TY - JOUR
T1 - Comparative cultures of accountability
T2 - The Scottish Exchequer and the Audit Chamber of Holland between 1477 and 1515
AU - den Hollander, Maurits
PY - 2018/12
Y1 - 2018/12
N2 - This comparative paper describes the spread of a new culture of probatory accountability in North-Western Europe through the study of the Scottish Exchequer and the Audit Chamber of Holland between 1477 and 1515. It allows to re-evaluate persisting views of an inefficient and archaic Scottish Exchequer, as opposed to the ‘Weberian ideal’ of the Burgundian bureaucracy. Both institutions primarily had a fiscal goal, the auditing of accounts, while archival and judicial tasks supported this process. Through a study of the format of important series of these accounts as well as their marginalia, it has been revealed that by 1515 the daily practices surrounding the auditing process in Scotland and Holland showed important similarities. These cases serve to portray that through the auditors’ work, a new written culture of accountability spread among all governmental officials in either Scotland or Holland.
AB - This comparative paper describes the spread of a new culture of probatory accountability in North-Western Europe through the study of the Scottish Exchequer and the Audit Chamber of Holland between 1477 and 1515. It allows to re-evaluate persisting views of an inefficient and archaic Scottish Exchequer, as opposed to the ‘Weberian ideal’ of the Burgundian bureaucracy. Both institutions primarily had a fiscal goal, the auditing of accounts, while archival and judicial tasks supported this process. Through a study of the format of important series of these accounts as well as their marginalia, it has been revealed that by 1515 the daily practices surrounding the auditing process in Scotland and Holland showed important similarities. These cases serve to portray that through the auditors’ work, a new written culture of accountability spread among all governmental officials in either Scotland or Holland.
U2 - 10.1080/2049677X.2018.1534778
DO - 10.1080/2049677X.2018.1534778
M3 - Article
SN - 2049-677X
VL - 6
SP - 158
EP - 183
JO - Comparative Legal History
JF - Comparative Legal History
IS - 2
ER -