Gratitude, indebtedness, and reciprocity: An extended replication of Bartlett & DeSteno (2006)

Cong Peng*, Charlotte Malafosse, Rob M. A. Nelissen, Marcel Zeelenberg

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

In a landmark study in 2006, Bartlett and DeSteno found that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior and that this effect was mediated by gratitude. Recent research, however, suggested that indebtedness is more closely associated with reciprocation than gratitude. Therefore, we examined whether reciprocal behavior could (also) be attributed to indebtedness. Specifically, we attempted to replicate and extend Bartlett and DeSteno's Study 1 by additionally including a measure of indebtedness. Surprisingly, the replication was not successful. We did not find support for the idea that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior, and neither gratitude nor indebtedness was associated with reciprocal behavior. Finally, we call for attention that the extant literature may be inconclusive regarding the presumed prosocial effects of gratitude.

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages13
JournalSocial Influence
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 2020

Keywords

  • Gratitude
  • indebtedness
  • reciprocity
  • Replication
  • PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR
  • BENEFITS
  • ROLES

Cite this

@article{064cdb734dc5485db158f9649a44c7a6,
title = "Gratitude, indebtedness, and reciprocity: An extended replication of Bartlett & DeSteno (2006)",
abstract = "In a landmark study in 2006, Bartlett and DeSteno found that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior and that this effect was mediated by gratitude. Recent research, however, suggested that indebtedness is more closely associated with reciprocation than gratitude. Therefore, we examined whether reciprocal behavior could (also) be attributed to indebtedness. Specifically, we attempted to replicate and extend Bartlett and DeSteno's Study 1 by additionally including a measure of indebtedness. Surprisingly, the replication was not successful. We did not find support for the idea that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior, and neither gratitude nor indebtedness was associated with reciprocal behavior. Finally, we call for attention that the extant literature may be inconclusive regarding the presumed prosocial effects of gratitude.",
keywords = "Gratitude, indebtedness, reciprocity, Replication, PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR, BENEFITS, ROLES",
author = "Cong Peng and Charlotte Malafosse and Nelissen, {Rob M. A.} and Marcel Zeelenberg",
year = "2020",
doi = "10.1080/15534510.2019.1710248",
language = "English",
journal = "Social Influence",
issn = "1553-4510",
publisher = "Psychology Press Ltd",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gratitude, indebtedness, and reciprocity

T2 - An extended replication of Bartlett & DeSteno (2006)

AU - Peng, Cong

AU - Malafosse, Charlotte

AU - Nelissen, Rob M. A.

AU - Zeelenberg, Marcel

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - In a landmark study in 2006, Bartlett and DeSteno found that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior and that this effect was mediated by gratitude. Recent research, however, suggested that indebtedness is more closely associated with reciprocation than gratitude. Therefore, we examined whether reciprocal behavior could (also) be attributed to indebtedness. Specifically, we attempted to replicate and extend Bartlett and DeSteno's Study 1 by additionally including a measure of indebtedness. Surprisingly, the replication was not successful. We did not find support for the idea that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior, and neither gratitude nor indebtedness was associated with reciprocal behavior. Finally, we call for attention that the extant literature may be inconclusive regarding the presumed prosocial effects of gratitude.

AB - In a landmark study in 2006, Bartlett and DeSteno found that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior and that this effect was mediated by gratitude. Recent research, however, suggested that indebtedness is more closely associated with reciprocation than gratitude. Therefore, we examined whether reciprocal behavior could (also) be attributed to indebtedness. Specifically, we attempted to replicate and extend Bartlett and DeSteno's Study 1 by additionally including a measure of indebtedness. Surprisingly, the replication was not successful. We did not find support for the idea that receiving help promoted reciprocal behavior, and neither gratitude nor indebtedness was associated with reciprocal behavior. Finally, we call for attention that the extant literature may be inconclusive regarding the presumed prosocial effects of gratitude.

KW - Gratitude

KW - indebtedness

KW - reciprocity

KW - Replication

KW - PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR

KW - BENEFITS

KW - ROLES

UR - https://app-eu.readspeaker.com/cgi-bin/rsent?customerid=10118&lang=en_us&readclass=rs_readArea&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tandfonline.com%2Fdoi%2Ffull%2F10.1080%2F15534510.2019.1710248

U2 - 10.1080/15534510.2019.1710248

DO - 10.1080/15534510.2019.1710248

M3 - Article

JO - Social Influence

JF - Social Influence

SN - 1553-4510

ER -