Reconsidering the roles of gratitude and indebtedness in social exchange

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

40 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Receiving favors is often a mixed blessing and commonly triggers two emotions: the positive emotion gratitude and negative emotion indebtedness. In three studies, we examined the hypothesis that gratitude and indebtedness have distinct functions in social exchange. Contrary to current views, we believe that the function of gratitude does not primarily reside in facilitating social exchange. Instead, we propose that indebtedness motivates people to repay favours received, and thus accounts for most of the prosocial effects commonly attributed to gratitude. On the other hand consistent with current views, we believe that gratitude signals the potential for developing a relationship and fosters proximity seeking. Supporting these assumptions, in Study 1 we found that gratitude and indebtedness were associated with aspects of the favour that reflect the concern for relationship and the level of inequity. Studies 2 and 3 provided causal support for these relations, and revealed the unique associations between gratitude and the motivation of proximity seeking, and between indebtedness and the motivation to reciprocate. We argue that this functional distinction has escaped research attention as gratitude and indebtedness are naturally correlated because they stem from the same eliciting event. To appreciate this functional distinction, both emotions should be studied simultaneously in the context of social exchange.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)760-772
JournalCognition and Emotion
Volume32
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2018

Fingerprint

Gratitude
Indebtedness
Emotion
Proximity
Causal
Trigger
Blessing

Keywords

  • Gratitude
  • indebtedness
  • social exchange
  • reciprocity
  • social relationship
  • PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR
  • EMOTION SPECIFICITY
  • MECHANICAL TURK
  • RECIPROCITY
  • EVOLUTION
  • HELP
  • DETERMINANTS
  • MAINTENANCE
  • ALTRUISM
  • VALENCE

Cite this

@article{45e247d1cf4343858caa015415c9d9fc,
title = "Reconsidering the roles of gratitude and indebtedness in social exchange",
abstract = "Receiving favors is often a mixed blessing and commonly triggers two emotions: the positive emotion gratitude and negative emotion indebtedness. In three studies, we examined the hypothesis that gratitude and indebtedness have distinct functions in social exchange. Contrary to current views, we believe that the function of gratitude does not primarily reside in facilitating social exchange. Instead, we propose that indebtedness motivates people to repay favours received, and thus accounts for most of the prosocial effects commonly attributed to gratitude. On the other hand consistent with current views, we believe that gratitude signals the potential for developing a relationship and fosters proximity seeking. Supporting these assumptions, in Study 1 we found that gratitude and indebtedness were associated with aspects of the favour that reflect the concern for relationship and the level of inequity. Studies 2 and 3 provided causal support for these relations, and revealed the unique associations between gratitude and the motivation of proximity seeking, and between indebtedness and the motivation to reciprocate. We argue that this functional distinction has escaped research attention as gratitude and indebtedness are naturally correlated because they stem from the same eliciting event. To appreciate this functional distinction, both emotions should be studied simultaneously in the context of social exchange.",
keywords = "Gratitude, indebtedness, social exchange, reciprocity, social relationship, PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR, EMOTION SPECIFICITY, MECHANICAL TURK, RECIPROCITY, EVOLUTION, HELP, DETERMINANTS, MAINTENANCE, ALTRUISM, VALENCE",
author = "C. Peng and R.M.A. Nelissen and M. Zeelenberg",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1080/02699931.2017.1353484",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "760--772",
journal = "Cognition and Emotion",
issn = "0269-9931",
publisher = "Psychology Press Ltd",
number = "4",

}

Reconsidering the roles of gratitude and indebtedness in social exchange. / Peng, C.; Nelissen, R.M.A.; Zeelenberg, M.

In: Cognition and Emotion, Vol. 32, No. 4, 2018, p. 760-772.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reconsidering the roles of gratitude and indebtedness in social exchange

AU - Peng, C.

AU - Nelissen, R.M.A.

AU - Zeelenberg, M.

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Receiving favors is often a mixed blessing and commonly triggers two emotions: the positive emotion gratitude and negative emotion indebtedness. In three studies, we examined the hypothesis that gratitude and indebtedness have distinct functions in social exchange. Contrary to current views, we believe that the function of gratitude does not primarily reside in facilitating social exchange. Instead, we propose that indebtedness motivates people to repay favours received, and thus accounts for most of the prosocial effects commonly attributed to gratitude. On the other hand consistent with current views, we believe that gratitude signals the potential for developing a relationship and fosters proximity seeking. Supporting these assumptions, in Study 1 we found that gratitude and indebtedness were associated with aspects of the favour that reflect the concern for relationship and the level of inequity. Studies 2 and 3 provided causal support for these relations, and revealed the unique associations between gratitude and the motivation of proximity seeking, and between indebtedness and the motivation to reciprocate. We argue that this functional distinction has escaped research attention as gratitude and indebtedness are naturally correlated because they stem from the same eliciting event. To appreciate this functional distinction, both emotions should be studied simultaneously in the context of social exchange.

AB - Receiving favors is often a mixed blessing and commonly triggers two emotions: the positive emotion gratitude and negative emotion indebtedness. In three studies, we examined the hypothesis that gratitude and indebtedness have distinct functions in social exchange. Contrary to current views, we believe that the function of gratitude does not primarily reside in facilitating social exchange. Instead, we propose that indebtedness motivates people to repay favours received, and thus accounts for most of the prosocial effects commonly attributed to gratitude. On the other hand consistent with current views, we believe that gratitude signals the potential for developing a relationship and fosters proximity seeking. Supporting these assumptions, in Study 1 we found that gratitude and indebtedness were associated with aspects of the favour that reflect the concern for relationship and the level of inequity. Studies 2 and 3 provided causal support for these relations, and revealed the unique associations between gratitude and the motivation of proximity seeking, and between indebtedness and the motivation to reciprocate. We argue that this functional distinction has escaped research attention as gratitude and indebtedness are naturally correlated because they stem from the same eliciting event. To appreciate this functional distinction, both emotions should be studied simultaneously in the context of social exchange.

KW - Gratitude

KW - indebtedness

KW - social exchange

KW - reciprocity

KW - social relationship

KW - PROSOCIAL BEHAVIOR

KW - EMOTION SPECIFICITY

KW - MECHANICAL TURK

KW - RECIPROCITY

KW - EVOLUTION

KW - HELP

KW - DETERMINANTS

KW - MAINTENANCE

KW - ALTRUISM

KW - VALENCE

U2 - 10.1080/02699931.2017.1353484

DO - 10.1080/02699931.2017.1353484

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 760

EP - 772

JO - Cognition and Emotion

JF - Cognition and Emotion

SN - 0269-9931

IS - 4

ER -