Global law and governmentality: (Re)Conceptualising the "Rule of Law' as Rule "through" law

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

This article (11, 596 words) was published in Europe’s premier journal of interdisciplinary International Relations, the European Journal of International Relations. The article looks at the “rule of law” topos in global governance scholarship, and specifically questions how liberal IL and IR scholars, such as Anne-Marie Slaughter, equate the “rule of law” with the American judicial model expressed in the US Supreme Court case Marbury v. Madison. My argument provides a Foucauldian critique of Anne-Marie Slaughter’s vision of a “global community of courts”, bringing into question whether the expansion of international courts and tribunals will deliver genuine constitutional rule at the global level and, ultimately, the rule of “no one”. A recent publication in Social and Legal Studies referred to my article as an example of “(p. 343) pivotal work of scholars in international law” alongside the work of Prof. Fleur Johns. See: Marjo Lindroth, “Indigenous Rights as Tactics of Neoliberal Governance: Practices of Expertise in the United Nations”, 23 Social and Legal Studies 3 (2014): 341-360. The latest book by Prof. Jens Bartelsen, Sovereignty as Symbolic Form (Routledge, 2014) cites my article twice (Ch. 3 “Restoring Sovereignty” and Ch. 4 “Reinventing Outsides”). The article is cited by Tanja Aalberts and Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen in “Sovereignty at Sea: The Law and Politics of Saving Lives in mare liberum”: 17 Journal of International Relations and Development 4 (2014): 439-468. Finally, a March 2012 ed. of the E-International Relations: The World’s Leading Website for Students and Scholars of International Relations cited the article in its literature review “A Critical Introduction to the ‘Legalization of World Politics’”(http://www.e-ir.info/2012/03/08/a-critical-introduction-to-the-legalisation-of-world-politics/).
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)29-52
Number of pages22
JournalEuropean Journal of International Relations
Volume18
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Mar 2012

Fingerprint

governmentality
constitutional state
international relations
Law
sovereignty
legalization
world politics
global governance
international law
tactics
Supreme Court
website
UNO
expertise
governance
politics
community
student

Keywords

  • Global Governance, global institutions, liberalism, power, rule of law

Cite this

@article{5412cd5002f84f2ab05be9ba5c4add87,
title = "Global law and governmentality: (Re)Conceptualising the {"}Rule of Law' as Rule {"}through{"} law",
abstract = "This article (11, 596 words) was published in Europe’s premier journal of interdisciplinary International Relations, the European Journal of International Relations. The article looks at the “rule of law” topos in global governance scholarship, and specifically questions how liberal IL and IR scholars, such as Anne-Marie Slaughter, equate the “rule of law” with the American judicial model expressed in the US Supreme Court case Marbury v. Madison. My argument provides a Foucauldian critique of Anne-Marie Slaughter’s vision of a “global community of courts”, bringing into question whether the expansion of international courts and tribunals will deliver genuine constitutional rule at the global level and, ultimately, the rule of “no one”. A recent publication in Social and Legal Studies referred to my article as an example of “(p. 343) pivotal work of scholars in international law” alongside the work of Prof. Fleur Johns. See: Marjo Lindroth, “Indigenous Rights as Tactics of Neoliberal Governance: Practices of Expertise in the United Nations”, 23 Social and Legal Studies 3 (2014): 341-360. The latest book by Prof. Jens Bartelsen, Sovereignty as Symbolic Form (Routledge, 2014) cites my article twice (Ch. 3 “Restoring Sovereignty” and Ch. 4 “Reinventing Outsides”). The article is cited by Tanja Aalberts and Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen in “Sovereignty at Sea: The Law and Politics of Saving Lives in mare liberum”: 17 Journal of International Relations and Development 4 (2014): 439-468. Finally, a March 2012 ed. of the E-International Relations: The World’s Leading Website for Students and Scholars of International Relations cited the article in its literature review “A Critical Introduction to the ‘Legalization of World Politics’”(http://www.e-ir.info/2012/03/08/a-critical-introduction-to-the-legalisation-of-world-politics/).",
keywords = "Global Governance, global institutions, liberalism, power, rule of law",
author = "Nikolas Rajkovic",
year = "2012",
month = "3",
day = "1",
doi = "10.11778/1354066110380966",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "29--52",
journal = "European Journal of International Relations",
issn = "1354-0661",
publisher = "Sage Publications Ltd",
number = "1",

}

Global law and governmentality : (Re)Conceptualising the "Rule of Law' as Rule "through" law. / Rajkovic, Nikolas.

In: European Journal of International Relations, Vol. 18, No. 1, 01.03.2012, p. 29-52.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Global law and governmentality

T2 - (Re)Conceptualising the "Rule of Law' as Rule "through" law

AU - Rajkovic, Nikolas

PY - 2012/3/1

Y1 - 2012/3/1

N2 - This article (11, 596 words) was published in Europe’s premier journal of interdisciplinary International Relations, the European Journal of International Relations. The article looks at the “rule of law” topos in global governance scholarship, and specifically questions how liberal IL and IR scholars, such as Anne-Marie Slaughter, equate the “rule of law” with the American judicial model expressed in the US Supreme Court case Marbury v. Madison. My argument provides a Foucauldian critique of Anne-Marie Slaughter’s vision of a “global community of courts”, bringing into question whether the expansion of international courts and tribunals will deliver genuine constitutional rule at the global level and, ultimately, the rule of “no one”. A recent publication in Social and Legal Studies referred to my article as an example of “(p. 343) pivotal work of scholars in international law” alongside the work of Prof. Fleur Johns. See: Marjo Lindroth, “Indigenous Rights as Tactics of Neoliberal Governance: Practices of Expertise in the United Nations”, 23 Social and Legal Studies 3 (2014): 341-360. The latest book by Prof. Jens Bartelsen, Sovereignty as Symbolic Form (Routledge, 2014) cites my article twice (Ch. 3 “Restoring Sovereignty” and Ch. 4 “Reinventing Outsides”). The article is cited by Tanja Aalberts and Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen in “Sovereignty at Sea: The Law and Politics of Saving Lives in mare liberum”: 17 Journal of International Relations and Development 4 (2014): 439-468. Finally, a March 2012 ed. of the E-International Relations: The World’s Leading Website for Students and Scholars of International Relations cited the article in its literature review “A Critical Introduction to the ‘Legalization of World Politics’”(http://www.e-ir.info/2012/03/08/a-critical-introduction-to-the-legalisation-of-world-politics/).

AB - This article (11, 596 words) was published in Europe’s premier journal of interdisciplinary International Relations, the European Journal of International Relations. The article looks at the “rule of law” topos in global governance scholarship, and specifically questions how liberal IL and IR scholars, such as Anne-Marie Slaughter, equate the “rule of law” with the American judicial model expressed in the US Supreme Court case Marbury v. Madison. My argument provides a Foucauldian critique of Anne-Marie Slaughter’s vision of a “global community of courts”, bringing into question whether the expansion of international courts and tribunals will deliver genuine constitutional rule at the global level and, ultimately, the rule of “no one”. A recent publication in Social and Legal Studies referred to my article as an example of “(p. 343) pivotal work of scholars in international law” alongside the work of Prof. Fleur Johns. See: Marjo Lindroth, “Indigenous Rights as Tactics of Neoliberal Governance: Practices of Expertise in the United Nations”, 23 Social and Legal Studies 3 (2014): 341-360. The latest book by Prof. Jens Bartelsen, Sovereignty as Symbolic Form (Routledge, 2014) cites my article twice (Ch. 3 “Restoring Sovereignty” and Ch. 4 “Reinventing Outsides”). The article is cited by Tanja Aalberts and Thomas Gammeltoft-Hansen in “Sovereignty at Sea: The Law and Politics of Saving Lives in mare liberum”: 17 Journal of International Relations and Development 4 (2014): 439-468. Finally, a March 2012 ed. of the E-International Relations: The World’s Leading Website for Students and Scholars of International Relations cited the article in its literature review “A Critical Introduction to the ‘Legalization of World Politics’”(http://www.e-ir.info/2012/03/08/a-critical-introduction-to-the-legalisation-of-world-politics/).

KW - Global Governance, global institutions, liberalism, power, rule of law

U2 - 10.11778/1354066110380966

DO - 10.11778/1354066110380966

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 29

EP - 52

JO - European Journal of International Relations

JF - European Journal of International Relations

SN - 1354-0661

IS - 1

ER -