Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game

Jacob Engwerda

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

354 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This note analyzes in a fishery management problem the effects of relaxing one of the usual assumptions in the literature of dynamic games. Specifically, the assumption that players restrict to strategies that stabilize the system. Previous works in the literature have shown that feedback Nash equilibria can exist in which a player can improve unilaterally by choosing a feedback control for which the closed-loop system is unstable. This paper considers in some more detail the
implication this setting has in the framework of a simple fishery management.
It is shown that if the fishermen are not short-sighted in their valuation of future profits, the considered approach implies a division of them into two groups. One group going for maximal profits and the other group taking care of the imposed stability constraint. To see how noise might impact these results we additionally consider a framework where fishermen take into account the possibility that the fish growth might be corrupted by external factors. We consider a deterministic approach of dealing with noise in this set-up. The model predicts that the more people are involved in the group taking care of the stabilization constraint, the less active they get. Furthermore it predicts that the natural reaction of any of these persons is to increase his activities if he expects more noise. But that this activity is reduced, and partly replaced by more active control policies by group members, if the size of the group increases. Activity of fishermen going for maximal profits is not affected by noise expectations.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherCentER, Center for Economic Research
Number of pages22
Volume2017-031
Publication statusPublished - 9 Aug 2017

Publication series

NameCentER Discussion Paper
Volume2017-031

Fingerprint

Management games
Fisheries management
Profit
Stabilization
External factors
Feedback control
Nash equilibrium
Fish
Dynamic games

Keywords

  • fishery management
  • fishing strategies
  • linear quadratic differential games
  • feedback information structure
  • soft-constrained Nash equilibrium
  • infinte planning horizon

Cite this

Engwerda, J. (2017). Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game. (CentER Discussion Paper; Vol. 2017-031). Tilburg: CentER, Center for Economic Research.
Engwerda, Jacob. / Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game. Tilburg : CentER, Center for Economic Research, 2017. (CentER Discussion Paper).
@techreport{3823c5f71ade4bd2bcb8eff724c3d781,
title = "Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game",
abstract = "This note analyzes in a fishery management problem the effects of relaxing one of the usual assumptions in the literature of dynamic games. Specifically, the assumption that players restrict to strategies that stabilize the system. Previous works in the literature have shown that feedback Nash equilibria can exist in which a player can improve unilaterally by choosing a feedback control for which the closed-loop system is unstable. This paper considers in some more detail theimplication this setting has in the framework of a simple fishery management.It is shown that if the fishermen are not short-sighted in their valuation of future profits, the considered approach implies a division of them into two groups. One group going for maximal profits and the other group taking care of the imposed stability constraint. To see how noise might impact these results we additionally consider a framework where fishermen take into account the possibility that the fish growth might be corrupted by external factors. We consider a deterministic approach of dealing with noise in this set-up. The model predicts that the more people are involved in the group taking care of the stabilization constraint, the less active they get. Furthermore it predicts that the natural reaction of any of these persons is to increase his activities if he expects more noise. But that this activity is reduced, and partly replaced by more active control policies by group members, if the size of the group increases. Activity of fishermen going for maximal profits is not affected by noise expectations.",
keywords = "fishery management, fishing strategies, linear quadratic differential games, feedback information structure, soft-constrained Nash equilibrium, infinte planning horizon",
author = "Jacob Engwerda",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
day = "9",
language = "English",
volume = "2017-031",
series = "CentER Discussion Paper",
publisher = "CentER, Center for Economic Research",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "CentER, Center for Economic Research",

}

Engwerda, J 2017 'Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game' CentER Discussion Paper, vol. 2017-031, CentER, Center for Economic Research, Tilburg.

Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game. / Engwerda, Jacob.

Tilburg : CentER, Center for Economic Research, 2017. (CentER Discussion Paper; Vol. 2017-031).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game

AU - Engwerda, Jacob

PY - 2017/8/9

Y1 - 2017/8/9

N2 - This note analyzes in a fishery management problem the effects of relaxing one of the usual assumptions in the literature of dynamic games. Specifically, the assumption that players restrict to strategies that stabilize the system. Previous works in the literature have shown that feedback Nash equilibria can exist in which a player can improve unilaterally by choosing a feedback control for which the closed-loop system is unstable. This paper considers in some more detail theimplication this setting has in the framework of a simple fishery management.It is shown that if the fishermen are not short-sighted in their valuation of future profits, the considered approach implies a division of them into two groups. One group going for maximal profits and the other group taking care of the imposed stability constraint. To see how noise might impact these results we additionally consider a framework where fishermen take into account the possibility that the fish growth might be corrupted by external factors. We consider a deterministic approach of dealing with noise in this set-up. The model predicts that the more people are involved in the group taking care of the stabilization constraint, the less active they get. Furthermore it predicts that the natural reaction of any of these persons is to increase his activities if he expects more noise. But that this activity is reduced, and partly replaced by more active control policies by group members, if the size of the group increases. Activity of fishermen going for maximal profits is not affected by noise expectations.

AB - This note analyzes in a fishery management problem the effects of relaxing one of the usual assumptions in the literature of dynamic games. Specifically, the assumption that players restrict to strategies that stabilize the system. Previous works in the literature have shown that feedback Nash equilibria can exist in which a player can improve unilaterally by choosing a feedback control for which the closed-loop system is unstable. This paper considers in some more detail theimplication this setting has in the framework of a simple fishery management.It is shown that if the fishermen are not short-sighted in their valuation of future profits, the considered approach implies a division of them into two groups. One group going for maximal profits and the other group taking care of the imposed stability constraint. To see how noise might impact these results we additionally consider a framework where fishermen take into account the possibility that the fish growth might be corrupted by external factors. We consider a deterministic approach of dealing with noise in this set-up. The model predicts that the more people are involved in the group taking care of the stabilization constraint, the less active they get. Furthermore it predicts that the natural reaction of any of these persons is to increase his activities if he expects more noise. But that this activity is reduced, and partly replaced by more active control policies by group members, if the size of the group increases. Activity of fishermen going for maximal profits is not affected by noise expectations.

KW - fishery management

KW - fishing strategies

KW - linear quadratic differential games

KW - feedback information structure

KW - soft-constrained Nash equilibrium

KW - infinte planning horizon

M3 - Discussion paper

VL - 2017-031

T3 - CentER Discussion Paper

BT - Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game

PB - CentER, Center for Economic Research

CY - Tilburg

ER -

Engwerda J. Stabilization of an Uncertain Simple Fishery Management Game. Tilburg: CentER, Center for Economic Research. 2017 Aug 9. (CentER Discussion Paper).