Sustainability of government debt in the EMU

A.M. Lejour, J. Lukkezen, P. Veenendaal

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientificpeer-review

Abstract

This paper addresses the sustainability of government debt in Europe and is motivated by the recent debt increases following the crisis. We evaluate the sustainability in a time frame of ten years in which governments will be able to implement budget rules to get budget deficits under control. We develop a fiscal sustainability model for selected EMU member states that uses stochastic inputs based on historic data, closely following van Wijnbergen’s (van Wijnbergen and Budina, 2008) approach. We simulate the development of government debt as a percentage of GDP and show its expectation value including a confidence interval for a member state conditional on deficit reduction scenarios and the behaviour of other EMU member states. Using OECD projections as a baseline, we find that without additional fiscal consolidation and taking into account the public costs of ageing until the end of the projection period, budget deficits in all selected EMU countries will rise and sovereign debt is not sustainable, apart from Belgium. Even ignoring the cost of ageing, consolidation of sovereign debt is necessary for nearly all EMU countries. The consolidation proposed by the OECD would eliminate the doubts on sustainability of Belgium, Dutch, German, Italian, Portuguese and French bonds. For Ireland, Greece and Spain additional actions are required on top of the consolidation in the OECD projections. Together with a review of spillovers and stress-tests performed with our
model we conclude that coordination of fiscal policies in the EMU is necessary.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration
Place of PublicationCheltenham
PublisherEdward Elgar
Chapter4
Number of pages20
Publication statusPublished - 2011
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Consolidation
Sustainability
Government debt
Budget deficits
Belgium
Sovereign debt
Costs
Ireland
Spain
Scenarios
Fiscal sustainability
Confidence interval
Spillover
Debt
Stress test
Greece
Government
Fiscal consolidation
Fiscal policy

Keywords

  • EU
  • government debt
  • cross border spillovers
  • Euro area

Cite this

Lejour, A. M., Lukkezen, J., & Veenendaal, P. (2011). Sustainability of government debt in the EMU. In The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Lejour, A.M. ; Lukkezen, J. ; Veenendaal, P. / Sustainability of government debt in the EMU. The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar, 2011.
@inbook{b19522b6b59546d2a997e3c0fbc1fc16,
title = "Sustainability of government debt in the EMU",
abstract = "This paper addresses the sustainability of government debt in Europe and is motivated by the recent debt increases following the crisis. We evaluate the sustainability in a time frame of ten years in which governments will be able to implement budget rules to get budget deficits under control. We develop a fiscal sustainability model for selected EMU member states that uses stochastic inputs based on historic data, closely following van Wijnbergen’s (van Wijnbergen and Budina, 2008) approach. We simulate the development of government debt as a percentage of GDP and show its expectation value including a confidence interval for a member state conditional on deficit reduction scenarios and the behaviour of other EMU member states. Using OECD projections as a baseline, we find that without additional fiscal consolidation and taking into account the public costs of ageing until the end of the projection period, budget deficits in all selected EMU countries will rise and sovereign debt is not sustainable, apart from Belgium. Even ignoring the cost of ageing, consolidation of sovereign debt is necessary for nearly all EMU countries. The consolidation proposed by the OECD would eliminate the doubts on sustainability of Belgium, Dutch, German, Italian, Portuguese and French bonds. For Ireland, Greece and Spain additional actions are required on top of the consolidation in the OECD projections. Together with a review of spillovers and stress-tests performed with ourmodel we conclude that coordination of fiscal policies in the EMU is necessary.",
keywords = "EU, government debt, cross border spillovers, Euro area",
author = "A.M. Lejour and J. Lukkezen and P. Veenendaal",
year = "2011",
language = "English",
publisher = "Edward Elgar",
booktitle = "The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration",

}

Lejour, AM, Lukkezen, J & Veenendaal, P 2011, Sustainability of government debt in the EMU. in The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration. Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

Sustainability of government debt in the EMU. / Lejour, A.M.; Lukkezen, J.; Veenendaal, P.

The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar, 2011.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapterScientificpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Sustainability of government debt in the EMU

AU - Lejour, A.M.

AU - Lukkezen, J.

AU - Veenendaal, P.

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - This paper addresses the sustainability of government debt in Europe and is motivated by the recent debt increases following the crisis. We evaluate the sustainability in a time frame of ten years in which governments will be able to implement budget rules to get budget deficits under control. We develop a fiscal sustainability model for selected EMU member states that uses stochastic inputs based on historic data, closely following van Wijnbergen’s (van Wijnbergen and Budina, 2008) approach. We simulate the development of government debt as a percentage of GDP and show its expectation value including a confidence interval for a member state conditional on deficit reduction scenarios and the behaviour of other EMU member states. Using OECD projections as a baseline, we find that without additional fiscal consolidation and taking into account the public costs of ageing until the end of the projection period, budget deficits in all selected EMU countries will rise and sovereign debt is not sustainable, apart from Belgium. Even ignoring the cost of ageing, consolidation of sovereign debt is necessary for nearly all EMU countries. The consolidation proposed by the OECD would eliminate the doubts on sustainability of Belgium, Dutch, German, Italian, Portuguese and French bonds. For Ireland, Greece and Spain additional actions are required on top of the consolidation in the OECD projections. Together with a review of spillovers and stress-tests performed with ourmodel we conclude that coordination of fiscal policies in the EMU is necessary.

AB - This paper addresses the sustainability of government debt in Europe and is motivated by the recent debt increases following the crisis. We evaluate the sustainability in a time frame of ten years in which governments will be able to implement budget rules to get budget deficits under control. We develop a fiscal sustainability model for selected EMU member states that uses stochastic inputs based on historic data, closely following van Wijnbergen’s (van Wijnbergen and Budina, 2008) approach. We simulate the development of government debt as a percentage of GDP and show its expectation value including a confidence interval for a member state conditional on deficit reduction scenarios and the behaviour of other EMU member states. Using OECD projections as a baseline, we find that without additional fiscal consolidation and taking into account the public costs of ageing until the end of the projection period, budget deficits in all selected EMU countries will rise and sovereign debt is not sustainable, apart from Belgium. Even ignoring the cost of ageing, consolidation of sovereign debt is necessary for nearly all EMU countries. The consolidation proposed by the OECD would eliminate the doubts on sustainability of Belgium, Dutch, German, Italian, Portuguese and French bonds. For Ireland, Greece and Spain additional actions are required on top of the consolidation in the OECD projections. Together with a review of spillovers and stress-tests performed with ourmodel we conclude that coordination of fiscal policies in the EMU is necessary.

KW - EU

KW - government debt

KW - cross border spillovers

KW - Euro area

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?eid=2-s2.0-84879059949&partnerID=MN8TOARS

M3 - Chapter

BT - The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration

PB - Edward Elgar

CY - Cheltenham

ER -

Lejour AM, Lukkezen J, Veenendaal P. Sustainability of government debt in the EMU. In The Economic Crisis and the Process of European Integration. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. 2011