Extending literary darwinism: Culture and alternatives to adaptation

J. Verpooten

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Literary Darwinism is an emerging interdisciplinary research field that seeks to explain literature and its oral antecedents (“literary behaviors”), from a Darwinian perspective. Considered the fact that an evolutionary approach to human behavior has proven insightful, this is a promising endeavor. However, Literary Darwinism as it is commonly practiced, I argue, suffers from some shortcomings. First, while literary Darwinists only weigh adaptation against by-product as competing explanations of literary behaviors, other alternatives, such as constraint and exaptation, should be considered as well. I attempt to demonstrate their relevance by evaluating the evidentiary criteria commonly employed by Literary Darwinists. Second, Literary Darwinists usually acknowledge the role of culture in human behavior and make references to Dual Inheritance theory (i.e., the body of empirical and theoretical work demonstrating that human behavior is the outcome of both genetic and cultural inheritance). However, they often do not fully appreciate the explanatory implications of dual inheritance. Literary Darwinism should be extended to include these recent refinements in our understanding of the evolution of human behavior.
Keywords: Dual Inheritance; Literary Darwinism; adaptationism; evidentiary criteria; evolutionary psychology
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)19-27
JournalScientific Study of Literature
Volume3
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Human Behavior
Darwinism
Key Words
Exaptation
Evolutionary Psychology
Adaptationism
Interdisciplinary Research
Evolutionary

Cite this

@article{b580a2bf91074beaab8ea20318d6cc1f,
title = "Extending literary darwinism: Culture and alternatives to adaptation",
abstract = "Literary Darwinism is an emerging interdisciplinary research field that seeks to explain literature and its oral antecedents (“literary behaviors”), from a Darwinian perspective. Considered the fact that an evolutionary approach to human behavior has proven insightful, this is a promising endeavor. However, Literary Darwinism as it is commonly practiced, I argue, suffers from some shortcomings. First, while literary Darwinists only weigh adaptation against by-product as competing explanations of literary behaviors, other alternatives, such as constraint and exaptation, should be considered as well. I attempt to demonstrate their relevance by evaluating the evidentiary criteria commonly employed by Literary Darwinists. Second, Literary Darwinists usually acknowledge the role of culture in human behavior and make references to Dual Inheritance theory (i.e., the body of empirical and theoretical work demonstrating that human behavior is the outcome of both genetic and cultural inheritance). However, they often do not fully appreciate the explanatory implications of dual inheritance. Literary Darwinism should be extended to include these recent refinements in our understanding of the evolution of human behavior. Keywords: Dual Inheritance; Literary Darwinism; adaptationism; evidentiary criteria; evolutionary psychology",
author = "J. Verpooten",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1075/ssol.3.1.05ver",
language = "English",
volume = "3",
pages = "19--27",
journal = "Scientific Study of Literature",
issn = "2210-4372",
number = "1",

}

Extending literary darwinism : Culture and alternatives to adaptation. / Verpooten, J.

In: Scientific Study of Literature, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2013, p. 19-27.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Extending literary darwinism

T2 - Culture and alternatives to adaptation

AU - Verpooten, J.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - Literary Darwinism is an emerging interdisciplinary research field that seeks to explain literature and its oral antecedents (“literary behaviors”), from a Darwinian perspective. Considered the fact that an evolutionary approach to human behavior has proven insightful, this is a promising endeavor. However, Literary Darwinism as it is commonly practiced, I argue, suffers from some shortcomings. First, while literary Darwinists only weigh adaptation against by-product as competing explanations of literary behaviors, other alternatives, such as constraint and exaptation, should be considered as well. I attempt to demonstrate their relevance by evaluating the evidentiary criteria commonly employed by Literary Darwinists. Second, Literary Darwinists usually acknowledge the role of culture in human behavior and make references to Dual Inheritance theory (i.e., the body of empirical and theoretical work demonstrating that human behavior is the outcome of both genetic and cultural inheritance). However, they often do not fully appreciate the explanatory implications of dual inheritance. Literary Darwinism should be extended to include these recent refinements in our understanding of the evolution of human behavior. Keywords: Dual Inheritance; Literary Darwinism; adaptationism; evidentiary criteria; evolutionary psychology

AB - Literary Darwinism is an emerging interdisciplinary research field that seeks to explain literature and its oral antecedents (“literary behaviors”), from a Darwinian perspective. Considered the fact that an evolutionary approach to human behavior has proven insightful, this is a promising endeavor. However, Literary Darwinism as it is commonly practiced, I argue, suffers from some shortcomings. First, while literary Darwinists only weigh adaptation against by-product as competing explanations of literary behaviors, other alternatives, such as constraint and exaptation, should be considered as well. I attempt to demonstrate their relevance by evaluating the evidentiary criteria commonly employed by Literary Darwinists. Second, Literary Darwinists usually acknowledge the role of culture in human behavior and make references to Dual Inheritance theory (i.e., the body of empirical and theoretical work demonstrating that human behavior is the outcome of both genetic and cultural inheritance). However, they often do not fully appreciate the explanatory implications of dual inheritance. Literary Darwinism should be extended to include these recent refinements in our understanding of the evolution of human behavior. Keywords: Dual Inheritance; Literary Darwinism; adaptationism; evidentiary criteria; evolutionary psychology

U2 - 10.1075/ssol.3.1.05ver

DO - 10.1075/ssol.3.1.05ver

M3 - Article

VL - 3

SP - 19

EP - 27

JO - Scientific Study of Literature

JF - Scientific Study of Literature

SN - 2210-4372

IS - 1

ER -