The flywheel effect of gender role expectations in diverse work groups

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articleScientificpeer-review

1 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Popular press suggests that gender diversity benefits the performance of work groups. However, decades of research indicate that such performance benefits of gender diversity are anything but a given. To account for this incongruity, in this conceptual paper we argue that the performance of gender-diverse work groups is often inhibited by self-reinforcing gender role expectations. We use the analogy of a flywheel to illustrate how gender role expectations tend to reinforce themselves via three mechanisms. Specifically, we argue that gender role expectations shape (1) the allocation of jobs, tasks, and responsibilities, (2) the behavior of perceivers, and (3) the behavior of target women and men. In turn, these three consequences of gender role expectations tend to confirm the initial gender role expectations, thus creating an automatic, self-reinforcing flywheel effect. Such self-reinforcing gender role expectations provide superficial impressions of individual women's and men's actual knowledge and abilities at best. We therefore further propose that each of the three mechanisms of the flywheel of gender role expectations negatively affects group performance to the extent that gender role expectations inaccurately capture group members' actual knowledge and abilities. Because the extent to which work group members rely on gender role expectations depends on how they form impressions of others, we propose that individuals' motivation to form accurate impressions is crucial for inhibiting the flywheel of gender role expectations. We close by advancing an agenda for future research on each of the three areas of interest in our conceptual analysis: the flywheel effect of gender role expectations, the consequences of this flywheel effect for group functioning, and ways to motivate group members to form accurate impressions.

Original languageEnglish
Article number976
Number of pages11
JournalFrontiers in Psychology
Volume10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Keywords

  • gender role expectations, impression formation motivation, team performance, diverse teams, stereotypes
  • gender role expectations
  • stereotypes
  • METAANALYSIS
  • PERFORMANCE
  • INFORMATION
  • POWER
  • STEREOTYPE THREAT
  • BACKLASH
  • MODEL
  • FEMALE
  • impression formation motivation
  • WOMEN
  • diverse teams
  • CONSTRUCTION
  • team performance

Cite this

@article{872061d70ec0481eb26e5286a891e5ab,
title = "The flywheel effect of gender role expectations in diverse work groups",
abstract = "Popular press suggests that gender diversity benefits the performance of work groups. However, decades of research indicate that such performance benefits of gender diversity are anything but a given. To account for this incongruity, in this conceptual paper we argue that the performance of gender-diverse work groups is often inhibited by self-reinforcing gender role expectations. We use the analogy of a flywheel to illustrate how gender role expectations tend to reinforce themselves via three mechanisms. Specifically, we argue that gender role expectations shape (1) the allocation of jobs, tasks, and responsibilities, (2) the behavior of perceivers, and (3) the behavior of target women and men. In turn, these three consequences of gender role expectations tend to confirm the initial gender role expectations, thus creating an automatic, self-reinforcing flywheel effect. Such self-reinforcing gender role expectations provide superficial impressions of individual women's and men's actual knowledge and abilities at best. We therefore further propose that each of the three mechanisms of the flywheel of gender role expectations negatively affects group performance to the extent that gender role expectations inaccurately capture group members' actual knowledge and abilities. Because the extent to which work group members rely on gender role expectations depends on how they form impressions of others, we propose that individuals' motivation to form accurate impressions is crucial for inhibiting the flywheel of gender role expectations. We close by advancing an agenda for future research on each of the three areas of interest in our conceptual analysis: the flywheel effect of gender role expectations, the consequences of this flywheel effect for group functioning, and ways to motivate group members to form accurate impressions.",
keywords = "gender role expectations, impression formation motivation, team performance, diverse teams, stereotypes, gender role expectations, stereotypes, METAANALYSIS, PERFORMANCE, INFORMATION, POWER, STEREOTYPE THREAT, BACKLASH, MODEL, FEMALE, impression formation motivation, WOMEN, diverse teams, CONSTRUCTION, team performance",
author = "{van Dijk}, Hans and {van Engen}, Marloes",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00976",
language = "English",
volume = "10",
journal = "Frontiers in Psychology",
issn = "1664-1078",
publisher = "Frontiers Media S.A.",

}

The flywheel effect of gender role expectations in diverse work groups. / van Dijk, Hans; van Engen, Marloes.

In: Frontiers in Psychology, Vol. 10, 976, 2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The flywheel effect of gender role expectations in diverse work groups

AU - van Dijk, Hans

AU - van Engen, Marloes

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Popular press suggests that gender diversity benefits the performance of work groups. However, decades of research indicate that such performance benefits of gender diversity are anything but a given. To account for this incongruity, in this conceptual paper we argue that the performance of gender-diverse work groups is often inhibited by self-reinforcing gender role expectations. We use the analogy of a flywheel to illustrate how gender role expectations tend to reinforce themselves via three mechanisms. Specifically, we argue that gender role expectations shape (1) the allocation of jobs, tasks, and responsibilities, (2) the behavior of perceivers, and (3) the behavior of target women and men. In turn, these three consequences of gender role expectations tend to confirm the initial gender role expectations, thus creating an automatic, self-reinforcing flywheel effect. Such self-reinforcing gender role expectations provide superficial impressions of individual women's and men's actual knowledge and abilities at best. We therefore further propose that each of the three mechanisms of the flywheel of gender role expectations negatively affects group performance to the extent that gender role expectations inaccurately capture group members' actual knowledge and abilities. Because the extent to which work group members rely on gender role expectations depends on how they form impressions of others, we propose that individuals' motivation to form accurate impressions is crucial for inhibiting the flywheel of gender role expectations. We close by advancing an agenda for future research on each of the three areas of interest in our conceptual analysis: the flywheel effect of gender role expectations, the consequences of this flywheel effect for group functioning, and ways to motivate group members to form accurate impressions.

AB - Popular press suggests that gender diversity benefits the performance of work groups. However, decades of research indicate that such performance benefits of gender diversity are anything but a given. To account for this incongruity, in this conceptual paper we argue that the performance of gender-diverse work groups is often inhibited by self-reinforcing gender role expectations. We use the analogy of a flywheel to illustrate how gender role expectations tend to reinforce themselves via three mechanisms. Specifically, we argue that gender role expectations shape (1) the allocation of jobs, tasks, and responsibilities, (2) the behavior of perceivers, and (3) the behavior of target women and men. In turn, these three consequences of gender role expectations tend to confirm the initial gender role expectations, thus creating an automatic, self-reinforcing flywheel effect. Such self-reinforcing gender role expectations provide superficial impressions of individual women's and men's actual knowledge and abilities at best. We therefore further propose that each of the three mechanisms of the flywheel of gender role expectations negatively affects group performance to the extent that gender role expectations inaccurately capture group members' actual knowledge and abilities. Because the extent to which work group members rely on gender role expectations depends on how they form impressions of others, we propose that individuals' motivation to form accurate impressions is crucial for inhibiting the flywheel of gender role expectations. We close by advancing an agenda for future research on each of the three areas of interest in our conceptual analysis: the flywheel effect of gender role expectations, the consequences of this flywheel effect for group functioning, and ways to motivate group members to form accurate impressions.

KW - gender role expectations, impression formation motivation, team performance, diverse teams, stereotypes

KW - gender role expectations

KW - stereotypes

KW - METAANALYSIS

KW - PERFORMANCE

KW - INFORMATION

KW - POWER

KW - STEREOTYPE THREAT

KW - BACKLASH

KW - MODEL

KW - FEMALE

KW - impression formation motivation

KW - WOMEN

KW - diverse teams

KW - CONSTRUCTION

KW - team performance

U2 - 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00976

DO - 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00976

M3 - Review article

VL - 10

JO - Frontiers in Psychology

JF - Frontiers in Psychology

SN - 1664-1078

M1 - 976

ER -