Principles-based legislation in context

A Dworkinian perspective

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

Abstract

Principles-based legislation (PBL) is sometimes presented as an alternative regulatory instrument to counter aggressive tax planning, as a remedy for the failure of rules-based legislation. Rules are almost sacred in (tax) law - for rules are thought to secure legal certainty (and equality) for citizens. Nonetheless, a system of pre-established rules has its drawbacks because one can play by the rules but also bend the rules. This a well-known reality in tax.
Counteracting tax avoidance is one of tax authorities’ major concern nowadays. However, there are various instruments in the legislature’s toolkit. Principles-based drafting is but one of them. Here we will deal with fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, before turning to PBL.
This paper will investigate the meaning of these instruments from the perspective of (legal) principles as advocated by the legal philosopher Dworkin. Fundamental legal principles embody the dimension of morality (justice, fairness) in law. They are regulative ideals that make morally sound positive law possible. They constitute a normative framework for legislation: legislation should be aimed at realizing these principles.
Original languageEnglish
PublisherSSRN
Pages1-27
Number of pages27
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2018

Fingerprint

taxes
legislation
positive law
tax law
morality
fairness
remedies
equality
justice
citizen
planning
Law

Keywords

  • Principles-based legislation, tax complexity, tax avoidance, fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, normative legal principles

Cite this

@techreport{25252ca77ca7447585fd016a01929cd8,
title = "Principles-based legislation in context: A Dworkinian perspective",
abstract = "Principles-based legislation (PBL) is sometimes presented as an alternative regulatory instrument to counter aggressive tax planning, as a remedy for the failure of rules-based legislation. Rules are almost sacred in (tax) law - for rules are thought to secure legal certainty (and equality) for citizens. Nonetheless, a system of pre-established rules has its drawbacks because one can play by the rules but also bend the rules. This a well-known reality in tax. Counteracting tax avoidance is one of tax authorities’ major concern nowadays. However, there are various instruments in the legislature’s toolkit. Principles-based drafting is but one of them. Here we will deal with fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, before turning to PBL.This paper will investigate the meaning of these instruments from the perspective of (legal) principles as advocated by the legal philosopher Dworkin. Fundamental legal principles embody the dimension of morality (justice, fairness) in law. They are regulative ideals that make morally sound positive law possible. They constitute a normative framework for legislation: legislation should be aimed at realizing these principles.",
keywords = "Principles-based legislation, tax complexity, tax avoidance, fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, normative legal principles",
author = "Sonja Dusarduijn and Hans Gribnau",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
language = "English",
pages = "1--27",
publisher = "SSRN",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "SSRN",

}

Principles-based legislation in context : A Dworkinian perspective. / Dusarduijn, Sonja; Gribnau, Hans.

SSRN, 2018. p. 1-27.

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - Principles-based legislation in context

T2 - A Dworkinian perspective

AU - Dusarduijn, Sonja

AU - Gribnau, Hans

PY - 2018/10

Y1 - 2018/10

N2 - Principles-based legislation (PBL) is sometimes presented as an alternative regulatory instrument to counter aggressive tax planning, as a remedy for the failure of rules-based legislation. Rules are almost sacred in (tax) law - for rules are thought to secure legal certainty (and equality) for citizens. Nonetheless, a system of pre-established rules has its drawbacks because one can play by the rules but also bend the rules. This a well-known reality in tax. Counteracting tax avoidance is one of tax authorities’ major concern nowadays. However, there are various instruments in the legislature’s toolkit. Principles-based drafting is but one of them. Here we will deal with fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, before turning to PBL.This paper will investigate the meaning of these instruments from the perspective of (legal) principles as advocated by the legal philosopher Dworkin. Fundamental legal principles embody the dimension of morality (justice, fairness) in law. They are regulative ideals that make morally sound positive law possible. They constitute a normative framework for legislation: legislation should be aimed at realizing these principles.

AB - Principles-based legislation (PBL) is sometimes presented as an alternative regulatory instrument to counter aggressive tax planning, as a remedy for the failure of rules-based legislation. Rules are almost sacred in (tax) law - for rules are thought to secure legal certainty (and equality) for citizens. Nonetheless, a system of pre-established rules has its drawbacks because one can play by the rules but also bend the rules. This a well-known reality in tax. Counteracting tax avoidance is one of tax authorities’ major concern nowadays. However, there are various instruments in the legislature’s toolkit. Principles-based drafting is but one of them. Here we will deal with fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, before turning to PBL.This paper will investigate the meaning of these instruments from the perspective of (legal) principles as advocated by the legal philosopher Dworkin. Fundamental legal principles embody the dimension of morality (justice, fairness) in law. They are regulative ideals that make morally sound positive law possible. They constitute a normative framework for legislation: legislation should be aimed at realizing these principles.

KW - Principles-based legislation, tax complexity, tax avoidance, fictions, standards, general anti-avoidance rules, normative legal principles

M3 - Discussion paper

SP - 1

EP - 27

BT - Principles-based legislation in context

PB - SSRN

ER -