The Power of Percentage: Quantitative Framing of Pension Income

Henriette Prast, F. Teppa

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

27 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

We investigate whether the quantitative frame used to communicate future pension income to plan members matters for perceived pension income adequacy. We allocate plan members randomly to one of four pension income framing conditions: annual pension income, monthly pension income, pension income as percentage of current income, pension income as decimal of current income. We find that expressing projected pension income as a percentage (decimal) of current income significantly increases (decreases) the probability that a plan member perceives the pension income as too low. This effect is robust to adding retirement savings attitude. In addition, we find significant and intuitive effects of household wealth, income, age and education on perceived pension income adequacy. We discuss our findings against the backdrop of previous studies on the effect of numeric frames on perceptions, provide suggestions for further research and draw conclusions for pension communication and survey design.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationAmsterdam
PublisherDe Nederlandsche Bank
Number of pages31
Volume578
Publication statusPublished - 11 Dec 2017

Publication series

NameDNB Working Paper
Volume578

Fingerprint

Income
Pensions
Adequacy
Household wealth
Retirement saving
Communication
Education
Survey design

Keywords

  • framing effects
  • pension income
  • perceived adquacy

Cite this

Prast, H., & Teppa, F. (2017). The Power of Percentage: Quantitative Framing of Pension Income. (DNB Working Paper ; Vol. 578). Amsterdam: De Nederlandsche Bank.
Prast, Henriette ; Teppa, F. / The Power of Percentage : Quantitative Framing of Pension Income. Amsterdam : De Nederlandsche Bank, 2017. (DNB Working Paper ).
@techreport{f4542b67668e4a6f84e8908f50ff5146,
title = "The Power of Percentage: Quantitative Framing of Pension Income",
abstract = "We investigate whether the quantitative frame used to communicate future pension income to plan members matters for perceived pension income adequacy. We allocate plan members randomly to one of four pension income framing conditions: annual pension income, monthly pension income, pension income as percentage of current income, pension income as decimal of current income. We find that expressing projected pension income as a percentage (decimal) of current income significantly increases (decreases) the probability that a plan member perceives the pension income as too low. This effect is robust to adding retirement savings attitude. In addition, we find significant and intuitive effects of household wealth, income, age and education on perceived pension income adequacy. We discuss our findings against the backdrop of previous studies on the effect of numeric frames on perceptions, provide suggestions for further research and draw conclusions for pension communication and survey design.",
keywords = "framing effects, pension income, perceived adquacy",
author = "Henriette Prast and F. Teppa",
year = "2017",
month = "12",
day = "11",
language = "English",
volume = "578",
series = "DNB Working Paper",
publisher = "De Nederlandsche Bank",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "De Nederlandsche Bank",

}

Prast, H & Teppa, F 2017 'The Power of Percentage: Quantitative Framing of Pension Income' DNB Working Paper , vol. 578, De Nederlandsche Bank, Amsterdam.

The Power of Percentage : Quantitative Framing of Pension Income. / Prast, Henriette; Teppa, F.

Amsterdam : De Nederlandsche Bank, 2017. (DNB Working Paper ; Vol. 578).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - The Power of Percentage

T2 - Quantitative Framing of Pension Income

AU - Prast, Henriette

AU - Teppa, F.

PY - 2017/12/11

Y1 - 2017/12/11

N2 - We investigate whether the quantitative frame used to communicate future pension income to plan members matters for perceived pension income adequacy. We allocate plan members randomly to one of four pension income framing conditions: annual pension income, monthly pension income, pension income as percentage of current income, pension income as decimal of current income. We find that expressing projected pension income as a percentage (decimal) of current income significantly increases (decreases) the probability that a plan member perceives the pension income as too low. This effect is robust to adding retirement savings attitude. In addition, we find significant and intuitive effects of household wealth, income, age and education on perceived pension income adequacy. We discuss our findings against the backdrop of previous studies on the effect of numeric frames on perceptions, provide suggestions for further research and draw conclusions for pension communication and survey design.

AB - We investigate whether the quantitative frame used to communicate future pension income to plan members matters for perceived pension income adequacy. We allocate plan members randomly to one of four pension income framing conditions: annual pension income, monthly pension income, pension income as percentage of current income, pension income as decimal of current income. We find that expressing projected pension income as a percentage (decimal) of current income significantly increases (decreases) the probability that a plan member perceives the pension income as too low. This effect is robust to adding retirement savings attitude. In addition, we find significant and intuitive effects of household wealth, income, age and education on perceived pension income adequacy. We discuss our findings against the backdrop of previous studies on the effect of numeric frames on perceptions, provide suggestions for further research and draw conclusions for pension communication and survey design.

KW - framing effects

KW - pension income

KW - perceived adquacy

M3 - Discussion paper

VL - 578

T3 - DNB Working Paper

BT - The Power of Percentage

PB - De Nederlandsche Bank

CY - Amsterdam

ER -

Prast H, Teppa F. The Power of Percentage: Quantitative Framing of Pension Income. Amsterdam: De Nederlandsche Bank. 2017 Dec 11. (DNB Working Paper ).