Efficiency and equity in private and public education: A nonparametric comparison

L.J.H. Cherchye, K. de Witte, E. Ooghe, I. Nicaise

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

We present a nonparametric approach for (1) efficiency and (2) equity evaluation in education. Firstly, we use a nonparametric (Data Envelopment Analysis) model that is specially tailored to assess educational efficiency at the pupil level. The model accounts for the fact that typically minimal prior structure is available for the behavior (objectives and feasibility set) under evaluation. It allows for uncertainty in the data, while it corrects for exogenous ‘environmental’ characteristics that are specific to each pupil. Secondly, we propose two multidimensional stochastic dominance criteria as naturally complementary aggregation criteria for comparing the performance of different school types (private and public schools). While the first criterion only accounts for efficiency, the second criterion also takes equity into consideration. The model is applied for comparing private (but publicly funded) and public primary schools in Flanders. Our application finds that no school type robustly dominates another type when controlling for the school environment and taking equity into account. More generally, it demonstrates the usefulness of our nonparametric approach, which includes environmental and equity considerations, for obtaining ‘fair’ performance comparisons in the public sector context.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)563-573
JournalEuropean Journal of Operational Research
Volume202
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

Equity
Education
Data envelopment analysis
Stochastic Dominance
Public Sector
Evaluation
Performance Comparison
Data Envelopment Analysis
Agglomeration
Aggregation
Model
Uncertainty
Private education
Public education
Demonstrate

Cite this

@article{2cd23d0b34d9474a92ec17e91005088e,
title = "Efficiency and equity in private and public education: A nonparametric comparison",
abstract = "We present a nonparametric approach for (1) efficiency and (2) equity evaluation in education. Firstly, we use a nonparametric (Data Envelopment Analysis) model that is specially tailored to assess educational efficiency at the pupil level. The model accounts for the fact that typically minimal prior structure is available for the behavior (objectives and feasibility set) under evaluation. It allows for uncertainty in the data, while it corrects for exogenous ‘environmental’ characteristics that are specific to each pupil. Secondly, we propose two multidimensional stochastic dominance criteria as naturally complementary aggregation criteria for comparing the performance of different school types (private and public schools). While the first criterion only accounts for efficiency, the second criterion also takes equity into consideration. The model is applied for comparing private (but publicly funded) and public primary schools in Flanders. Our application finds that no school type robustly dominates another type when controlling for the school environment and taking equity into account. More generally, it demonstrates the usefulness of our nonparametric approach, which includes environmental and equity considerations, for obtaining ‘fair’ performance comparisons in the public sector context.",
author = "L.J.H. Cherchye and {de Witte}, K. and E. Ooghe and I. Nicaise",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
volume = "202",
pages = "563--573",
journal = "European Journal of Operational Research",
issn = "0377-2217",
publisher = "Elsevier Science BV",
number = "2",

}

Efficiency and equity in private and public education : A nonparametric comparison. / Cherchye, L.J.H.; de Witte, K.; Ooghe, E.; Nicaise, I.

In: European Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 202, No. 2, 2010, p. 563-573.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Efficiency and equity in private and public education

T2 - A nonparametric comparison

AU - Cherchye, L.J.H.

AU - de Witte, K.

AU - Ooghe, E.

AU - Nicaise, I.

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - We present a nonparametric approach for (1) efficiency and (2) equity evaluation in education. Firstly, we use a nonparametric (Data Envelopment Analysis) model that is specially tailored to assess educational efficiency at the pupil level. The model accounts for the fact that typically minimal prior structure is available for the behavior (objectives and feasibility set) under evaluation. It allows for uncertainty in the data, while it corrects for exogenous ‘environmental’ characteristics that are specific to each pupil. Secondly, we propose two multidimensional stochastic dominance criteria as naturally complementary aggregation criteria for comparing the performance of different school types (private and public schools). While the first criterion only accounts for efficiency, the second criterion also takes equity into consideration. The model is applied for comparing private (but publicly funded) and public primary schools in Flanders. Our application finds that no school type robustly dominates another type when controlling for the school environment and taking equity into account. More generally, it demonstrates the usefulness of our nonparametric approach, which includes environmental and equity considerations, for obtaining ‘fair’ performance comparisons in the public sector context.

AB - We present a nonparametric approach for (1) efficiency and (2) equity evaluation in education. Firstly, we use a nonparametric (Data Envelopment Analysis) model that is specially tailored to assess educational efficiency at the pupil level. The model accounts for the fact that typically minimal prior structure is available for the behavior (objectives and feasibility set) under evaluation. It allows for uncertainty in the data, while it corrects for exogenous ‘environmental’ characteristics that are specific to each pupil. Secondly, we propose two multidimensional stochastic dominance criteria as naturally complementary aggregation criteria for comparing the performance of different school types (private and public schools). While the first criterion only accounts for efficiency, the second criterion also takes equity into consideration. The model is applied for comparing private (but publicly funded) and public primary schools in Flanders. Our application finds that no school type robustly dominates another type when controlling for the school environment and taking equity into account. More generally, it demonstrates the usefulness of our nonparametric approach, which includes environmental and equity considerations, for obtaining ‘fair’ performance comparisons in the public sector context.

M3 - Article

VL - 202

SP - 563

EP - 573

JO - European Journal of Operational Research

JF - European Journal of Operational Research

SN - 0377-2217

IS - 2

ER -