Ideas are cheap: When and why adults value labor over ideas

Pascal Burgmer, Matthias Forstmann, O. Stavrova

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

What do people value about a creation: the idea behind it or the labor needed for its implementation? Recent developmental research suggests that children by the age of 6 begin to value ideas over labor. Yet, much less is known about whether adults similarly attribute a higher value to ideas and idea givers than to labor and idea executors. In seven studies (N = 1,463), we explored the relative valuation of ideas versus labor in adults, its mechanisms and boundary conditions. Participants learned about an idea giver and a laborer who collaborated to create a product and indicated who deserves ownership and monetary compensation for the product. Contrary to what has been reported for children, Studies 1a-1c found that participants valued the contribution of the laborer more than the contribution of the idea giver. This labor-valuation effect emerged even when participants themselves were idea givers (Study 1b), and it was replicated across different populations (including legal professionals, Study 1c) and contexts (e.g., art works and businesses, Study 2). Studies 3a and 3b established perceived effort as a central psychological process behind the labor-valuation effect. Finally, Study 4 extended the effect to the realm of praise and blame judgments, showing that laborers receive more praise for positive outcomes, but less blame for negative outcomes, relative to idea givers. The current findings may provide a useful framework for understanding the role of effort in lay people's valuation of ideas and labor, thereby bridging research on creativity, effort, and valuation judgments.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)824-844
JournalJournal of Experimental Psychology: General
Volume148
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2019

Fingerprint

Creativity
Ownership

Keywords

  • BELIEFS
  • BODY
  • CHILDRENS RESPONSE
  • CONSEQUENCES
  • COPYCAT BRANDS
  • CREATIVITY
  • FLEXIBILITY
  • JUDGMENTS
  • PSYCHOLOGY
  • creativity
  • idea valuation
  • labor valuation
  • perceived effort
  • praise and blame judgments

Cite this

Burgmer, Pascal ; Forstmann, Matthias ; Stavrova, O. / Ideas are cheap : When and why adults value labor over ideas. In: Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 2019 ; Vol. 148, No. 5. pp. 824-844.
@article{be45822352af401ab89ed4a993a83da6,
title = "Ideas are cheap: When and why adults value labor over ideas",
abstract = "What do people value about a creation: the idea behind it or the labor needed for its implementation? Recent developmental research suggests that children by the age of 6 begin to value ideas over labor. Yet, much less is known about whether adults similarly attribute a higher value to ideas and idea givers than to labor and idea executors. In seven studies (N = 1,463), we explored the relative valuation of ideas versus labor in adults, its mechanisms and boundary conditions. Participants learned about an idea giver and a laborer who collaborated to create a product and indicated who deserves ownership and monetary compensation for the product. Contrary to what has been reported for children, Studies 1a-1c found that participants valued the contribution of the laborer more than the contribution of the idea giver. This labor-valuation effect emerged even when participants themselves were idea givers (Study 1b), and it was replicated across different populations (including legal professionals, Study 1c) and contexts (e.g., art works and businesses, Study 2). Studies 3a and 3b established perceived effort as a central psychological process behind the labor-valuation effect. Finally, Study 4 extended the effect to the realm of praise and blame judgments, showing that laborers receive more praise for positive outcomes, but less blame for negative outcomes, relative to idea givers. The current findings may provide a useful framework for understanding the role of effort in lay people's valuation of ideas and labor, thereby bridging research on creativity, effort, and valuation judgments.",
keywords = "BELIEFS, BODY, CHILDRENS RESPONSE, CONSEQUENCES, COPYCAT BRANDS, CREATIVITY, FLEXIBILITY, JUDGMENTS, PSYCHOLOGY, creativity, idea valuation, labor valuation, perceived effort, praise and blame judgments",
author = "Pascal Burgmer and Matthias Forstmann and O. Stavrova",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1037/xge0000473",
language = "English",
volume = "148",
pages = "824--844",
journal = "Journal of Experimental Psychology: General",
issn = "0096-3445",
publisher = "AMER PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOC",
number = "5",

}

Ideas are cheap : When and why adults value labor over ideas. / Burgmer, Pascal; Forstmann, Matthias; Stavrova, O.

In: Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, Vol. 148, No. 5, 05.2019, p. 824-844.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Ideas are cheap

T2 - When and why adults value labor over ideas

AU - Burgmer, Pascal

AU - Forstmann, Matthias

AU - Stavrova, O.

PY - 2019/5

Y1 - 2019/5

N2 - What do people value about a creation: the idea behind it or the labor needed for its implementation? Recent developmental research suggests that children by the age of 6 begin to value ideas over labor. Yet, much less is known about whether adults similarly attribute a higher value to ideas and idea givers than to labor and idea executors. In seven studies (N = 1,463), we explored the relative valuation of ideas versus labor in adults, its mechanisms and boundary conditions. Participants learned about an idea giver and a laborer who collaborated to create a product and indicated who deserves ownership and monetary compensation for the product. Contrary to what has been reported for children, Studies 1a-1c found that participants valued the contribution of the laborer more than the contribution of the idea giver. This labor-valuation effect emerged even when participants themselves were idea givers (Study 1b), and it was replicated across different populations (including legal professionals, Study 1c) and contexts (e.g., art works and businesses, Study 2). Studies 3a and 3b established perceived effort as a central psychological process behind the labor-valuation effect. Finally, Study 4 extended the effect to the realm of praise and blame judgments, showing that laborers receive more praise for positive outcomes, but less blame for negative outcomes, relative to idea givers. The current findings may provide a useful framework for understanding the role of effort in lay people's valuation of ideas and labor, thereby bridging research on creativity, effort, and valuation judgments.

AB - What do people value about a creation: the idea behind it or the labor needed for its implementation? Recent developmental research suggests that children by the age of 6 begin to value ideas over labor. Yet, much less is known about whether adults similarly attribute a higher value to ideas and idea givers than to labor and idea executors. In seven studies (N = 1,463), we explored the relative valuation of ideas versus labor in adults, its mechanisms and boundary conditions. Participants learned about an idea giver and a laborer who collaborated to create a product and indicated who deserves ownership and monetary compensation for the product. Contrary to what has been reported for children, Studies 1a-1c found that participants valued the contribution of the laborer more than the contribution of the idea giver. This labor-valuation effect emerged even when participants themselves were idea givers (Study 1b), and it was replicated across different populations (including legal professionals, Study 1c) and contexts (e.g., art works and businesses, Study 2). Studies 3a and 3b established perceived effort as a central psychological process behind the labor-valuation effect. Finally, Study 4 extended the effect to the realm of praise and blame judgments, showing that laborers receive more praise for positive outcomes, but less blame for negative outcomes, relative to idea givers. The current findings may provide a useful framework for understanding the role of effort in lay people's valuation of ideas and labor, thereby bridging research on creativity, effort, and valuation judgments.

KW - BELIEFS

KW - BODY

KW - CHILDRENS RESPONSE

KW - CONSEQUENCES

KW - COPYCAT BRANDS

KW - CREATIVITY

KW - FLEXIBILITY

KW - JUDGMENTS

KW - PSYCHOLOGY

KW - creativity

KW - idea valuation

KW - labor valuation

KW - perceived effort

KW - praise and blame judgments

U2 - 10.1037/xge0000473

DO - 10.1037/xge0000473

M3 - Article

VL - 148

SP - 824

EP - 844

JO - Journal of Experimental Psychology: General

JF - Journal of Experimental Psychology: General

SN - 0096-3445

IS - 5

ER -