Rethinking the Essential Facilities Doctrine for the EU Digital Economy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientific

Abstract

The essential facilities doctrine forms an important part of EU competition law.
Although it has not been used recently in EU competition enforcement, the doctrine is regularly referred to in EU policy discussions as a tool to open up markets in which ‘tech giants’ act as gatekeepers to businesses and consumers. Considering that the digital economy is not driven by physical infrastructures, such as the bridges in the US Terminal Railroad case from which the essential facilities doctrine originates, other assets like data or rankings – considered as the backbone of many digital markets – may become the subject of essential facilities claims. The article explores how the essential facilities doctrine can be rethought in order to be effectively applied to such assets in the EU digital economy. Attention is paid to market characteristics, the recent Google
competition cases seemingly bypassing the essential facilities doctrine, and legislative and policy developments regulating access outside EU competition law. To revive the essential facilities doctrine for the EU digital economy, suggestions are made as to how its application can be better aligned with the underlying economic interests at stake.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)33-72
JournalRevue juridique Thémis de l'Université de Montréal
Volume53
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

doctrine
EU
economy
assets
market
EU policy
Law
gatekeeper
railroad
development policy
ranking
infrastructure
economics

Cite this

@article{8121259006264b159f3a77ceab048d42,
title = "Rethinking the Essential Facilities Doctrine for the EU Digital Economy",
abstract = "The essential facilities doctrine forms an important part of EU competition law.Although it has not been used recently in EU competition enforcement, the doctrine is regularly referred to in EU policy discussions as a tool to open up markets in which ‘tech giants’ act as gatekeepers to businesses and consumers. Considering that the digital economy is not driven by physical infrastructures, such as the bridges in the US Terminal Railroad case from which the essential facilities doctrine originates, other assets like data or rankings – considered as the backbone of many digital markets – may become the subject of essential facilities claims. The article explores how the essential facilities doctrine can be rethought in order to be effectively applied to such assets in the EU digital economy. Attention is paid to market characteristics, the recent Googlecompetition cases seemingly bypassing the essential facilities doctrine, and legislative and policy developments regulating access outside EU competition law. To revive the essential facilities doctrine for the EU digital economy, suggestions are made as to how its application can be better aligned with the underlying economic interests at stake.",
author = "Inge Graef",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
volume = "53",
pages = "33--72",
journal = "Revue juridique Th{\'e}mis de l'Universit{\'e} de Montr{\'e}al",
number = "1",

}

Rethinking the Essential Facilities Doctrine for the EU Digital Economy. / Graef, Inge.

In: Revue juridique Thémis de l'Université de Montréal , Vol. 53, No. 1, 2019, p. 33-72.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientific

TY - JOUR

T1 - Rethinking the Essential Facilities Doctrine for the EU Digital Economy

AU - Graef, Inge

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - The essential facilities doctrine forms an important part of EU competition law.Although it has not been used recently in EU competition enforcement, the doctrine is regularly referred to in EU policy discussions as a tool to open up markets in which ‘tech giants’ act as gatekeepers to businesses and consumers. Considering that the digital economy is not driven by physical infrastructures, such as the bridges in the US Terminal Railroad case from which the essential facilities doctrine originates, other assets like data or rankings – considered as the backbone of many digital markets – may become the subject of essential facilities claims. The article explores how the essential facilities doctrine can be rethought in order to be effectively applied to such assets in the EU digital economy. Attention is paid to market characteristics, the recent Googlecompetition cases seemingly bypassing the essential facilities doctrine, and legislative and policy developments regulating access outside EU competition law. To revive the essential facilities doctrine for the EU digital economy, suggestions are made as to how its application can be better aligned with the underlying economic interests at stake.

AB - The essential facilities doctrine forms an important part of EU competition law.Although it has not been used recently in EU competition enforcement, the doctrine is regularly referred to in EU policy discussions as a tool to open up markets in which ‘tech giants’ act as gatekeepers to businesses and consumers. Considering that the digital economy is not driven by physical infrastructures, such as the bridges in the US Terminal Railroad case from which the essential facilities doctrine originates, other assets like data or rankings – considered as the backbone of many digital markets – may become the subject of essential facilities claims. The article explores how the essential facilities doctrine can be rethought in order to be effectively applied to such assets in the EU digital economy. Attention is paid to market characteristics, the recent Googlecompetition cases seemingly bypassing the essential facilities doctrine, and legislative and policy developments regulating access outside EU competition law. To revive the essential facilities doctrine for the EU digital economy, suggestions are made as to how its application can be better aligned with the underlying economic interests at stake.

M3 - Article

VL - 53

SP - 33

EP - 72

JO - Revue juridique Thémis de l'Université de Montréal

JF - Revue juridique Thémis de l'Université de Montréal

IS - 1

ER -