Innocence lost: Care and control in dutch digital youth care

Esther Keymolen, Dennis Broeders

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

The Dutch National Reference Index is the political answer to public outcry about a number of well-publicised cases in which the tragic deaths of very small children were connected with a failing youth care system. The parallel with the tragic UK case of Victoria Climbié in 2003, which catalysed the reform and digitisation of the UK policy system of child and youth care, is striking. Analysing the development of the index in the Netherlands, we perceive a ‘double translation’: first, how public sentiment is translated into a database tool and, second, how nationally formulated aims and guidelines for the tool are translated into local practices. Where the national system is firmly rooted in the idea and ideal of the care for children at risk and uses tools of communication to achieve this, other functions are tagged on in the development of the local systems. The system at the local level enables professionals to monitor each other's decisions; there is a direct surveillance at the managerial level (on professionals) and an increased control of the municipality on the various agencies that constitute the local youth-care system. We conclude that using ICT in social policy is not just a power-neutral digitalisation of existing processes, but that it alters the character of these processes and brings along unforeseen functions and risks. The dominant goal of ‘care’ for children is supplemented with elements of ‘control’ within the organisation of local youth care. In this sense, the basic idea of the National Reference Index itself loses some of its innocence, too.
LanguageEnglish
Pages41-63
Number of pages23
JournalBritish Journal of Social Work
Volume43
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2013
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Patient Care Planning
Victoria
Netherlands
digitalization
Communication
Organizations
Databases
municipality
surveillance
death
reform
communication
Social Policy

Keywords

  • ContactPoint
  • ICT
  • National Reference Index
  • Youth care
  • control
  • surveillance

Cite this

@article{cdaf0ca2a2134ec1ba123691f4a08393,
title = "Innocence lost: Care and control in dutch digital youth care",
abstract = "The Dutch National Reference Index is the political answer to public outcry about a number of well-publicised cases in which the tragic deaths of very small children were connected with a failing youth care system. The parallel with the tragic UK case of Victoria Climbi{\'e} in 2003, which catalysed the reform and digitisation of the UK policy system of child and youth care, is striking. Analysing the development of the index in the Netherlands, we perceive a ‘double translation’: first, how public sentiment is translated into a database tool and, second, how nationally formulated aims and guidelines for the tool are translated into local practices. Where the national system is firmly rooted in the idea and ideal of the care for children at risk and uses tools of communication to achieve this, other functions are tagged on in the development of the local systems. The system at the local level enables professionals to monitor each other's decisions; there is a direct surveillance at the managerial level (on professionals) and an increased control of the municipality on the various agencies that constitute the local youth-care system. We conclude that using ICT in social policy is not just a power-neutral digitalisation of existing processes, but that it alters the character of these processes and brings along unforeseen functions and risks. The dominant goal of ‘care’ for children is supplemented with elements of ‘control’ within the organisation of local youth care. In this sense, the basic idea of the National Reference Index itself loses some of its innocence, too.",
keywords = "ContactPoint, ICT, National Reference Index, Youth care, control, surveillance",
author = "Esther Keymolen and Dennis Broeders",
year = "2013",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1093/bjsw/bcr169",
language = "English",
volume = "43",
pages = "41--63",
journal = "British Journal of Social Work",
issn = "0045-3102",
publisher = "Oxford University Press",
number = "1",

}

Innocence lost : Care and control in dutch digital youth care. / Keymolen, Esther; Broeders, Dennis.

In: British Journal of Social Work, Vol. 43, No. 1, 02.2013, p. 41-63.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Innocence lost

T2 - British Journal of Social Work

AU - Keymolen, Esther

AU - Broeders, Dennis

PY - 2013/2

Y1 - 2013/2

N2 - The Dutch National Reference Index is the political answer to public outcry about a number of well-publicised cases in which the tragic deaths of very small children were connected with a failing youth care system. The parallel with the tragic UK case of Victoria Climbié in 2003, which catalysed the reform and digitisation of the UK policy system of child and youth care, is striking. Analysing the development of the index in the Netherlands, we perceive a ‘double translation’: first, how public sentiment is translated into a database tool and, second, how nationally formulated aims and guidelines for the tool are translated into local practices. Where the national system is firmly rooted in the idea and ideal of the care for children at risk and uses tools of communication to achieve this, other functions are tagged on in the development of the local systems. The system at the local level enables professionals to monitor each other's decisions; there is a direct surveillance at the managerial level (on professionals) and an increased control of the municipality on the various agencies that constitute the local youth-care system. We conclude that using ICT in social policy is not just a power-neutral digitalisation of existing processes, but that it alters the character of these processes and brings along unforeseen functions and risks. The dominant goal of ‘care’ for children is supplemented with elements of ‘control’ within the organisation of local youth care. In this sense, the basic idea of the National Reference Index itself loses some of its innocence, too.

AB - The Dutch National Reference Index is the political answer to public outcry about a number of well-publicised cases in which the tragic deaths of very small children were connected with a failing youth care system. The parallel with the tragic UK case of Victoria Climbié in 2003, which catalysed the reform and digitisation of the UK policy system of child and youth care, is striking. Analysing the development of the index in the Netherlands, we perceive a ‘double translation’: first, how public sentiment is translated into a database tool and, second, how nationally formulated aims and guidelines for the tool are translated into local practices. Where the national system is firmly rooted in the idea and ideal of the care for children at risk and uses tools of communication to achieve this, other functions are tagged on in the development of the local systems. The system at the local level enables professionals to monitor each other's decisions; there is a direct surveillance at the managerial level (on professionals) and an increased control of the municipality on the various agencies that constitute the local youth-care system. We conclude that using ICT in social policy is not just a power-neutral digitalisation of existing processes, but that it alters the character of these processes and brings along unforeseen functions and risks. The dominant goal of ‘care’ for children is supplemented with elements of ‘control’ within the organisation of local youth care. In this sense, the basic idea of the National Reference Index itself loses some of its innocence, too.

KW - ContactPoint

KW - ICT

KW - National Reference Index

KW - Youth care

KW - control

KW - surveillance

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/innocence-lost-care-control-dutch-digital-youth-care

U2 - 10.1093/bjsw/bcr169

DO - 10.1093/bjsw/bcr169

M3 - Article

VL - 43

SP - 41

EP - 63

JO - British Journal of Social Work

JF - British Journal of Social Work

SN - 0045-3102

IS - 1

ER -