Improving inter-organizational care-cure designs

Specialization versus integration

Angele Pieters, K.E. van Oorschot, Henk Akkermans, S.C. Brailsford

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Purpose
The purpose of this paper is to investigate inter-organizational designs for care–cure conditions in which low-risk patients are cared for in specialized care organizations and high-risk patients are cared for in specialized cure organizations. Performance impacts of increasing levels of integration between these organizations are analyzed.

Design/methodology/approach
Mixed methods were used in Dutch perinatal care: analysis of archival data, clinical research and system dynamics simulation modeling.

Findings
Inter-organizational design has an effect on inter-organizational dynamics such as collaboration and trust, and also on the operational aspects such as patient flows through the system. Solutions are found in integrating care and cure organizations. However, not all levels of integrated designs perform better than a design based on organizational separation of care and cure.

Practical implications
A clear split between midwifery practices (care) and obstetric departments (cure) will not work since all pregnant women need both care and cure. Having midwifery practices only works well when there are high levels of collaboration and trust with obstetric departments in hospitals. Integrated care designs are likely to exhibit superior performance. However, these designs will have an adverse effect on organizations that are not part of this integration, since integrating only a subset of organizations will feed distrust, low collaboration and hence low performance.

Originality/value
The originality of this research is derived from its multi-method approach. Archival data and clinical research revealed the dynamic relations between organizations. The caveat of some integrated care models was found through simulation.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)328-341
JournalJournal of Intergrated Care
Volume26
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

specialization
Organizations
Hospital Obstetrics and Gynecology Department
Midwifery
obstetrics
performance
simulation
methodology

Keywords

  • system dynamics
  • healthcare
  • organization design
  • inter-organizational collaboration

Cite this

Pieters, Angele ; van Oorschot, K.E. ; Akkermans, Henk ; Brailsford, S.C. / Improving inter-organizational care-cure designs : Specialization versus integration. In: Journal of Intergrated Care. 2018 ; Vol. 26, No. 4. pp. 328-341.
@article{89bd5549bd1742049ffbbf4e5064d7ee,
title = "Improving inter-organizational care-cure designs: Specialization versus integration",
abstract = "PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to investigate inter-organizational designs for care–cure conditions in which low-risk patients are cared for in specialized care organizations and high-risk patients are cared for in specialized cure organizations. Performance impacts of increasing levels of integration between these organizations are analyzed.Design/methodology/approachMixed methods were used in Dutch perinatal care: analysis of archival data, clinical research and system dynamics simulation modeling.FindingsInter-organizational design has an effect on inter-organizational dynamics such as collaboration and trust, and also on the operational aspects such as patient flows through the system. Solutions are found in integrating care and cure organizations. However, not all levels of integrated designs perform better than a design based on organizational separation of care and cure.Practical implicationsA clear split between midwifery practices (care) and obstetric departments (cure) will not work since all pregnant women need both care and cure. Having midwifery practices only works well when there are high levels of collaboration and trust with obstetric departments in hospitals. Integrated care designs are likely to exhibit superior performance. However, these designs will have an adverse effect on organizations that are not part of this integration, since integrating only a subset of organizations will feed distrust, low collaboration and hence low performance.Originality/valueThe originality of this research is derived from its multi-method approach. Archival data and clinical research revealed the dynamic relations between organizations. The caveat of some integrated care models was found through simulation.",
keywords = "system dynamics, healthcare, organization design, inter-organizational collaboration",
author = "Angele Pieters and {van Oorschot}, K.E. and Henk Akkermans and S.C. Brailsford",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1108/JICA-02-2018-0018",
language = "English",
volume = "26",
pages = "328--341",
journal = "Journal of Intergrated Care",
issn = "1476-9018",
publisher = "Emerald Publishing",
number = "4",

}

Improving inter-organizational care-cure designs : Specialization versus integration. / Pieters, Angele; van Oorschot, K.E.; Akkermans, Henk; Brailsford, S.C.

In: Journal of Intergrated Care, Vol. 26, No. 4, 2018, p. 328-341.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Improving inter-organizational care-cure designs

T2 - Specialization versus integration

AU - Pieters, Angele

AU - van Oorschot, K.E.

AU - Akkermans, Henk

AU - Brailsford, S.C.

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to investigate inter-organizational designs for care–cure conditions in which low-risk patients are cared for in specialized care organizations and high-risk patients are cared for in specialized cure organizations. Performance impacts of increasing levels of integration between these organizations are analyzed.Design/methodology/approachMixed methods were used in Dutch perinatal care: analysis of archival data, clinical research and system dynamics simulation modeling.FindingsInter-organizational design has an effect on inter-organizational dynamics such as collaboration and trust, and also on the operational aspects such as patient flows through the system. Solutions are found in integrating care and cure organizations. However, not all levels of integrated designs perform better than a design based on organizational separation of care and cure.Practical implicationsA clear split between midwifery practices (care) and obstetric departments (cure) will not work since all pregnant women need both care and cure. Having midwifery practices only works well when there are high levels of collaboration and trust with obstetric departments in hospitals. Integrated care designs are likely to exhibit superior performance. However, these designs will have an adverse effect on organizations that are not part of this integration, since integrating only a subset of organizations will feed distrust, low collaboration and hence low performance.Originality/valueThe originality of this research is derived from its multi-method approach. Archival data and clinical research revealed the dynamic relations between organizations. The caveat of some integrated care models was found through simulation.

AB - PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to investigate inter-organizational designs for care–cure conditions in which low-risk patients are cared for in specialized care organizations and high-risk patients are cared for in specialized cure organizations. Performance impacts of increasing levels of integration between these organizations are analyzed.Design/methodology/approachMixed methods were used in Dutch perinatal care: analysis of archival data, clinical research and system dynamics simulation modeling.FindingsInter-organizational design has an effect on inter-organizational dynamics such as collaboration and trust, and also on the operational aspects such as patient flows through the system. Solutions are found in integrating care and cure organizations. However, not all levels of integrated designs perform better than a design based on organizational separation of care and cure.Practical implicationsA clear split between midwifery practices (care) and obstetric departments (cure) will not work since all pregnant women need both care and cure. Having midwifery practices only works well when there are high levels of collaboration and trust with obstetric departments in hospitals. Integrated care designs are likely to exhibit superior performance. However, these designs will have an adverse effect on organizations that are not part of this integration, since integrating only a subset of organizations will feed distrust, low collaboration and hence low performance.Originality/valueThe originality of this research is derived from its multi-method approach. Archival data and clinical research revealed the dynamic relations between organizations. The caveat of some integrated care models was found through simulation.

KW - system dynamics

KW - healthcare

KW - organization design

KW - inter-organizational collaboration

U2 - 10.1108/JICA-02-2018-0018

DO - 10.1108/JICA-02-2018-0018

M3 - Article

VL - 26

SP - 328

EP - 341

JO - Journal of Intergrated Care

JF - Journal of Intergrated Care

SN - 1476-9018

IS - 4

ER -