 (n = 471), which increased the number of stimuli. The earlier and now repeated replication failure can therefore likely be attributed to an increased variation in stimulus material. We conclude that there is not enough evidence to argue that one social outcome of tears signals a relative lack of competence as the effect seems to depend on the specific stimuli used.

KW - competence

KW - emotional tears

KW - stereotype content model

U2 - 10.31234/osf.io/asje7

DO - 10.31234/osf.io/asje7

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 119

EP - 139

JO - Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology

JF - Comprehensive Results in Social Psychology

SN - 2374-3603

IS - 2

ER -