How important are student-selected versus instructor-selected literature resources for students' learning and motivation in problem-based learning?

Lisette Wijnia, Sofie M. M. Loyens, Eva Derous, Henk G. Schmidt

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

In problem-based learning students are responsible for their own learning process, which becomes evident when they must act independently, for example, when selecting literature resources for individual study. It is a matter of debate whether it is better to have students select their own literature resources or to present them with a list of mandatory instructor-selected literature resources. The current study investigated the effect of using instructor-selected literature resources or student-selected literature resources (from a predetermined set of literature) on several learning outcome variables. The results demonstrated that students in the student-selected literature condition scored higher on autonomous motivation and perceived competence, and lower on perceptions of mental effort during studying. Students in the instructor-selected condition had better test performance on factual test items, whereas no difference was found for the conceptual questions. Overall, the results indicate that letting students select their own literature resources can be beneficial in terms of autonomous motivation, perceived competence, and perceptions of mental effort invested during learning and does not differentially affect conceptual knowledge.
Keywords: Problem-based learning, Self-study, Self-directed learning, Autonomous motivation, Perceived competence
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)39-58
JournalInstructional Science
Volume43
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Keywords

  • Problem-based learning
  • Self-study
  • Self-directed learning
  • Autonomous motivation
  • Perceived competence

Cite this

Wijnia, Lisette ; Loyens, Sofie M. M. ; Derous, Eva ; Schmidt, Henk G. / How important are student-selected versus instructor-selected literature resources for students' learning and motivation in problem-based learning?. In: Instructional Science. 2015 ; Vol. 43, No. 1. pp. 39-58.
@article{b69693abccaf49a7ad29a1bd442624c7,
title = "How important are student-selected versus instructor-selected literature resources for students' learning and motivation in problem-based learning?",
abstract = "In problem-based learning students are responsible for their own learning process, which becomes evident when they must act independently, for example, when selecting literature resources for individual study. It is a matter of debate whether it is better to have students select their own literature resources or to present them with a list of mandatory instructor-selected literature resources. The current study investigated the effect of using instructor-selected literature resources or student-selected literature resources (from a predetermined set of literature) on several learning outcome variables. The results demonstrated that students in the student-selected literature condition scored higher on autonomous motivation and perceived competence, and lower on perceptions of mental effort during studying. Students in the instructor-selected condition had better test performance on factual test items, whereas no difference was found for the conceptual questions. Overall, the results indicate that letting students select their own literature resources can be beneficial in terms of autonomous motivation, perceived competence, and perceptions of mental effort invested during learning and does not differentially affect conceptual knowledge.Keywords: Problem-based learning, Self-study, Self-directed learning, Autonomous motivation, Perceived competence",
keywords = "Problem-based learning, Self-study, Self-directed learning, Autonomous motivation, Perceived competence",
author = "Lisette Wijnia and Loyens, {Sofie M. M.} and Eva Derous and Schmidt, {Henk G.}",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1007/s11251-014-9325-6",
language = "English",
volume = "43",
pages = "39--58",
journal = "Instructional Science",
issn = "0020-4277",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "1",

}

How important are student-selected versus instructor-selected literature resources for students' learning and motivation in problem-based learning? / Wijnia, Lisette; Loyens, Sofie M. M.; Derous, Eva; Schmidt, Henk G.

In: Instructional Science, Vol. 43, No. 1, 2015, p. 39-58.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - How important are student-selected versus instructor-selected literature resources for students' learning and motivation in problem-based learning?

AU - Wijnia, Lisette

AU - Loyens, Sofie M. M.

AU - Derous, Eva

AU - Schmidt, Henk G.

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - In problem-based learning students are responsible for their own learning process, which becomes evident when they must act independently, for example, when selecting literature resources for individual study. It is a matter of debate whether it is better to have students select their own literature resources or to present them with a list of mandatory instructor-selected literature resources. The current study investigated the effect of using instructor-selected literature resources or student-selected literature resources (from a predetermined set of literature) on several learning outcome variables. The results demonstrated that students in the student-selected literature condition scored higher on autonomous motivation and perceived competence, and lower on perceptions of mental effort during studying. Students in the instructor-selected condition had better test performance on factual test items, whereas no difference was found for the conceptual questions. Overall, the results indicate that letting students select their own literature resources can be beneficial in terms of autonomous motivation, perceived competence, and perceptions of mental effort invested during learning and does not differentially affect conceptual knowledge.Keywords: Problem-based learning, Self-study, Self-directed learning, Autonomous motivation, Perceived competence

AB - In problem-based learning students are responsible for their own learning process, which becomes evident when they must act independently, for example, when selecting literature resources for individual study. It is a matter of debate whether it is better to have students select their own literature resources or to present them with a list of mandatory instructor-selected literature resources. The current study investigated the effect of using instructor-selected literature resources or student-selected literature resources (from a predetermined set of literature) on several learning outcome variables. The results demonstrated that students in the student-selected literature condition scored higher on autonomous motivation and perceived competence, and lower on perceptions of mental effort during studying. Students in the instructor-selected condition had better test performance on factual test items, whereas no difference was found for the conceptual questions. Overall, the results indicate that letting students select their own literature resources can be beneficial in terms of autonomous motivation, perceived competence, and perceptions of mental effort invested during learning and does not differentially affect conceptual knowledge.Keywords: Problem-based learning, Self-study, Self-directed learning, Autonomous motivation, Perceived competence

KW - Problem-based learning

KW - Self-study

KW - Self-directed learning

KW - Autonomous motivation

KW - Perceived competence

U2 - 10.1007/s11251-014-9325-6

DO - 10.1007/s11251-014-9325-6

M3 - Article

VL - 43

SP - 39

EP - 58

JO - Instructional Science

JF - Instructional Science

SN - 0020-4277

IS - 1

ER -