Balancing public values during the energy transition

How can German and Dutch DSOs safeguard sustainability

    Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

    Abstract

    Distribution of electricity constitutes an essential link in the energy sector value chain for which Distribution System Operators (DSOs) bear the responsibility. While executing that role, DSOs are expected to take into consideration public values, such as the availability, affordability and sustainability of the infrastructure they manage.

    The energy transition causes DSOs to deal with increasingly unpredictable flows of locally generated renewable energy, requiring more response options than current legislation provides. This paper uses legal-empirical research (interviews and surveys) to demonstrate that German and Dutch DSOs increasingly struggle with the limited consideration they can give sustainability during the transition towards a smart and renewables-based energy system. DSOs experience an imbalance within the energy public value triangle. Unbalanced public values, as perceived by DSOs, are a symptom of the mismatch between the DSOs’ daily practice, shaped by the challenges of the energy transition, and existing legislation.

    This paper compares European, German, and Dutch (forthcoming) legislation intended to further the energy transition, and analyzes the pros and cons of the various approaches in terms of their impact on the DSOs’ challenges. On that basis, legislative changes are recommended to clarify the role of DSOs, reduce public value tensions for DSOs, and support DSOs in a more balanced overall response to the energy transition.

    • DSOs find it increasingly difficult to balance the public values they are to protect
    • Current German and Dutch legislation leaves limited room for sustainability
    • Legislative changes are recommended to provide DSOs with more response options
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages1-30
    Number of pages30
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2018

    Fingerprint

    Sustainable development
    Electricity
    Availability

    Cite this

    @techreport{6bee5a702c064e8ab139cbfc8e5d0fa4,
    title = "Balancing public values during the energy transition: How can German and Dutch DSOs safeguard sustainability",
    abstract = "Distribution of electricity constitutes an essential link in the energy sector value chain for which Distribution System Operators (DSOs) bear the responsibility. While executing that role, DSOs are expected to take into consideration public values, such as the availability, affordability and sustainability of the infrastructure they manage. The energy transition causes DSOs to deal with increasingly unpredictable flows of locally generated renewable energy, requiring more response options than current legislation provides. This paper uses legal-empirical research (interviews and surveys) to demonstrate that German and Dutch DSOs increasingly struggle with the limited consideration they can give sustainability during the transition towards a smart and renewables-based energy system. DSOs experience an imbalance within the energy public value triangle. Unbalanced public values, as perceived by DSOs, are a symptom of the mismatch between the DSOs’ daily practice, shaped by the challenges of the energy transition, and existing legislation. This paper compares European, German, and Dutch (forthcoming) legislation intended to further the energy transition, and analyzes the pros and cons of the various approaches in terms of their impact on the DSOs’ challenges. On that basis, legislative changes are recommended to clarify the role of DSOs, reduce public value tensions for DSOs, and support DSOs in a more balanced overall response to the energy transition. • DSOs find it increasingly difficult to balance the public values they are to protect• Current German and Dutch legislation leaves limited room for sustainability• Legislative changes are recommended to provide DSOs with more response options",
    author = "Saskia Lavrijssen and Marga Edens",
    note = "TILEC Discussion Paper No. 2018-015. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3179372",
    year = "2018",
    month = "5",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.2139/ssrn.3179372",
    language = "English",
    pages = "1--30",
    type = "WorkingPaper",

    }

    Balancing public values during the energy transition : How can German and Dutch DSOs safeguard sustainability. / Lavrijssen, Saskia; Edens, Marga.

    2018. p. 1-30.

    Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

    TY - UNPB

    T1 - Balancing public values during the energy transition

    T2 - How can German and Dutch DSOs safeguard sustainability

    AU - Lavrijssen, Saskia

    AU - Edens, Marga

    N1 - TILEC Discussion Paper No. 2018-015. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3179372

    PY - 2018/5/1

    Y1 - 2018/5/1

    N2 - Distribution of electricity constitutes an essential link in the energy sector value chain for which Distribution System Operators (DSOs) bear the responsibility. While executing that role, DSOs are expected to take into consideration public values, such as the availability, affordability and sustainability of the infrastructure they manage. The energy transition causes DSOs to deal with increasingly unpredictable flows of locally generated renewable energy, requiring more response options than current legislation provides. This paper uses legal-empirical research (interviews and surveys) to demonstrate that German and Dutch DSOs increasingly struggle with the limited consideration they can give sustainability during the transition towards a smart and renewables-based energy system. DSOs experience an imbalance within the energy public value triangle. Unbalanced public values, as perceived by DSOs, are a symptom of the mismatch between the DSOs’ daily practice, shaped by the challenges of the energy transition, and existing legislation. This paper compares European, German, and Dutch (forthcoming) legislation intended to further the energy transition, and analyzes the pros and cons of the various approaches in terms of their impact on the DSOs’ challenges. On that basis, legislative changes are recommended to clarify the role of DSOs, reduce public value tensions for DSOs, and support DSOs in a more balanced overall response to the energy transition. • DSOs find it increasingly difficult to balance the public values they are to protect• Current German and Dutch legislation leaves limited room for sustainability• Legislative changes are recommended to provide DSOs with more response options

    AB - Distribution of electricity constitutes an essential link in the energy sector value chain for which Distribution System Operators (DSOs) bear the responsibility. While executing that role, DSOs are expected to take into consideration public values, such as the availability, affordability and sustainability of the infrastructure they manage. The energy transition causes DSOs to deal with increasingly unpredictable flows of locally generated renewable energy, requiring more response options than current legislation provides. This paper uses legal-empirical research (interviews and surveys) to demonstrate that German and Dutch DSOs increasingly struggle with the limited consideration they can give sustainability during the transition towards a smart and renewables-based energy system. DSOs experience an imbalance within the energy public value triangle. Unbalanced public values, as perceived by DSOs, are a symptom of the mismatch between the DSOs’ daily practice, shaped by the challenges of the energy transition, and existing legislation. This paper compares European, German, and Dutch (forthcoming) legislation intended to further the energy transition, and analyzes the pros and cons of the various approaches in terms of their impact on the DSOs’ challenges. On that basis, legislative changes are recommended to clarify the role of DSOs, reduce public value tensions for DSOs, and support DSOs in a more balanced overall response to the energy transition. • DSOs find it increasingly difficult to balance the public values they are to protect• Current German and Dutch legislation leaves limited room for sustainability• Legislative changes are recommended to provide DSOs with more response options

    UR - https://ssrn.com/abstract=3179372

    U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.3179372

    DO - 10.2139/ssrn.3179372

    M3 - Discussion paper

    SP - 1

    EP - 30

    BT - Balancing public values during the energy transition

    ER -