How economic crises affect alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems

A realist systematic review

Moniek C. M. de Goeij, Marc Suhrcke, Veronica Toffolutti, Dike van de Mheen, Tim M. Schoenmakers, Anton E. Kunst

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Economic crises are complex events that affect behavioral patterns (including alcohol consumption) via opposing mechanisms. With this realist systematic review, we aimed to investigate evidence from studies of previous or ongoing crises on which mechanisms (How?) play a role among which individuals (Whom?). Such evidence would help understand and predict the potential impact of economic crises on alcohol consumption. Medical, psychological, social, and economic databases were used to search for peer-reviewed qualitative or quantitative empirical evidence (published January 1, 1990–May 1, 2014) linking economic crises or stressors with alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. We included 35 papers, based on defined selection criteria. From these papers, we extracted evidence on mechanism(s), determinant, outcome, country-level context, and individual context. We found 16 studies that reported evidence completely covering two behavioral mechanisms by which economic crises can influence alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. The first mechanism suggests that psychological distress triggered by unemployment and income reductions can increase drinking problems. The second mechanism suggests that due to tighter budget constraints, less money is spent on alcoholic beverages. Across many countries, the psychological distress mechanism was observed mainly in men. The tighter budget constraints mechanism seems to play a role in all population subgroups across all countries. For the other three mechanisms (i.e., deterioration in the social situation, fear of losing one's job, and increased non-working time), empirical evidence was scarce or absent, or had small to moderate coverage. This was also the case for important influential contextual factors described in our initial theoretical framework. This realist systematic review suggests that among men (but not among women), the net impact of economic crises will be an increase in harmful drinking. Such a different net impact between men and women could potentially contribute to growing gender-related health inequalities during a crisis.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)131-146
JournalSocial Science & Medicine
Volume131
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

alcohol consumption
Alcohol Drinking
economic crisis
alcohol
Alcohols
health
evidence
Drinking
budget
Unemployment
social situation
alcoholism
Patient Selection
Realist
Alcohol
Economic Crisis
Systematic Review
Health
unemployment
money

Keywords

  • Economic crisis, Alcohol consumption, Alcohol-related health problems, Realist systematic review

Cite this

de Goeij, Moniek C. M. ; Suhrcke, Marc ; Toffolutti, Veronica ; van de Mheen, Dike ; Schoenmakers, Tim M. ; Kunst, Anton E. / How economic crises affect alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems : A realist systematic review. In: Social Science & Medicine. 2015 ; Vol. 131. pp. 131-146.
@article{b75fdd3c1a834d82b331a04910d80d7f,
title = "How economic crises affect alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems: A realist systematic review",
abstract = "Economic crises are complex events that affect behavioral patterns (including alcohol consumption) via opposing mechanisms. With this realist systematic review, we aimed to investigate evidence from studies of previous or ongoing crises on which mechanisms (How?) play a role among which individuals (Whom?). Such evidence would help understand and predict the potential impact of economic crises on alcohol consumption. Medical, psychological, social, and economic databases were used to search for peer-reviewed qualitative or quantitative empirical evidence (published January 1, 1990–May 1, 2014) linking economic crises or stressors with alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. We included 35 papers, based on defined selection criteria. From these papers, we extracted evidence on mechanism(s), determinant, outcome, country-level context, and individual context. We found 16 studies that reported evidence completely covering two behavioral mechanisms by which economic crises can influence alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. The first mechanism suggests that psychological distress triggered by unemployment and income reductions can increase drinking problems. The second mechanism suggests that due to tighter budget constraints, less money is spent on alcoholic beverages. Across many countries, the psychological distress mechanism was observed mainly in men. The tighter budget constraints mechanism seems to play a role in all population subgroups across all countries. For the other three mechanisms (i.e., deterioration in the social situation, fear of losing one's job, and increased non-working time), empirical evidence was scarce or absent, or had small to moderate coverage. This was also the case for important influential contextual factors described in our initial theoretical framework. This realist systematic review suggests that among men (but not among women), the net impact of economic crises will be an increase in harmful drinking. Such a different net impact between men and women could potentially contribute to growing gender-related health inequalities during a crisis.",
keywords = "Economic crisis, Alcohol consumption, Alcohol-related health problems, Realist systematic review",
author = "{de Goeij}, {Moniek C. M.} and Marc Suhrcke and Veronica Toffolutti and {van de Mheen}, Dike and Schoenmakers, {Tim M.} and Kunst, {Anton E.}",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.02.025",
language = "English",
volume = "131",
pages = "131--146",
journal = "Social Science & Medicine",
issn = "0277-9536",
publisher = "PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD",

}

How economic crises affect alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems : A realist systematic review. / de Goeij, Moniek C. M.; Suhrcke, Marc; Toffolutti, Veronica; van de Mheen, Dike; Schoenmakers, Tim M.; Kunst, Anton E.

In: Social Science & Medicine, Vol. 131, 2015, p. 131-146.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - How economic crises affect alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems

T2 - A realist systematic review

AU - de Goeij, Moniek C. M.

AU - Suhrcke, Marc

AU - Toffolutti, Veronica

AU - van de Mheen, Dike

AU - Schoenmakers, Tim M.

AU - Kunst, Anton E.

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Economic crises are complex events that affect behavioral patterns (including alcohol consumption) via opposing mechanisms. With this realist systematic review, we aimed to investigate evidence from studies of previous or ongoing crises on which mechanisms (How?) play a role among which individuals (Whom?). Such evidence would help understand and predict the potential impact of economic crises on alcohol consumption. Medical, psychological, social, and economic databases were used to search for peer-reviewed qualitative or quantitative empirical evidence (published January 1, 1990–May 1, 2014) linking economic crises or stressors with alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. We included 35 papers, based on defined selection criteria. From these papers, we extracted evidence on mechanism(s), determinant, outcome, country-level context, and individual context. We found 16 studies that reported evidence completely covering two behavioral mechanisms by which economic crises can influence alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. The first mechanism suggests that psychological distress triggered by unemployment and income reductions can increase drinking problems. The second mechanism suggests that due to tighter budget constraints, less money is spent on alcoholic beverages. Across many countries, the psychological distress mechanism was observed mainly in men. The tighter budget constraints mechanism seems to play a role in all population subgroups across all countries. For the other three mechanisms (i.e., deterioration in the social situation, fear of losing one's job, and increased non-working time), empirical evidence was scarce or absent, or had small to moderate coverage. This was also the case for important influential contextual factors described in our initial theoretical framework. This realist systematic review suggests that among men (but not among women), the net impact of economic crises will be an increase in harmful drinking. Such a different net impact between men and women could potentially contribute to growing gender-related health inequalities during a crisis.

AB - Economic crises are complex events that affect behavioral patterns (including alcohol consumption) via opposing mechanisms. With this realist systematic review, we aimed to investigate evidence from studies of previous or ongoing crises on which mechanisms (How?) play a role among which individuals (Whom?). Such evidence would help understand and predict the potential impact of economic crises on alcohol consumption. Medical, psychological, social, and economic databases were used to search for peer-reviewed qualitative or quantitative empirical evidence (published January 1, 1990–May 1, 2014) linking economic crises or stressors with alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. We included 35 papers, based on defined selection criteria. From these papers, we extracted evidence on mechanism(s), determinant, outcome, country-level context, and individual context. We found 16 studies that reported evidence completely covering two behavioral mechanisms by which economic crises can influence alcohol consumption and alcohol-related health problems. The first mechanism suggests that psychological distress triggered by unemployment and income reductions can increase drinking problems. The second mechanism suggests that due to tighter budget constraints, less money is spent on alcoholic beverages. Across many countries, the psychological distress mechanism was observed mainly in men. The tighter budget constraints mechanism seems to play a role in all population subgroups across all countries. For the other three mechanisms (i.e., deterioration in the social situation, fear of losing one's job, and increased non-working time), empirical evidence was scarce or absent, or had small to moderate coverage. This was also the case for important influential contextual factors described in our initial theoretical framework. This realist systematic review suggests that among men (but not among women), the net impact of economic crises will be an increase in harmful drinking. Such a different net impact between men and women could potentially contribute to growing gender-related health inequalities during a crisis.

KW - Economic crisis, Alcohol consumption, Alcohol-related health problems, Realist systematic review

U2 - 10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.02.025

DO - 10.1016/j.socscimed.2015.02.025

M3 - Article

VL - 131

SP - 131

EP - 146

JO - Social Science & Medicine

JF - Social Science & Medicine

SN - 0277-9536

ER -