"Thinking About Arrows": Modeling the associations between inadequate parenting, mentalizing, and dissociation. Commentary on "The developmental roots of dissociation: A multiple mediation analysis" (Schimmenti, 2017)

C. Garofalo, Patrizia Velotti

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/Letter to the editorScientificpeer-review

Abstract

In an article published in Psychoanalytic Psychology, Schimmenti (2017) reported an empirical study whose results were interpreted as supporting the trauma model of dissociation and suggested that alexithymia and deficits in theory of mind might mediate the relation between emotional neglect and dissociation. Although interesting and thought provoking, that study also had methodological and conceptual limits, which leave open the possibility that other conclusions could be drawn from the data. In this commentary, we point out the conceptual and methodological issues that should be taken into consideration when interpreting Schimmenti's (2017) findings; argue that alternative explanations are equally defensible; and propose an alternative (or complementary) model to understand the connections among inadequate parenting, dissociation, and mentalizing (i.e., theory of mind and alexithymia). Finally, we report the results of a reanalysis from the original correlation matrix to demonstrate some evidence in support of the proposed alternative model using Structural Equation Modeling. Clinical implications are then briefly discussed.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)106-108
Number of pages3
JournalPsychoanalytic Psychology
Volume34
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2017

Keywords

  • dissociation
  • mentalizing
  • emotional neglect
  • parenting
  • attachment
  • TRAUMA

Cite this

@article{02e2d643c7a44f0782330fdfd05ad5ae,
title = "{"}Thinking About Arrows{"}: Modeling the associations between inadequate parenting, mentalizing, and dissociation. Commentary on {"}The developmental roots of dissociation: A multiple mediation analysis{"} (Schimmenti, 2017)",
abstract = "In an article published in Psychoanalytic Psychology, Schimmenti (2017) reported an empirical study whose results were interpreted as supporting the trauma model of dissociation and suggested that alexithymia and deficits in theory of mind might mediate the relation between emotional neglect and dissociation. Although interesting and thought provoking, that study also had methodological and conceptual limits, which leave open the possibility that other conclusions could be drawn from the data. In this commentary, we point out the conceptual and methodological issues that should be taken into consideration when interpreting Schimmenti's (2017) findings; argue that alternative explanations are equally defensible; and propose an alternative (or complementary) model to understand the connections among inadequate parenting, dissociation, and mentalizing (i.e., theory of mind and alexithymia). Finally, we report the results of a reanalysis from the original correlation matrix to demonstrate some evidence in support of the proposed alternative model using Structural Equation Modeling. Clinical implications are then briefly discussed.",
keywords = "dissociation, mentalizing, emotional neglect, parenting, attachment, TRAUMA",
author = "C. Garofalo and Patrizia Velotti",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1037/pap0000108",
language = "English",
volume = "34",
pages = "106--108",
journal = "Psychoanalytic Psychology",
issn = "0736-9735",
publisher = "EDUCATIONAL PUBLISHING FOUNDATION-AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOC",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - "Thinking About Arrows"

T2 - Modeling the associations between inadequate parenting, mentalizing, and dissociation. Commentary on "The developmental roots of dissociation: A multiple mediation analysis" (Schimmenti, 2017)

AU - Garofalo, C.

AU - Velotti, Patrizia

PY - 2017/1

Y1 - 2017/1

N2 - In an article published in Psychoanalytic Psychology, Schimmenti (2017) reported an empirical study whose results were interpreted as supporting the trauma model of dissociation and suggested that alexithymia and deficits in theory of mind might mediate the relation between emotional neglect and dissociation. Although interesting and thought provoking, that study also had methodological and conceptual limits, which leave open the possibility that other conclusions could be drawn from the data. In this commentary, we point out the conceptual and methodological issues that should be taken into consideration when interpreting Schimmenti's (2017) findings; argue that alternative explanations are equally defensible; and propose an alternative (or complementary) model to understand the connections among inadequate parenting, dissociation, and mentalizing (i.e., theory of mind and alexithymia). Finally, we report the results of a reanalysis from the original correlation matrix to demonstrate some evidence in support of the proposed alternative model using Structural Equation Modeling. Clinical implications are then briefly discussed.

AB - In an article published in Psychoanalytic Psychology, Schimmenti (2017) reported an empirical study whose results were interpreted as supporting the trauma model of dissociation and suggested that alexithymia and deficits in theory of mind might mediate the relation between emotional neglect and dissociation. Although interesting and thought provoking, that study also had methodological and conceptual limits, which leave open the possibility that other conclusions could be drawn from the data. In this commentary, we point out the conceptual and methodological issues that should be taken into consideration when interpreting Schimmenti's (2017) findings; argue that alternative explanations are equally defensible; and propose an alternative (or complementary) model to understand the connections among inadequate parenting, dissociation, and mentalizing (i.e., theory of mind and alexithymia). Finally, we report the results of a reanalysis from the original correlation matrix to demonstrate some evidence in support of the proposed alternative model using Structural Equation Modeling. Clinical implications are then briefly discussed.

KW - dissociation

KW - mentalizing

KW - emotional neglect

KW - parenting

KW - attachment

KW - TRAUMA

U2 - 10.1037/pap0000108

DO - 10.1037/pap0000108

M3 - Comment/Letter to the editor

VL - 34

SP - 106

EP - 108

JO - Psychoanalytic Psychology

JF - Psychoanalytic Psychology

SN - 0736-9735

IS - 1

ER -