Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

The robustness of mental accounting across 21 countries

  • Giulia Priolo
  • , Federica Stablum
  • , Martina Vacondio
  • , Simone D’Ambrogio
  • , Marta Caserotti
  • , Beatrice Conte
  • , Prisca De Roni
  • , Hilda du Plooy
  • , Vivian D Grillo
  • , Libera Y Mastromatteo
  • , Elisa Tedaldi
  • , Filippo Toscano
  • , Jesús Aguilar-Armijo
  • , Parisa Ahmadi Ghomroudi
  • , Lucian Alexa
  • , Mathias H Andersen
  • , Per A Andersson
  • , Karine Aoun Barakat
  • , Carolina Barros
  • , Ruggero Basanisi
  • Tara Beilner, Sergiu Burlacu, Thai Cao, Alessandra Carella, Arianna Chiappi, Zafer Çiftçi, Claudia Civai, Alana Daly, Valdonė Darškuvienė, Marta De Pedis, Earle J du Plooy, Mohammed El-Mir, Christian T Elbæk, Sondos Elkot, Valeria Fanghella, Eman Farahat, Amy G Fehl, Ama P Fenny, Paul A G Forbes, Gemma Garbi, André Gonçalves, Sevias Guvuriro, Ali Hajian, Steve Heinke, Austin Howard, Sudharsana Jagatheesh Jayanand, Peiran Jiao, Gabriela Jiga-Boy, Alejandra Jordano De Castro, Tobias Kalenscher, Austėja Kažemekaitytė, Afreen Khalid, Kiana Kothe, Philip Krüger, Ngân Lê Thị Kiều, Gintarė Leckė, Yanina Ledovaya, Mengyu Lim, Luca M Lüpken, Huong Mai Thi Xuan, Laura Mangold, Alfarisi Maulana, Maya Maze, Hajdi Moche, Zahra Moradi, Adel Moumin, Valeria Nava, Michelle J Y Neoh, Leonardo Nicolao, Hamza O. K. El Hallaoui, Sebastian Olschewski, Adobea Y Owusu, Ahmet F Ozates, Sofia Pelica, Sonja Perkovic, Ananda W M Puteri, Hagai Rabinovitch, Guilherme A Ramos, Nicole Robitaille, Caroline Roux, Benjamin Scheibehenne, Martin Schoemann, Mohammad Seidisarouei, Sanjay Singh, Mustafa Z Söyük, Liza Steiner, Amira Tarek, Berto Usman, Hannah van Alebeek, Mohammad H Vazirian, Evgeniya Vedernikova, Janet L Wijaya, Xinxin Zhu, Jichuan Zong, Leaf Van Boven, Stephan Dickert, Lorella Lotto, David J Hardisty, Justin Pomerance, Beatriz Pereira, Kai Ruggeri, Enrico Rubaltelli

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › Scientific › peer-review

2 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

First introduced four decades ago, the influential concept of mental accounting—how people mentally organize, evaluate, and track financial activities—posits that consumers often defy traditional economic rationality, treating money as non-fungible across discrete mental accounts. The present study provides the first large-scale test of the replicability and generalizability of mental accounting effects, using a sample of 5,589 participants from 21 countries. The results demonstrate that mental accounting effects are replicable, robust, and generalizable. Hierarchical Bayesian meta-analyses revealed a 100% replication rate for all tested scenarios, while unpooled analyses showed a 90.5% replication rate (133/147 effects). Further analyses indicated that mental accounting effects were weaker in lower-income countries than in higher-income countries. Multidimensional scaling suggested that mental accounting effects vary along three interpretable dimensions that reflect social context (individual vs. interactive decisions), decision perspective (deciding for self vs. other), and role in price determination (setting vs. evaluating prices). Across a diverse population and after controlling for multiple factors, the findings show that consumers make decisions based on mentally formed accounts that consistently diverge from their objective financial value.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)ucag022
JournalJournal of Consumer Research
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jul 2026

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'The robustness of mental accounting across 21 countries'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this