Ethical issues in engineering models: An operations researcher's reflections

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

335 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This article starts with an overview of the author’s personal involvement—as an Operations Research consultant—in several engineering case-studies that may raise ethical questions; e.g., case-studies on nuclear waste, water management, sustainable ecology, military tactics, and animal welfare. All these case studies employ computer simulation models. In general, models are meant to solve practical problems, which may have ethical implications for the various stakeholders; namely, the modelers, the clients, and the public at large. The article further presents an overview of codes of ethics in a variety of disciples. It discusses the role of mathematical models, focusing on the validation of these models’ assumptions. Documentation of these model assumptions needs special attention. Some ethical norms and values may be quantified through the model’s multiple performance measures, which might be optimized. The uncertainty about the validity of the model leads to risk or uncertainty analysis and to a search for robust models. Ethical questions may be pressing in military models, including war games. However, computer games and the related experimental economics may also provide a special tool to study ethical issues. Finally, the article briefly discusses whistleblowing. Its many references to publications and websites enable further study of ethical issues in modeling.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)539-552
JournalScience and Engineering Ethics
Volume17
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Fingerprint

Ethics
Computer Simulation
Whistleblowing
engineering
Video Games
Ecology
Documentation
Theoretical Models
Military
uncertainty
Operations research
Computer games
operations research
Uncertainty analysis
Ethical issues
Water management
Risk analysis
computer game
Radioactive wastes
computer simulation

Cite this

@article{88caba9e1d7847d79a0bb80b8e5a4814,
title = "Ethical issues in engineering models: An operations researcher's reflections",
abstract = "This article starts with an overview of the author’s personal involvement—as an Operations Research consultant—in several engineering case-studies that may raise ethical questions; e.g., case-studies on nuclear waste, water management, sustainable ecology, military tactics, and animal welfare. All these case studies employ computer simulation models. In general, models are meant to solve practical problems, which may have ethical implications for the various stakeholders; namely, the modelers, the clients, and the public at large. The article further presents an overview of codes of ethics in a variety of disciples. It discusses the role of mathematical models, focusing on the validation of these models’ assumptions. Documentation of these model assumptions needs special attention. Some ethical norms and values may be quantified through the model’s multiple performance measures, which might be optimized. The uncertainty about the validity of the model leads to risk or uncertainty analysis and to a search for robust models. Ethical questions may be pressing in military models, including war games. However, computer games and the related experimental economics may also provide a special tool to study ethical issues. Finally, the article briefly discusses whistleblowing. Its many references to publications and websites enable further study of ethical issues in modeling.",
author = "Kleijnen, {Jack P.C.}",
note = "Appeared earlier as CentER DP 2010-09 (rt)",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.1007/s11948-010-9215-5",
language = "English",
volume = "17",
pages = "539--552",
journal = "Science and Engineering Ethics",
issn = "1353-3452",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "3",

}

Ethical issues in engineering models : An operations researcher's reflections. / Kleijnen, Jack P.C.

In: Science and Engineering Ethics, Vol. 17, No. 3, 2011, p. 539-552.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ethical issues in engineering models

T2 - An operations researcher's reflections

AU - Kleijnen, Jack P.C.

N1 - Appeared earlier as CentER DP 2010-09 (rt)

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - This article starts with an overview of the author’s personal involvement—as an Operations Research consultant—in several engineering case-studies that may raise ethical questions; e.g., case-studies on nuclear waste, water management, sustainable ecology, military tactics, and animal welfare. All these case studies employ computer simulation models. In general, models are meant to solve practical problems, which may have ethical implications for the various stakeholders; namely, the modelers, the clients, and the public at large. The article further presents an overview of codes of ethics in a variety of disciples. It discusses the role of mathematical models, focusing on the validation of these models’ assumptions. Documentation of these model assumptions needs special attention. Some ethical norms and values may be quantified through the model’s multiple performance measures, which might be optimized. The uncertainty about the validity of the model leads to risk or uncertainty analysis and to a search for robust models. Ethical questions may be pressing in military models, including war games. However, computer games and the related experimental economics may also provide a special tool to study ethical issues. Finally, the article briefly discusses whistleblowing. Its many references to publications and websites enable further study of ethical issues in modeling.

AB - This article starts with an overview of the author’s personal involvement—as an Operations Research consultant—in several engineering case-studies that may raise ethical questions; e.g., case-studies on nuclear waste, water management, sustainable ecology, military tactics, and animal welfare. All these case studies employ computer simulation models. In general, models are meant to solve practical problems, which may have ethical implications for the various stakeholders; namely, the modelers, the clients, and the public at large. The article further presents an overview of codes of ethics in a variety of disciples. It discusses the role of mathematical models, focusing on the validation of these models’ assumptions. Documentation of these model assumptions needs special attention. Some ethical norms and values may be quantified through the model’s multiple performance measures, which might be optimized. The uncertainty about the validity of the model leads to risk or uncertainty analysis and to a search for robust models. Ethical questions may be pressing in military models, including war games. However, computer games and the related experimental economics may also provide a special tool to study ethical issues. Finally, the article briefly discusses whistleblowing. Its many references to publications and websites enable further study of ethical issues in modeling.

U2 - 10.1007/s11948-010-9215-5

DO - 10.1007/s11948-010-9215-5

M3 - Article

VL - 17

SP - 539

EP - 552

JO - Science and Engineering Ethics

JF - Science and Engineering Ethics

SN - 1353-3452

IS - 3

ER -