Effects of cognitive design principles on user’s performance and preference

A large scale evaluation of a soccer stats display

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

We present an analytic and a large scale experimental comparison of two informationally equivalent information displays of soccer statistics. Both displays were presented by the BBC during the 2010 FIFA World Cup. The displays mainly differ in terms of the number and types of cognitively natural mappings between visual variables and meaning. Theoretically, such natural form-meaning mappings help users to interpret the information quickly and easily. However, our analysis indicates that the design which contains most of these mappings is inevitably inconsistent in how forms and meanings are mapped to each other. The experiment shows that this inconsistency was detrimental for how fast people can find information in the display and for which display people prefer to use. Our findings shed new light on the well-established cognitive design principle of natural mapping: while in theory, information designs may benefit from natural mapping, in practice its applicability may be limited. Information designs that contain a
high number of form-meaning mappings, for example, for aesthetic reasons, risk being inconsistent and too complex for users, leading them to find information less quickly and less easily.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)129-145
Number of pages17
JournalInformation Design Journal
Volume21
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

soccer
evaluation
performance
information theory
BBC
aesthetics
statistics
experiment

Keywords

  • efficiency
  • information design
  • natural mapping
  • preference
  • visual variables

Cite this

@article{d32f0955f1254380a51c8dec4480c851,
title = "Effects of cognitive design principles on user’s performance and preference: A large scale evaluation of a soccer stats display",
abstract = "We present an analytic and a large scale experimental comparison of two informationally equivalent information displays of soccer statistics. Both displays were presented by the BBC during the 2010 FIFA World Cup. The displays mainly differ in terms of the number and types of cognitively natural mappings between visual variables and meaning. Theoretically, such natural form-meaning mappings help users to interpret the information quickly and easily. However, our analysis indicates that the design which contains most of these mappings is inevitably inconsistent in how forms and meanings are mapped to each other. The experiment shows that this inconsistency was detrimental for how fast people can find information in the display and for which display people prefer to use. Our findings shed new light on the well-established cognitive design principle of natural mapping: while in theory, information designs may benefit from natural mapping, in practice its applicability may be limited. Information designs that contain ahigh number of form-meaning mappings, for example, for aesthetic reasons, risk being inconsistent and too complex for users, leading them to find information less quickly and less easily.",
keywords = "efficiency, information design, natural mapping, preference, visual variables",
author = "Hans Westerbeek and {van Amelsvoort}, Marije and Fons Maes and Marc Swerts",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1075/idj.21.2.05wes",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "129--145",
journal = "Information Design Journal",
issn = "0142-5471",
publisher = "John Benjamins Publishing Company",
number = "2",

}

Effects of cognitive design principles on user’s performance and preference : A large scale evaluation of a soccer stats display. / Westerbeek, Hans; van Amelsvoort, Marije; Maes, Fons; Swerts, Marc.

In: Information Design Journal, Vol. 21, No. 2, 2014, p. 129-145.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effects of cognitive design principles on user’s performance and preference

T2 - A large scale evaluation of a soccer stats display

AU - Westerbeek, Hans

AU - van Amelsvoort, Marije

AU - Maes, Fons

AU - Swerts, Marc

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - We present an analytic and a large scale experimental comparison of two informationally equivalent information displays of soccer statistics. Both displays were presented by the BBC during the 2010 FIFA World Cup. The displays mainly differ in terms of the number and types of cognitively natural mappings between visual variables and meaning. Theoretically, such natural form-meaning mappings help users to interpret the information quickly and easily. However, our analysis indicates that the design which contains most of these mappings is inevitably inconsistent in how forms and meanings are mapped to each other. The experiment shows that this inconsistency was detrimental for how fast people can find information in the display and for which display people prefer to use. Our findings shed new light on the well-established cognitive design principle of natural mapping: while in theory, information designs may benefit from natural mapping, in practice its applicability may be limited. Information designs that contain ahigh number of form-meaning mappings, for example, for aesthetic reasons, risk being inconsistent and too complex for users, leading them to find information less quickly and less easily.

AB - We present an analytic and a large scale experimental comparison of two informationally equivalent information displays of soccer statistics. Both displays were presented by the BBC during the 2010 FIFA World Cup. The displays mainly differ in terms of the number and types of cognitively natural mappings between visual variables and meaning. Theoretically, such natural form-meaning mappings help users to interpret the information quickly and easily. However, our analysis indicates that the design which contains most of these mappings is inevitably inconsistent in how forms and meanings are mapped to each other. The experiment shows that this inconsistency was detrimental for how fast people can find information in the display and for which display people prefer to use. Our findings shed new light on the well-established cognitive design principle of natural mapping: while in theory, information designs may benefit from natural mapping, in practice its applicability may be limited. Information designs that contain ahigh number of form-meaning mappings, for example, for aesthetic reasons, risk being inconsistent and too complex for users, leading them to find information less quickly and less easily.

KW - efficiency

KW - information design

KW - natural mapping

KW - preference

KW - visual variables

U2 - 10.1075/idj.21.2.05wes

DO - 10.1075/idj.21.2.05wes

M3 - Article

VL - 21

SP - 129

EP - 145

JO - Information Design Journal

JF - Information Design Journal

SN - 0142-5471

IS - 2

ER -