Meaningful mediation analysis

Plausible causal inference and informative communication

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Statistical mediation analysis has become the technique of choice in consumer research to make causal inferences about the influence of a treatment on an outcome via one or more mediators. This tutorial aims to strengthen two weak links that impede statistical mediation analysis from reaching its full potential. The first weak link is the path from mediator to outcome, which is a correlation. Six conditions are described that this correlation needs to meet in order to make plausible causal inferences: directionality, reliability, unconfoundedness, distinctiveness, power, and mediation. Recommendations are made to increase the plausibility of causal inferences based on statistical mediation analysis. Sweetspot analysis is proposed to establish whether an observed mediator-outcome correlation falls within the region of statistically meaningful correlations. The second weak link is the communication of mediation results. Four components of informative communication of mediation analysis are described: effect decomposition, effect size, difference testing, and data sharing. Recommendations are made to improve the communication of mediation analysis. A review of 166 recently published mediation analyses in the Journal of Consumer Research, a reanalysis of two published datasets, and Monte Carlo simulations support the conclusions and recommendations.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)692-716
JournalJournal of Consumer Research
Volume44
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2017

Fingerprint

causal analysis
mediation
communication
consumer research
Communication
Causal inference
Mediation
Causal Inference
simulation

Keywords

  • mediation analysis
  • causal inference
  • experiment
  • bias
  • knowledge accumulation

Cite this

@article{71646981a97848c6901ae2e92d9726a9,
title = "Meaningful mediation analysis: Plausible causal inference and informative communication",
abstract = "Statistical mediation analysis has become the technique of choice in consumer research to make causal inferences about the influence of a treatment on an outcome via one or more mediators. This tutorial aims to strengthen two weak links that impede statistical mediation analysis from reaching its full potential. The first weak link is the path from mediator to outcome, which is a correlation. Six conditions are described that this correlation needs to meet in order to make plausible causal inferences: directionality, reliability, unconfoundedness, distinctiveness, power, and mediation. Recommendations are made to increase the plausibility of causal inferences based on statistical mediation analysis. Sweetspot analysis is proposed to establish whether an observed mediator-outcome correlation falls within the region of statistically meaningful correlations. The second weak link is the communication of mediation results. Four components of informative communication of mediation analysis are described: effect decomposition, effect size, difference testing, and data sharing. Recommendations are made to improve the communication of mediation analysis. A review of 166 recently published mediation analyses in the Journal of Consumer Research, a reanalysis of two published datasets, and Monte Carlo simulations support the conclusions and recommendations.",
keywords = "mediation analysis, causal inference, experiment , bias, knowledge accumulation",
author = "Rik Pieters",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1093/jcr/ucx081",
language = "English",
volume = "44",
pages = "692--716",
journal = "Journal of Consumer Research",
issn = "0093-5301",
publisher = "University of Chicago",
number = "3",

}

Meaningful mediation analysis : Plausible causal inference and informative communication. / Pieters, Rik.

In: Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 44, No. 3, 10.2017, p. 692-716.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Meaningful mediation analysis

T2 - Plausible causal inference and informative communication

AU - Pieters, Rik

PY - 2017/10

Y1 - 2017/10

N2 - Statistical mediation analysis has become the technique of choice in consumer research to make causal inferences about the influence of a treatment on an outcome via one or more mediators. This tutorial aims to strengthen two weak links that impede statistical mediation analysis from reaching its full potential. The first weak link is the path from mediator to outcome, which is a correlation. Six conditions are described that this correlation needs to meet in order to make plausible causal inferences: directionality, reliability, unconfoundedness, distinctiveness, power, and mediation. Recommendations are made to increase the plausibility of causal inferences based on statistical mediation analysis. Sweetspot analysis is proposed to establish whether an observed mediator-outcome correlation falls within the region of statistically meaningful correlations. The second weak link is the communication of mediation results. Four components of informative communication of mediation analysis are described: effect decomposition, effect size, difference testing, and data sharing. Recommendations are made to improve the communication of mediation analysis. A review of 166 recently published mediation analyses in the Journal of Consumer Research, a reanalysis of two published datasets, and Monte Carlo simulations support the conclusions and recommendations.

AB - Statistical mediation analysis has become the technique of choice in consumer research to make causal inferences about the influence of a treatment on an outcome via one or more mediators. This tutorial aims to strengthen two weak links that impede statistical mediation analysis from reaching its full potential. The first weak link is the path from mediator to outcome, which is a correlation. Six conditions are described that this correlation needs to meet in order to make plausible causal inferences: directionality, reliability, unconfoundedness, distinctiveness, power, and mediation. Recommendations are made to increase the plausibility of causal inferences based on statistical mediation analysis. Sweetspot analysis is proposed to establish whether an observed mediator-outcome correlation falls within the region of statistically meaningful correlations. The second weak link is the communication of mediation results. Four components of informative communication of mediation analysis are described: effect decomposition, effect size, difference testing, and data sharing. Recommendations are made to improve the communication of mediation analysis. A review of 166 recently published mediation analyses in the Journal of Consumer Research, a reanalysis of two published datasets, and Monte Carlo simulations support the conclusions and recommendations.

KW - mediation analysis

KW - causal inference

KW - experiment

KW - bias

KW - knowledge accumulation

U2 - 10.1093/jcr/ucx081

DO - 10.1093/jcr/ucx081

M3 - Article

VL - 44

SP - 692

EP - 716

JO - Journal of Consumer Research

JF - Journal of Consumer Research

SN - 0093-5301

IS - 3

ER -