Three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect

I. Blanken, N. van de Ven, M. Zeelenberg, Marijn H. C. Meijers

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

2 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The present work includes three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect by Sachdeva, Iliev, and Medin (2009). The original authors found that writing about positive traits led to lower donations to charity and decreased cooperative behavior. The first two replication attempts (student samples, 95% power based on the initial findings, N Study1 = 105, N Study2 = 150), did not confirm the original results. The third replication attempt (MTurk sample, 95% power based on a meta-analysis on self-licensing, N = 940) also did not confirm the moral licensing effect. We conclude that (1) there is as of yet no strong support for the moral self-regulation framework proposed in Sachdeva et al. (2009) (2) the manipulation used is unlikely to induce moral licensing, and (3) studies on moral licensing should use a neutral control condition.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)232-238
JournalSocial Psychology
Volume45
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Keywords

  • moral licensing
  • moral cleansing
  • self-regulation
  • replication

Cite this

Blanken, I. ; van de Ven, N. ; Zeelenberg, M. ; Meijers, Marijn H. C. / Three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect. In: Social Psychology. 2014 ; Vol. 45, No. 3. pp. 232-238.
@article{50442d05fc8d4d4e81a607e3d7c89095,
title = "Three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect",
abstract = "The present work includes three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect by Sachdeva, Iliev, and Medin (2009). The original authors found that writing about positive traits led to lower donations to charity and decreased cooperative behavior. The first two replication attempts (student samples, 95{\%} power based on the initial findings, N Study1 = 105, N Study2 = 150), did not confirm the original results. The third replication attempt (MTurk sample, 95{\%} power based on a meta-analysis on self-licensing, N = 940) also did not confirm the moral licensing effect. We conclude that (1) there is as of yet no strong support for the moral self-regulation framework proposed in Sachdeva et al. (2009) (2) the manipulation used is unlikely to induce moral licensing, and (3) studies on moral licensing should use a neutral control condition.",
keywords = "moral licensing, moral cleansing, self-regulation, replication",
author = "I. Blanken and {van de Ven}, N. and M. Zeelenberg and Meijers, {Marijn H. C.}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1027/1864-9335/a000189",
language = "English",
volume = "45",
pages = "232--238",
journal = "Social Psychology",
issn = "1864-9335",
publisher = "Hogrefe & Huber Publishers",
number = "3",

}

Three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect. / Blanken, I.; van de Ven, N.; Zeelenberg, M.; Meijers, Marijn H. C.

In: Social Psychology, Vol. 45, No. 3, 2014, p. 232-238.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect

AU - Blanken, I.

AU - van de Ven, N.

AU - Zeelenberg, M.

AU - Meijers, Marijn H. C.

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - The present work includes three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect by Sachdeva, Iliev, and Medin (2009). The original authors found that writing about positive traits led to lower donations to charity and decreased cooperative behavior. The first two replication attempts (student samples, 95% power based on the initial findings, N Study1 = 105, N Study2 = 150), did not confirm the original results. The third replication attempt (MTurk sample, 95% power based on a meta-analysis on self-licensing, N = 940) also did not confirm the moral licensing effect. We conclude that (1) there is as of yet no strong support for the moral self-regulation framework proposed in Sachdeva et al. (2009) (2) the manipulation used is unlikely to induce moral licensing, and (3) studies on moral licensing should use a neutral control condition.

AB - The present work includes three attempts to replicate the moral licensing effect by Sachdeva, Iliev, and Medin (2009). The original authors found that writing about positive traits led to lower donations to charity and decreased cooperative behavior. The first two replication attempts (student samples, 95% power based on the initial findings, N Study1 = 105, N Study2 = 150), did not confirm the original results. The third replication attempt (MTurk sample, 95% power based on a meta-analysis on self-licensing, N = 940) also did not confirm the moral licensing effect. We conclude that (1) there is as of yet no strong support for the moral self-regulation framework proposed in Sachdeva et al. (2009) (2) the manipulation used is unlikely to induce moral licensing, and (3) studies on moral licensing should use a neutral control condition.

KW - moral licensing

KW - moral cleansing

KW - self-regulation

KW - replication

U2 - 10.1027/1864-9335/a000189

DO - 10.1027/1864-9335/a000189

M3 - Article

VL - 45

SP - 232

EP - 238

JO - Social Psychology

JF - Social Psychology

SN - 1864-9335

IS - 3

ER -