The birth of tax as a legal discipline

Hans Gribnau, H. Vording

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

Abstract

Adam Smith’s taxation maxims found fertile ground in the Netherlands in the early nineteenth century—a time of national tax reform. But as the century drew to an end, progressive liberal thinking parted from its British inspiration. John Stuart Mill’s ‘equality of sacrifice’ was rejected by Nicolaas Pierson, the leading political economist of his age, as being too individualistic. Instead, the German Historical School with its idea of an organic relation between state and citizens gave guidance, especially to Pieter Cort van der Linden’s work on taxation. Borrowing from the German concept of Rechtsstaat, he laid the foundations for tax as a legal discipline.
Original languageEnglish
Place of Publicationssrn.com
Pages1-23
Number of pages23
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 16 Feb 2017

Fingerprint

Taxation
Tax
John Stuart Mill
Guidance
Rechtsstaat
Borrowing
Equality
Economists
The Netherlands

Keywords

  • Adam Smith, taxation, the Netherlands, nineteenth century, progressive liberal thinking, John Stuart Mill, Pierson, German Historical School, Pieter Cort van der Linden, Rechtsstaat, tax complexity, legal doctrine.

Cite this

Gribnau, Hans ; Vording, H. / The birth of tax as a legal discipline. ssrn.com, 2017. pp. 1-23
@techreport{228f16632e0e455a861744c4af0e7315,
title = "The birth of tax as a legal discipline",
abstract = "Adam Smith’s taxation maxims found fertile ground in the Netherlands in the early nineteenth century—a time of national tax reform. But as the century drew to an end, progressive liberal thinking parted from its British inspiration. John Stuart Mill’s ‘equality of sacrifice’ was rejected by Nicolaas Pierson, the leading political economist of his age, as being too individualistic. Instead, the German Historical School with its idea of an organic relation between state and citizens gave guidance, especially to Pieter Cort van der Linden’s work on taxation. Borrowing from the German concept of Rechtsstaat, he laid the foundations for tax as a legal discipline.",
keywords = "Adam Smith, taxation, the Netherlands, nineteenth century, progressive liberal thinking, John Stuart Mill, Pierson, German Historical School, Pieter Cort van der Linden, Rechtsstaat, tax complexity, legal doctrine.",
author = "Hans Gribnau and H. Vording",
year = "2017",
month = "2",
day = "16",
doi = "10.2139/ssrn.2919003",
language = "English",
pages = "1--23",
type = "WorkingPaper",

}

The birth of tax as a legal discipline. / Gribnau, Hans; Vording, H.

ssrn.com, 2017. p. 1-23.

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - The birth of tax as a legal discipline

AU - Gribnau, Hans

AU - Vording, H.

PY - 2017/2/16

Y1 - 2017/2/16

N2 - Adam Smith’s taxation maxims found fertile ground in the Netherlands in the early nineteenth century—a time of national tax reform. But as the century drew to an end, progressive liberal thinking parted from its British inspiration. John Stuart Mill’s ‘equality of sacrifice’ was rejected by Nicolaas Pierson, the leading political economist of his age, as being too individualistic. Instead, the German Historical School with its idea of an organic relation between state and citizens gave guidance, especially to Pieter Cort van der Linden’s work on taxation. Borrowing from the German concept of Rechtsstaat, he laid the foundations for tax as a legal discipline.

AB - Adam Smith’s taxation maxims found fertile ground in the Netherlands in the early nineteenth century—a time of national tax reform. But as the century drew to an end, progressive liberal thinking parted from its British inspiration. John Stuart Mill’s ‘equality of sacrifice’ was rejected by Nicolaas Pierson, the leading political economist of his age, as being too individualistic. Instead, the German Historical School with its idea of an organic relation between state and citizens gave guidance, especially to Pieter Cort van der Linden’s work on taxation. Borrowing from the German concept of Rechtsstaat, he laid the foundations for tax as a legal discipline.

KW - Adam Smith, taxation, the Netherlands, nineteenth century, progressive liberal thinking, John Stuart Mill, Pierson, German Historical School, Pieter Cort van der Linden, Rechtsstaat, tax complexity, legal doctrine.

UR - http://ssrn.com/abstract=2919003

U2 - 10.2139/ssrn.2919003

DO - 10.2139/ssrn.2919003

M3 - Discussion paper

SP - 1

EP - 23

BT - The birth of tax as a legal discipline

CY - ssrn.com

ER -