Explaining human altruism

Michael Vlerick*

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Humans often behave altruistically towards strangers with no chance of reciprocation. From an evolutionary perspective, this is puzzling. The evolution of altruistic cooperative behavior-in which an organism's action reduces its fitness and increases the fitness of another organism (e.g. by sharing food)-only makes sense when it is directed at genetically related organisms (kin selection) or when one can expect the favor to be returned (reciprocal altruism). Therefore, evolutionary theorists such as Sober and Wilson have argued that we should revise Neo-Darwininian evolutionary theory. They argue that human altruism evolved through group selection in which groups of altruists were naturally selected because they had a comparative advantage over other groups. Wilson and Sober's hypothesis attracted followers but is rejected by most of their peers. The heated debate between advocates and critics of group selection often suffers from a lack of conceptual clarity. In response, I set out to clearly distinguish 'genetic' from 'cultural' group selection (developed by Boyd, Richerson & Henrich) and argue that the latter does not face the potentially debilitating problems plaguing the former. I defend the claim that human altruistic dispositions evolved through cultural group selection and gene-culture coevolution and offer empirical evidence in support. I also argue that actual altruistic behavior often goes beyond the kind of behavior humans have evolved to display. Conscious and voluntary reasoning processes, I show, have an important role in altruistic behavior. This is often overlooked in the scientific literature on human altruism.

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages19
JournalSynthese
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 5 Oct 2020

Keywords

  • Human altruism
  • Behavioral game-theory
  • Group selection
  • Genetic group selection
  • Cultural group selection
  • Moral reasoning
  • STRONG RECIPROCITY
  • HUMAN COOPERATION
  • GROUP SELECTION
  • EVOLUTION
  • BEHAVIOR
  • ENFORCEMENT
  • PUNISHMENT
  • SOCIETIES
  • SEMANTICS
  • CULTURE

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Explaining human altruism'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this