Considered Judgements: Meaning, Community and Tradition

A.H. Vedder

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientific

112 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The method of reflective equilibrium (RE) and, subsequently, the method of wide reflective equilibrium (WRE) has been advocated as a device for theory acceptance in ethics, for the justification of moral beliefs and for testing the adequacy of conceptions of morality and of moral conceptions, respectively. In this article the role played by considered judgements or intuitions in (W)RE when applied to questions of conceptualisation is addressed. These judgements are mostly thought not to introduce a kind of objective normative basis to (W)RE. Furthermore, the alleged anti-foundationalist character of the method is often viewed as a virtue of the method. In this article, the author explains why it should rather be looked upon as a vice, at least when dealing with the application of (W)RE to questions of conceptualization. The author proposes to relate (W)RE to a view or theory of moral language and morality, which he provisionally calls a 'functional-contextual approach'. Connected to such an approach, (W)RE would be vested with an additional justificatory force. This would enhance its possibilities to be defended against allegations concerning its subjectivist taint. Persons named: Rawls, Daniels, Wittgenstein, Kovesi.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationReflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger
EditorsW. van der Burg, T. van Willigenburg
Place of PublicationDordrecht, Boston, London
PublisherKluwer Academic Publishers
Pages55-72
Number of pages18
ISBN (Print)0792353048
Publication statusPublished - 1998

Fingerprint

Reflective Equilibrium
Conception
Morality
Conceptualization
Contextual
Foundationalist
Wide Reflective Equilibrium
Acceptance
Justification
Ludwig Wittgenstein
Person
Adequacy
Testing
Subjectivist
Intuition
Language

Cite this

Vedder, A. H. (1998). Considered Judgements: Meaning, Community and Tradition. In W. van der Burg, & T. van Willigenburg (Eds.), Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger (pp. 55-72). Dordrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Vedder, A.H. / Considered Judgements : Meaning, Community and Tradition. Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger. editor / W. van der Burg ; T. van Willigenburg. Dordrecht, Boston, London : Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1998. pp. 55-72
@inbook{d2b8d4dd3a1a41358404c466d182d927,
title = "Considered Judgements: Meaning, Community and Tradition",
abstract = "The method of reflective equilibrium (RE) and, subsequently, the method of wide reflective equilibrium (WRE) has been advocated as a device for theory acceptance in ethics, for the justification of moral beliefs and for testing the adequacy of conceptions of morality and of moral conceptions, respectively. In this article the role played by considered judgements or intuitions in (W)RE when applied to questions of conceptualisation is addressed. These judgements are mostly thought not to introduce a kind of objective normative basis to (W)RE. Furthermore, the alleged anti-foundationalist character of the method is often viewed as a virtue of the method. In this article, the author explains why it should rather be looked upon as a vice, at least when dealing with the application of (W)RE to questions of conceptualization. The author proposes to relate (W)RE to a view or theory of moral language and morality, which he provisionally calls a 'functional-contextual approach'. Connected to such an approach, (W)RE would be vested with an additional justificatory force. This would enhance its possibilities to be defended against allegations concerning its subjectivist taint. Persons named: Rawls, Daniels, Wittgenstein, Kovesi.",
author = "A.H. Vedder",
note = "Pagination: 18",
year = "1998",
language = "English",
isbn = "0792353048",
pages = "55--72",
editor = "{van der Burg}, W. and {van Willigenburg}, T.",
booktitle = "Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger",
publisher = "Kluwer Academic Publishers",
address = "Netherlands",

}

Vedder, AH 1998, Considered Judgements: Meaning, Community and Tradition. in W van der Burg & T van Willigenburg (eds), Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger. Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, Boston, London, pp. 55-72.

Considered Judgements : Meaning, Community and Tradition. / Vedder, A.H.

Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger. ed. / W. van der Burg; T. van Willigenburg. Dordrecht, Boston, London : Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1998. p. 55-72.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientific

TY - CHAP

T1 - Considered Judgements

T2 - Meaning, Community and Tradition

AU - Vedder, A.H.

N1 - Pagination: 18

PY - 1998

Y1 - 1998

N2 - The method of reflective equilibrium (RE) and, subsequently, the method of wide reflective equilibrium (WRE) has been advocated as a device for theory acceptance in ethics, for the justification of moral beliefs and for testing the adequacy of conceptions of morality and of moral conceptions, respectively. In this article the role played by considered judgements or intuitions in (W)RE when applied to questions of conceptualisation is addressed. These judgements are mostly thought not to introduce a kind of objective normative basis to (W)RE. Furthermore, the alleged anti-foundationalist character of the method is often viewed as a virtue of the method. In this article, the author explains why it should rather be looked upon as a vice, at least when dealing with the application of (W)RE to questions of conceptualization. The author proposes to relate (W)RE to a view or theory of moral language and morality, which he provisionally calls a 'functional-contextual approach'. Connected to such an approach, (W)RE would be vested with an additional justificatory force. This would enhance its possibilities to be defended against allegations concerning its subjectivist taint. Persons named: Rawls, Daniels, Wittgenstein, Kovesi.

AB - The method of reflective equilibrium (RE) and, subsequently, the method of wide reflective equilibrium (WRE) has been advocated as a device for theory acceptance in ethics, for the justification of moral beliefs and for testing the adequacy of conceptions of morality and of moral conceptions, respectively. In this article the role played by considered judgements or intuitions in (W)RE when applied to questions of conceptualisation is addressed. These judgements are mostly thought not to introduce a kind of objective normative basis to (W)RE. Furthermore, the alleged anti-foundationalist character of the method is often viewed as a virtue of the method. In this article, the author explains why it should rather be looked upon as a vice, at least when dealing with the application of (W)RE to questions of conceptualization. The author proposes to relate (W)RE to a view or theory of moral language and morality, which he provisionally calls a 'functional-contextual approach'. Connected to such an approach, (W)RE would be vested with an additional justificatory force. This would enhance its possibilities to be defended against allegations concerning its subjectivist taint. Persons named: Rawls, Daniels, Wittgenstein, Kovesi.

M3 - Chapter

SN - 0792353048

SP - 55

EP - 72

BT - Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger

A2 - van der Burg, W.

A2 - van Willigenburg, T.

PB - Kluwer Academic Publishers

CY - Dordrecht, Boston, London

ER -

Vedder AH. Considered Judgements: Meaning, Community and Tradition. In van der Burg W, van Willigenburg T, editors, Reflective equilibrium. Essays in Honour of Robert Heeger. Dordrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer Academic Publishers. 1998. p. 55-72