The Incidence of Pension Contributions: What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates?

Casper van Ewijk, Sander Muns, Nicole Bosch, M. Micevska Scharf

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

Abstract

This paper investigates the incidence of pension contributions using a unique longitudinal administrative dataset covering individual employees at different pension funds in the Netherlands for the period 2006-2012. With a panel-based difference-indifference approach, we estimate the response of wages, labor cost and hours worked to both marginal and average contribution rates, which provides us insight into the mechanisms underlying incidence. In contrast to the standard demand and supply model of labor we find that average contribution rates matter more for incidence than marginal rates. Moreover, we find that a substantial part of the burden (some 70%) is borne by employers. This is in line with the statutory contribution rates (on average 70-30 for employers and employees) but could also be explained by other factors such as non-salience or bargaining. Together our findings indicate that incidence is best explained by a bargaining model of wages, at least in the short and medium term considered in our analysis.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherNETSPAR
Number of pages57
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Publication series

NameNetspar Discussion Paper
Volume02/2019-002

Fingerprint

Pensions
Contribution rate
Wages
Employees
Employers
Indifference
Labour costs
Demand and supply
Burden
Bargaining model
Pension funds
Hours worked
Labor
Factors
The Netherlands

Keywords

  • Incidence
  • pension contributions
  • labor supply

Cite this

van Ewijk, C., Muns, S., Bosch, N., & Micevska Scharf, M. (2019). The Incidence of Pension Contributions: What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates? (Netspar Discussion Paper; Vol. 02/2019-002). Tilburg: NETSPAR.
van Ewijk, Casper ; Muns, Sander ; Bosch, Nicole ; Micevska Scharf, M. / The Incidence of Pension Contributions : What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates?. Tilburg : NETSPAR, 2019. (Netspar Discussion Paper).
@techreport{49021ba69f8d4d68ab04d1b66aacde00,
title = "The Incidence of Pension Contributions: What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates?",
abstract = "This paper investigates the incidence of pension contributions using a unique longitudinal administrative dataset covering individual employees at different pension funds in the Netherlands for the period 2006-2012. With a panel-based difference-indifference approach, we estimate the response of wages, labor cost and hours worked to both marginal and average contribution rates, which provides us insight into the mechanisms underlying incidence. In contrast to the standard demand and supply model of labor we find that average contribution rates matter more for incidence than marginal rates. Moreover, we find that a substantial part of the burden (some 70{\%}) is borne by employers. This is in line with the statutory contribution rates (on average 70-30 for employers and employees) but could also be explained by other factors such as non-salience or bargaining. Together our findings indicate that incidence is best explained by a bargaining model of wages, at least in the short and medium term considered in our analysis.",
keywords = "Incidence, pension contributions, labor supply",
author = "{van Ewijk}, Casper and Sander Muns and Nicole Bosch and {Micevska Scharf}, M.",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
series = "Netspar Discussion Paper",
publisher = "NETSPAR",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "NETSPAR",

}

van Ewijk, C, Muns, S, Bosch, N & Micevska Scharf, M 2019 'The Incidence of Pension Contributions: What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates?' Netspar Discussion Paper, vol. 02/2019-002, NETSPAR, Tilburg.

The Incidence of Pension Contributions : What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates? / van Ewijk, Casper; Muns, Sander; Bosch, Nicole ; Micevska Scharf, M.

Tilburg : NETSPAR, 2019. (Netspar Discussion Paper; Vol. 02/2019-002).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - The Incidence of Pension Contributions

T2 - What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates?

AU - van Ewijk, Casper

AU - Muns, Sander

AU - Bosch, Nicole

AU - Micevska Scharf, M.

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - This paper investigates the incidence of pension contributions using a unique longitudinal administrative dataset covering individual employees at different pension funds in the Netherlands for the period 2006-2012. With a panel-based difference-indifference approach, we estimate the response of wages, labor cost and hours worked to both marginal and average contribution rates, which provides us insight into the mechanisms underlying incidence. In contrast to the standard demand and supply model of labor we find that average contribution rates matter more for incidence than marginal rates. Moreover, we find that a substantial part of the burden (some 70%) is borne by employers. This is in line with the statutory contribution rates (on average 70-30 for employers and employees) but could also be explained by other factors such as non-salience or bargaining. Together our findings indicate that incidence is best explained by a bargaining model of wages, at least in the short and medium term considered in our analysis.

AB - This paper investigates the incidence of pension contributions using a unique longitudinal administrative dataset covering individual employees at different pension funds in the Netherlands for the period 2006-2012. With a panel-based difference-indifference approach, we estimate the response of wages, labor cost and hours worked to both marginal and average contribution rates, which provides us insight into the mechanisms underlying incidence. In contrast to the standard demand and supply model of labor we find that average contribution rates matter more for incidence than marginal rates. Moreover, we find that a substantial part of the burden (some 70%) is borne by employers. This is in line with the statutory contribution rates (on average 70-30 for employers and employees) but could also be explained by other factors such as non-salience or bargaining. Together our findings indicate that incidence is best explained by a bargaining model of wages, at least in the short and medium term considered in our analysis.

KW - Incidence

KW - pension contributions

KW - labor supply

M3 - Discussion paper

T3 - Netspar Discussion Paper

BT - The Incidence of Pension Contributions

PB - NETSPAR

CY - Tilburg

ER -

van Ewijk C, Muns S, Bosch N, Micevska Scharf M. The Incidence of Pension Contributions: What Matters: Marginal or Average Rates? Tilburg: NETSPAR. 2019. (Netspar Discussion Paper).