Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’?

Mijke Houwerzijl, L.E. Berntsen

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Houwerzijl and Berntsen explore the tensions between the EU legal framework governing posting and the realities on the ground. Too often, they argue, policy debates are dominated by a narrow understanding of posting, which focuses mainly on legal definitions rather than on the practices of posting actors. Combining legal analysis with primary interviews with posting actors, as well as drawing on the empirical literature on posting, Houwerzijl and Berntsen show that firms see posting as a way to engage a highly flexible and exploitable workforce. Firm posting practices centre around reducing labour costs and increasing flexibility, if necessary by evading local labour laws and
norms, as a way of gaining a competitive edge. Posting is not so much a discrete form of employment as it is one of several parallel recruitment modalities used to establish a flexible European labour market governed by neither host nor sending country. This contrasts with the underlying assumptions behind the European legislation and CJEU case law, which insist that posted workers are embedded in their home country labour markets and never enter into the host country labour market. The chapter offers up hope in the form of regulatory initiatives being undertaken at the EU level, based on the now increasingly influential ‘broad’ notion of posting: these initiatives, however, remain politically controversial.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationPosted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement
EditorsJens Arnholtz, Nathan Lillie
PublisherRoutledge
Chapter8
Pages147 - 166
Number of pages19
ISBN (Electronic)978-0-429-03102-1
ISBN (Print)978-0-367-14271-1
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2020

Publication series

NameRoutledge Research in Employment Relations

Fingerprint

labor market
labor
worker
EU
firm
local law
labor law
European market
labor costs
case law
flexibility
legislation
interview
literature

Cite this

Houwerzijl, M., & Berntsen, L. E. (Accepted/In press). Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’? In J. Arnholtz, & N. Lillie (Eds.), Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement (pp. 147 - 166). (Routledge Research in Employment Relations). Routledge.
Houwerzijl, Mijke ; Berntsen, L.E. / Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’?. Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement. editor / Jens Arnholtz ; Nathan Lillie. Routledge, 2020. pp. 147 - 166 (Routledge Research in Employment Relations).
@inbook{b52772ae90fb48208ffd9ac063a0d4bb,
title = "Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’?",
abstract = "Houwerzijl and Berntsen explore the tensions between the EU legal framework governing posting and the realities on the ground. Too often, they argue, policy debates are dominated by a narrow understanding of posting, which focuses mainly on legal definitions rather than on the practices of posting actors. Combining legal analysis with primary interviews with posting actors, as well as drawing on the empirical literature on posting, Houwerzijl and Berntsen show that firms see posting as a way to engage a highly flexible and exploitable workforce. Firm posting practices centre around reducing labour costs and increasing flexibility, if necessary by evading local labour laws andnorms, as a way of gaining a competitive edge. Posting is not so much a discrete form of employment as it is one of several parallel recruitment modalities used to establish a flexible European labour market governed by neither host nor sending country. This contrasts with the underlying assumptions behind the European legislation and CJEU case law, which insist that posted workers are embedded in their home country labour markets and never enter into the host country labour market. The chapter offers up hope in the form of regulatory initiatives being undertaken at the EU level, based on the now increasingly influential ‘broad’ notion of posting: these initiatives, however, remain politically controversial.",
author = "Mijke Houwerzijl and L.E. Berntsen",
year = "2020",
language = "English",
isbn = "978-0-367-14271-1",
series = "Routledge Research in Employment Relations",
publisher = "Routledge",
pages = "147 -- 166",
editor = "Jens Arnholtz and Nathan Lillie",
booktitle = "Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

Houwerzijl, M & Berntsen, LE 2020, Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’? in J Arnholtz & N Lillie (eds), Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement. Routledge Research in Employment Relations, Routledge, pp. 147 - 166.

Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’? / Houwerzijl, Mijke; Berntsen, L.E.

Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement. ed. / Jens Arnholtz; Nathan Lillie. Routledge, 2020. p. 147 - 166 (Routledge Research in Employment Relations).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientificpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’?

AU - Houwerzijl, Mijke

AU - Berntsen, L.E.

PY - 2020

Y1 - 2020

N2 - Houwerzijl and Berntsen explore the tensions between the EU legal framework governing posting and the realities on the ground. Too often, they argue, policy debates are dominated by a narrow understanding of posting, which focuses mainly on legal definitions rather than on the practices of posting actors. Combining legal analysis with primary interviews with posting actors, as well as drawing on the empirical literature on posting, Houwerzijl and Berntsen show that firms see posting as a way to engage a highly flexible and exploitable workforce. Firm posting practices centre around reducing labour costs and increasing flexibility, if necessary by evading local labour laws andnorms, as a way of gaining a competitive edge. Posting is not so much a discrete form of employment as it is one of several parallel recruitment modalities used to establish a flexible European labour market governed by neither host nor sending country. This contrasts with the underlying assumptions behind the European legislation and CJEU case law, which insist that posted workers are embedded in their home country labour markets and never enter into the host country labour market. The chapter offers up hope in the form of regulatory initiatives being undertaken at the EU level, based on the now increasingly influential ‘broad’ notion of posting: these initiatives, however, remain politically controversial.

AB - Houwerzijl and Berntsen explore the tensions between the EU legal framework governing posting and the realities on the ground. Too often, they argue, policy debates are dominated by a narrow understanding of posting, which focuses mainly on legal definitions rather than on the practices of posting actors. Combining legal analysis with primary interviews with posting actors, as well as drawing on the empirical literature on posting, Houwerzijl and Berntsen show that firms see posting as a way to engage a highly flexible and exploitable workforce. Firm posting practices centre around reducing labour costs and increasing flexibility, if necessary by evading local labour laws andnorms, as a way of gaining a competitive edge. Posting is not so much a discrete form of employment as it is one of several parallel recruitment modalities used to establish a flexible European labour market governed by neither host nor sending country. This contrasts with the underlying assumptions behind the European legislation and CJEU case law, which insist that posted workers are embedded in their home country labour markets and never enter into the host country labour market. The chapter offers up hope in the form of regulatory initiatives being undertaken at the EU level, based on the now increasingly influential ‘broad’ notion of posting: these initiatives, however, remain politically controversial.

M3 - Chapter

SN - 978-0-367-14271-1

T3 - Routledge Research in Employment Relations

SP - 147

EP - 166

BT - Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement

A2 - Arnholtz, Jens

A2 - Lillie, Nathan

PB - Routledge

ER -

Houwerzijl M, Berntsen LE. Posting of Workers: From a Blurred Notion Associated with ‘Cheap Labour’ to a Tool for ‘Fair Labour Mobility’? In Arnholtz J, Lillie N, editors, Posted Work in the European Union, The Political Economy of Free Movement. Routledge. 2020. p. 147 - 166. (Routledge Research in Employment Relations).