Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption

Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientificpeer-review

Abstract

It would be easy to dismiss the theme of this book, Die Letzte am Schafott,
as no more than an expression of a Catholic triumphant attitude. During the
French revolution, possessions of convents were confiscated and whoever
resisted was sentenced to death and executed under the guillotine. The French
Revolution would be no more than a demonstration of the barbarous attitude
of the idolatry of Reason over against the devotion to true faith. The story, however,
goes far deeper than that. This becomes clear when we focus on two of
the main characters: Two young girls, strongly differing in temperament and
background; and two spiritual leaders in the convent diametrically opposed
to one another. We will note that the story contains a sharp criticism of traditional
Catholic ideas about self-sacrifice and martyrdom. Simultaneously, the
story offers a passionate picture of true martyrdom, which can only be reached
by acknowledging existential fear and a deep love of life.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationSacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity
Subtitle of host publicationFrom Nationalism and Nonviolence to Health Care and Harry Potter
EditorsJoachim Duyndam, Anne-Marie Korte, Marcel Poorthuis
Place of PublicationLeiden
PublisherBrill
Pages241-254
Number of pages15
ISBN (Print)9789004332065
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2016

Publication series

NameStudies in Theology and Religion
PublisherBrill
Volume22
ISSN (Print)1566-208X

Fingerprint

Redemption
Song
Convents
Self-sacrifice
Martyrdom
Forts
Possession
Devotion
Criticism
Revolution
Temperament
Faith
Idolatry

Keywords

  • Sacrifice
  • autonomy
  • modernity

Cite this

Poorthuis, M. (2016). Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption: Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold. In J. Duyndam, A-M. Korte, & M. Poorthuis (Eds.), Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity: From Nationalism and Nonviolence to Health Care and Harry Potter (pp. 241-254). (Studies in Theology and Religion; Vol. 22). Leiden: Brill.
Poorthuis, Marcel. / Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption : Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold. Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity: From Nationalism and Nonviolence to Health Care and Harry Potter. editor / Joachim Duyndam ; Anne-Marie Korte ; Marcel Poorthuis. Leiden : Brill, 2016. pp. 241-254 (Studies in Theology and Religion).
@inbook{9658a42e1c694415ba2f1bb9e798abbb,
title = "Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption: Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold",
abstract = "It would be easy to dismiss the theme of this book, Die Letzte am Schafott,as no more than an expression of a Catholic triumphant attitude. During theFrench revolution, possessions of convents were confiscated and whoeverresisted was sentenced to death and executed under the guillotine. The FrenchRevolution would be no more than a demonstration of the barbarous attitudeof the idolatry of Reason over against the devotion to true faith. The story, however,goes far deeper than that. This becomes clear when we focus on two ofthe main characters: Two young girls, strongly differing in temperament andbackground; and two spiritual leaders in the convent diametrically opposedto one another. We will note that the story contains a sharp criticism of traditionalCatholic ideas about self-sacrifice and martyrdom. Simultaneously, thestory offers a passionate picture of true martyrdom, which can only be reachedby acknowledging existential fear and a deep love of life.",
keywords = "Sacrifice, autonomy, modernity",
author = "Marcel Poorthuis",
year = "2016",
month = "10",
language = "English",
isbn = "9789004332065",
series = "Studies in Theology and Religion",
publisher = "Brill",
pages = "241--254",
editor = "Joachim Duyndam and Anne-Marie Korte and Marcel Poorthuis",
booktitle = "Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity",
address = "Netherlands",

}

Poorthuis, M 2016, Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption: Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold. in J Duyndam, A-M Korte & M Poorthuis (eds), Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity: From Nationalism and Nonviolence to Health Care and Harry Potter. Studies in Theology and Religion, vol. 22, Brill, Leiden, pp. 241-254.

Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption : Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold. / Poorthuis, Marcel.

Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity: From Nationalism and Nonviolence to Health Care and Harry Potter. ed. / Joachim Duyndam; Anne-Marie Korte; Marcel Poorthuis. Leiden : Brill, 2016. p. 241-254 (Studies in Theology and Religion; Vol. 22).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientificpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption

T2 - Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold

AU - Poorthuis, Marcel

PY - 2016/10

Y1 - 2016/10

N2 - It would be easy to dismiss the theme of this book, Die Letzte am Schafott,as no more than an expression of a Catholic triumphant attitude. During theFrench revolution, possessions of convents were confiscated and whoeverresisted was sentenced to death and executed under the guillotine. The FrenchRevolution would be no more than a demonstration of the barbarous attitudeof the idolatry of Reason over against the devotion to true faith. The story, however,goes far deeper than that. This becomes clear when we focus on two ofthe main characters: Two young girls, strongly differing in temperament andbackground; and two spiritual leaders in the convent diametrically opposedto one another. We will note that the story contains a sharp criticism of traditionalCatholic ideas about self-sacrifice and martyrdom. Simultaneously, thestory offers a passionate picture of true martyrdom, which can only be reachedby acknowledging existential fear and a deep love of life.

AB - It would be easy to dismiss the theme of this book, Die Letzte am Schafott,as no more than an expression of a Catholic triumphant attitude. During theFrench revolution, possessions of convents were confiscated and whoeverresisted was sentenced to death and executed under the guillotine. The FrenchRevolution would be no more than a demonstration of the barbarous attitudeof the idolatry of Reason over against the devotion to true faith. The story, however,goes far deeper than that. This becomes clear when we focus on two ofthe main characters: Two young girls, strongly differing in temperament andbackground; and two spiritual leaders in the convent diametrically opposedto one another. We will note that the story contains a sharp criticism of traditionalCatholic ideas about self-sacrifice and martyrdom. Simultaneously, thestory offers a passionate picture of true martyrdom, which can only be reachedby acknowledging existential fear and a deep love of life.

KW - Sacrifice

KW - autonomy

KW - modernity

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9789004332065

T3 - Studies in Theology and Religion

SP - 241

EP - 254

BT - Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity

A2 - Duyndam, Joachim

A2 - Korte, Anne-Marie

A2 - Poorthuis, Marcel

PB - Brill

CY - Leiden

ER -

Poorthuis M. Self-Sacrifice between Constraint and Redemption: Gertrud von Le Fort’s The Song at the Scaffold. In Duyndam J, Korte A-M, Poorthuis M, editors, Sacrifice in modernity: community, ritual, identity: From Nationalism and Nonviolence to Health Care and Harry Potter. Leiden: Brill. 2016. p. 241-254. (Studies in Theology and Religion).