Fairness and enforcement

Bridging competition, data protection, and consumer law

Inge Graef, Damian Clifford, Peggy Valcke

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

• Since the notion of fairness underpins the regimes of competition, data protection and consumer law, it can act as a connecting factor to align substantive protections and enforcement mechanisms in the three fields.
• While most attention has so far been devoted to how vigorous competition enforcement can render data protection rules more effective, the complementarity between the regimes also works the other way around.
• In particular, substantive data protection or consumer law principles can be integrated into competition analysis so as to strengthen the ability of competition authorities to tackle new forms of commercial conduct.
• At the same time, the competition concepts of market definition and market power can help to interpret the scale of obligations that data controllers and processors have to comply with under data protection law in line with the risk-based approach of the General Data Protection Regulation.
• Tensions occur where competition enforcement favours sharing or merging of datasets for economic efficiency reasons against the spirit of the data protection rules, but there is also room for synergies by involving data protection or consumer authorities in merger investigations and by considering data protection or consumer interests more proactively in the design of merger remedies.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)200-223
Number of pages24
JournalInternational Data Privacy Law
Volume8
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2018

Fingerprint

data protection
fairness
Law
merger
consumer interest
regime
market power
economic efficiency
synergy
remedies
obligation
regulation
market
ability

Keywords

  • Abuse of dominance
  • Data portability
  • Exploitation
  • Merger review
  • Refusal to deal
  • Unfair conditions

Cite this

@article{51ac2f101d6e4d939f8a79d27acdf457,
title = "Fairness and enforcement: Bridging competition, data protection, and consumer law",
abstract = "• Since the notion of fairness underpins the regimes of competition, data protection and consumer law, it can act as a connecting factor to align substantive protections and enforcement mechanisms in the three fields. • While most attention has so far been devoted to how vigorous competition enforcement can render data protection rules more effective, the complementarity between the regimes also works the other way around.• In particular, substantive data protection or consumer law principles can be integrated into competition analysis so as to strengthen the ability of competition authorities to tackle new forms of commercial conduct.• At the same time, the competition concepts of market definition and market power can help to interpret the scale of obligations that data controllers and processors have to comply with under data protection law in line with the risk-based approach of the General Data Protection Regulation.• Tensions occur where competition enforcement favours sharing or merging of datasets for economic efficiency reasons against the spirit of the data protection rules, but there is also room for synergies by involving data protection or consumer authorities in merger investigations and by considering data protection or consumer interests more proactively in the design of merger remedies.",
keywords = "Abuse of dominance, Data portability, Exploitation, Merger review, Refusal to deal, Unfair conditions",
author = "Inge Graef and Damian Clifford and Peggy Valcke",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1093/idpl/ipy013",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "200--223",
journal = "International Data Privacy Law",
issn = "2044-3994",
publisher = "OXFORD UNIV PRESS INC",
number = "3",

}

Fairness and enforcement : Bridging competition, data protection, and consumer law. / Graef, Inge; Clifford, Damian; Valcke, Peggy.

In: International Data Privacy Law, Vol. 8, No. 3, 08.2018, p. 200-223.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Fairness and enforcement

T2 - Bridging competition, data protection, and consumer law

AU - Graef, Inge

AU - Clifford, Damian

AU - Valcke, Peggy

PY - 2018/8

Y1 - 2018/8

N2 - • Since the notion of fairness underpins the regimes of competition, data protection and consumer law, it can act as a connecting factor to align substantive protections and enforcement mechanisms in the three fields. • While most attention has so far been devoted to how vigorous competition enforcement can render data protection rules more effective, the complementarity between the regimes also works the other way around.• In particular, substantive data protection or consumer law principles can be integrated into competition analysis so as to strengthen the ability of competition authorities to tackle new forms of commercial conduct.• At the same time, the competition concepts of market definition and market power can help to interpret the scale of obligations that data controllers and processors have to comply with under data protection law in line with the risk-based approach of the General Data Protection Regulation.• Tensions occur where competition enforcement favours sharing or merging of datasets for economic efficiency reasons against the spirit of the data protection rules, but there is also room for synergies by involving data protection or consumer authorities in merger investigations and by considering data protection or consumer interests more proactively in the design of merger remedies.

AB - • Since the notion of fairness underpins the regimes of competition, data protection and consumer law, it can act as a connecting factor to align substantive protections and enforcement mechanisms in the three fields. • While most attention has so far been devoted to how vigorous competition enforcement can render data protection rules more effective, the complementarity between the regimes also works the other way around.• In particular, substantive data protection or consumer law principles can be integrated into competition analysis so as to strengthen the ability of competition authorities to tackle new forms of commercial conduct.• At the same time, the competition concepts of market definition and market power can help to interpret the scale of obligations that data controllers and processors have to comply with under data protection law in line with the risk-based approach of the General Data Protection Regulation.• Tensions occur where competition enforcement favours sharing or merging of datasets for economic efficiency reasons against the spirit of the data protection rules, but there is also room for synergies by involving data protection or consumer authorities in merger investigations and by considering data protection or consumer interests more proactively in the design of merger remedies.

KW - Abuse of dominance

KW - Data portability

KW - Exploitation

KW - Merger review

KW - Refusal to deal

KW - Unfair conditions

U2 - 10.1093/idpl/ipy013

DO - 10.1093/idpl/ipy013

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 200

EP - 223

JO - International Data Privacy Law

JF - International Data Privacy Law

SN - 2044-3994

IS - 3

ER -