Costs and benefits of automatization in category learning of ill-defined rules

Maartje E. J. Raijmakers, Verena D. Schmittmann, Ingmar Visser

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Learning ill-defined categories (such as the structure of Medin & Schaffer, 1978) involves multiple learning systems and different corresponding category representations, which are difficult to detect. Application of latent Markov analysis allows detection and investigation of such multiple latent category representations in a statistically robust way, isolating low performers and quantifying shifts between latent strategies. We reanalyzed data from three experiments presented in Johansen and Palmeri (2002), which comprised prolonged training of ill-defined categories, with the aim of studying the changing interactions between underlying learning systems. Our results broadly confirm the original conclusion that, in most participants, learning involved a shift from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy. Separate analyses of latent strategies revealed that (a) shifts from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy resulted in an initial decrease of speed and an increase of accuracy; (b) exemplar-based strategies followed a power law of learning, indicating automatization once an exemplar-based strategy was used; (c) rule-based strategies changed from using pure rules to rules-plus-exceptions, which appeared as a dual processes as indicated by the accuracy and response-time profiles. Results suggest an additional pathway of learning ill-defined categories, namely involving a shift from a simple rule to a complex rule after which this complex rule is automatized as an exemplar-based strategy. Keywords: Category learning, Latent Markov analysis, Representational shifts, Strategies, Automaticity, Individual differences, Exemplar-based learning, Rule-based learning, Ill-defined categories
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-24
JournalApplied Cognitive Psychology
Volume69
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Keywords

  • Category learning
  • Latent Markov analysis
  • Representational shifts
  • Strategies
  • Automaticity
  • Individual differences
  • Exemplar-based learning
  • Rule-based learning
  • Ill-defined categories

Cite this

Raijmakers, Maartje E. J. ; Schmittmann, Verena D. ; Visser, Ingmar. / Costs and benefits of automatization in category learning of ill-defined rules. In: Applied Cognitive Psychology. 2014 ; Vol. 69. pp. 1-24.
@article{f1c32ef914844ed391f6feabf1aa9bc0,
title = "Costs and benefits of automatization in category learning of ill-defined rules",
abstract = "Learning ill-defined categories (such as the structure of Medin & Schaffer, 1978) involves multiple learning systems and different corresponding category representations, which are difficult to detect. Application of latent Markov analysis allows detection and investigation of such multiple latent category representations in a statistically robust way, isolating low performers and quantifying shifts between latent strategies. We reanalyzed data from three experiments presented in Johansen and Palmeri (2002), which comprised prolonged training of ill-defined categories, with the aim of studying the changing interactions between underlying learning systems. Our results broadly confirm the original conclusion that, in most participants, learning involved a shift from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy. Separate analyses of latent strategies revealed that (a) shifts from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy resulted in an initial decrease of speed and an increase of accuracy; (b) exemplar-based strategies followed a power law of learning, indicating automatization once an exemplar-based strategy was used; (c) rule-based strategies changed from using pure rules to rules-plus-exceptions, which appeared as a dual processes as indicated by the accuracy and response-time profiles. Results suggest an additional pathway of learning ill-defined categories, namely involving a shift from a simple rule to a complex rule after which this complex rule is automatized as an exemplar-based strategy. Keywords: Category learning, Latent Markov analysis, Representational shifts, Strategies, Automaticity, Individual differences, Exemplar-based learning, Rule-based learning, Ill-defined categories",
keywords = "Category learning, Latent Markov analysis, Representational shifts, Strategies, Automaticity, Individual differences, Exemplar-based learning, Rule-based learning, Ill-defined categories",
author = "Raijmakers, {Maartje E. J.} and Schmittmann, {Verena D.} and Ingmar Visser",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1016/j.cogpsych.2013.12.002",
language = "English",
volume = "69",
pages = "1--24",
journal = "Applied Cognitive Psychology",
issn = "0888-4080",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

Costs and benefits of automatization in category learning of ill-defined rules. / Raijmakers, Maartje E. J.; Schmittmann, Verena D.; Visser, Ingmar.

In: Applied Cognitive Psychology, Vol. 69, 2014, p. 1-24.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Costs and benefits of automatization in category learning of ill-defined rules

AU - Raijmakers, Maartje E. J.

AU - Schmittmann, Verena D.

AU - Visser, Ingmar

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Learning ill-defined categories (such as the structure of Medin & Schaffer, 1978) involves multiple learning systems and different corresponding category representations, which are difficult to detect. Application of latent Markov analysis allows detection and investigation of such multiple latent category representations in a statistically robust way, isolating low performers and quantifying shifts between latent strategies. We reanalyzed data from three experiments presented in Johansen and Palmeri (2002), which comprised prolonged training of ill-defined categories, with the aim of studying the changing interactions between underlying learning systems. Our results broadly confirm the original conclusion that, in most participants, learning involved a shift from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy. Separate analyses of latent strategies revealed that (a) shifts from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy resulted in an initial decrease of speed and an increase of accuracy; (b) exemplar-based strategies followed a power law of learning, indicating automatization once an exemplar-based strategy was used; (c) rule-based strategies changed from using pure rules to rules-plus-exceptions, which appeared as a dual processes as indicated by the accuracy and response-time profiles. Results suggest an additional pathway of learning ill-defined categories, namely involving a shift from a simple rule to a complex rule after which this complex rule is automatized as an exemplar-based strategy. Keywords: Category learning, Latent Markov analysis, Representational shifts, Strategies, Automaticity, Individual differences, Exemplar-based learning, Rule-based learning, Ill-defined categories

AB - Learning ill-defined categories (such as the structure of Medin & Schaffer, 1978) involves multiple learning systems and different corresponding category representations, which are difficult to detect. Application of latent Markov analysis allows detection and investigation of such multiple latent category representations in a statistically robust way, isolating low performers and quantifying shifts between latent strategies. We reanalyzed data from three experiments presented in Johansen and Palmeri (2002), which comprised prolonged training of ill-defined categories, with the aim of studying the changing interactions between underlying learning systems. Our results broadly confirm the original conclusion that, in most participants, learning involved a shift from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy. Separate analyses of latent strategies revealed that (a) shifts from a rule-based to an exemplar-based strategy resulted in an initial decrease of speed and an increase of accuracy; (b) exemplar-based strategies followed a power law of learning, indicating automatization once an exemplar-based strategy was used; (c) rule-based strategies changed from using pure rules to rules-plus-exceptions, which appeared as a dual processes as indicated by the accuracy and response-time profiles. Results suggest an additional pathway of learning ill-defined categories, namely involving a shift from a simple rule to a complex rule after which this complex rule is automatized as an exemplar-based strategy. Keywords: Category learning, Latent Markov analysis, Representational shifts, Strategies, Automaticity, Individual differences, Exemplar-based learning, Rule-based learning, Ill-defined categories

KW - Category learning

KW - Latent Markov analysis

KW - Representational shifts

KW - Strategies

KW - Automaticity

KW - Individual differences

KW - Exemplar-based learning

KW - Rule-based learning

KW - Ill-defined categories

U2 - 10.1016/j.cogpsych.2013.12.002

DO - 10.1016/j.cogpsych.2013.12.002

M3 - Article

VL - 69

SP - 1

EP - 24

JO - Applied Cognitive Psychology

JF - Applied Cognitive Psychology

SN - 0888-4080

ER -