To which world regions does the valence-dominance model of social perception apply?

Benedict Jones; Lisa Marie DeBruine; Jessica Kay Flake; Marco Tullio Liuzza; Jan Antfolk; Nwadiogo Chisom Arinze; Izuchukwu Lawrence Gabriel Ndukaihe; Nicholas Bloxsom; Savannah Lewis; Francesco Foroni; Megan Willis; Carmelo Cubillas; Miguel Vadillo; michael gilead; Almog Simchon; Selahattin Adil Saribay; Nicholas Calbraith Owsley; Dustin Calvillo; Anna Włodarczyk; Yue Qi; Kris Ariyabuddhiphongs; Somboon Jarukasemthawee; Harry Manley; Panita Suavansri; Nattasuda Taephant; Ryan Mayer Stolier; Thomas Rhys Evans; Judson Bonick; Jan Willem Lindemans; Logan Fox Ashworth; Coralie Chevallier; Aycan Kapucu; Aslan Karaaslan; Juan David Leongómez; Oscar Sánchez; Eugenio Valderrama Escallón; Milena Vásquez-Amézquita; Balazs Aczel; Nandor Hajdu; Peter Szecsi; Michael Andreychik; Erica Musser; Carlota Batres; Chuan-Peng Hu; Qing-Lan Liu; Nicole Legate; Leigh Ann Vaughn; Krystian Barzykowski; Karolina Golik; Irina Schmid; Stefan Stieger; Richard Artner; Chiel Kris Karel Mues; wolf vanpaemel; Zhongqing Jiang; Qi Wu; Gabriela Marcu; Ian Stephen; Jackson Lu; Michael Carl Philipp; Jack Dennis Arnal; Eric Hehman; Sally Xie; William Chopik; Martin Seehuus; Soufian Azouaghe; Abdelkarim Belhaj; Jamal Elouafa; John Paul Wilson; Elliott Tyler Kruse; Marietta Papadatou-Pastou; Alan Barba-Sanchez; ANABEL DE LA ROSA GOMEZ; Isaac González-Santoyo; Tsuyueh Hsu; Chun-Chia Kung; Wang Hsiao-Hsin; Jonathan Freeman; DongWon Oh; Vidar Schei; Therese Sverdrup; Carmel Levitan; Corey Cook; Priyanka Chandel; Pratibha Kujur; Arti Parganiha; Noorshama Parveen; Atanu Kumar Pati; Sraddha Pradhan; Margaret Messiah Singh; Babita Pande; Jozef Bavolar; Pavol Kačmár; Ilya Zakharov; Sara Álvarez Solas; Ernest Baskin; Martin Thirkettle; Kathleen Schmidt; Cody Christopherson; Jordan Suchow; Jonas Olofsson; Ai-Suan Lee; Jennifer Beaudry; Taylor Diarmuid Gogan; Julian Oldmeadow; Barnaby Dixson; Laura Stevens; Gianni Ribeiro; Mark John Brandt; Karlijn Hoyer; Bastian Jaeger; Dongning Ren; Willem Sleegers; Joeri Wissink; Gwenael Kaminski; Victoria Floerke; Heather Urry; Sau-Chin Chen; Gerit Pfuhl; Zahir Vally; Dana Basnight-Brown; Hans IJzerman; Elisa Sarda; Touhami Badidi; Nicolas Van der Linden; Chrystalle Tan; Vanja Kovic; Melissa Fay Colloff; Heather Flowe; DI Burin; Gwendolyn Gardiner; John Protzko; Christoph Schild; Karolina Scigala; Ingo Zettler; Erin Marie O'Mara Kunz; Daniel Storage; Fieke Maria Antoinet Wagemans; Blair Saunders; Miroslav Sirota; Guyan Sloane; Tiago Jessé Souza Lima; Kim Uittenhove; Evie Vergauwe; Katarzyna Jaworska; Lilian Carvalho; Karl Ask; Casper Van Zyl; Anita Körner; Sophia Christin Weissgerber; Jordane Boudesseul; Fernando Ruiz-Dodobara; Kay Ritchie; Nicholas Michael Michalak; Khandis Blake; David White; Alasdair Gordon-Finlayson; Michele Anne; Steve Janssen; Kean Mun Lee; Tonje Kvande Nielsen; Christian Tamnes; Janis Zickfeld; Anna Dalla Rosa; Ferenc Kocsor; Luca Kozma; Adam Putz; Patrizio Tressoldi; Michelangelo Vianello; Natalia Irrazabal; Armand Chatard; Samuel Lins; Isabel Pinto; Johannes Lutz; Matus Adamkovic; Peter Babinčák; Gabriel Baník; Ivan Ropovik; Vinet Coetzee; Kim Olivia Peters

doi:10.31234/osf.io/n26dy

To which world regions does the valence-dominance model of social perception apply?

Benedict Jones^*, Lisa Marie DeBruine, Jessica Kay Flake, Marco Tullio Liuzza, Jan Antfolk, Nwadiogo Chisom Arinze, Izuchukwu Lawrence Gabriel Ndukaihe, Nicholas Bloxsom, Savannah Lewis, Francesco Foroni, Megan Willis, Carmelo Cubillas, Miguel Vadillo, michael gilead, Almog Simchon, Selahattin Adil Saribay, Nicholas Calbraith Owsley, Dustin Calvillo, Anna Włodarczyk, Yue QiKris Ariyabuddhiphongs, Somboon Jarukasemthawee, Harry Manley, Panita Suavansri, Nattasuda Taephant, Ryan Mayer Stolier, Thomas Rhys Evans, Judson Bonick, Jan Willem Lindemans, Logan Fox Ashworth, Coralie Chevallier, Aycan Kapucu, Aslan Karaaslan, Juan David Leongómez, Oscar Sánchez, Eugenio Valderrama Escallón, Milena Vásquez-Amézquita, Balazs Aczel, Nandor Hajdu, Peter Szecsi, Michael Andreychik, Erica Musser, Carlota Batres, Chuan-Peng Hu, Qing-Lan Liu, Nicole Legate, Leigh Ann Vaughn, Krystian Barzykowski, Karolina Golik, Irina Schmid, Stefan Stieger, Richard Artner, Chiel Kris Karel Mues, wolf vanpaemel, Zhongqing Jiang, Qi Wu, Gabriela Marcu, Ian Stephen, Jackson Lu, Michael Carl Philipp, Jack Dennis Arnal, Eric Hehman, Sally Xie, William Chopik, Martin Seehuus, Soufian Azouaghe, Abdelkarim Belhaj, Jamal Elouafa, John Paul Wilson, Elliott Tyler Kruse, Marietta Papadatou-Pastou, Alan Barba-Sanchez, ANABEL DE LA ROSA GOMEZ, Isaac González-Santoyo, Tsuyueh Hsu, Chun-Chia Kung, Wang Hsiao-Hsin, Jonathan Freeman, DongWon Oh, Vidar Schei, Therese Sverdrup, Carmel Levitan, Corey Cook, Priyanka Chandel, Pratibha Kujur, Arti Parganiha, Noorshama Parveen, Atanu Kumar Pati, Sraddha Pradhan, Margaret Messiah Singh, Babita Pande, Jozef Bavolar, Pavol Kačmár, Ilya Zakharov, Sara Álvarez Solas, Ernest Baskin, Martin Thirkettle, Kathleen Schmidt, Cody Christopherson, Jordan Suchow, Jonas Olofsson, Ai-Suan Lee, Jennifer Beaudry, Taylor Diarmuid Gogan, Julian Oldmeadow, Barnaby Dixson, Laura Stevens, Gianni Ribeiro, Mark John Brandt, Karlijn Hoyer, Bastian Jaeger, Dongning Ren, Willem Sleegers, Joeri Wissink, Gwenael Kaminski, Victoria Floerke, Heather Urry, Sau-Chin Chen, Gerit Pfuhl, Zahir Vally, Dana Basnight-Brown, Hans IJzerman, Elisa Sarda, Touhami Badidi, Nicolas Van der Linden, Chrystalle Tan, Vanja Kovic, Melissa Fay Colloff, Heather Flowe, DI Burin, Gwendolyn Gardiner, John Protzko, Christoph Schild, Karolina Scigala, Ingo Zettler, Erin Marie O'Mara Kunz, Daniel Storage, Fieke Maria Antoinet Wagemans, Blair Saunders, Miroslav Sirota, Guyan Sloane, Tiago Jessé Souza Lima, Kim Uittenhove, Evie Vergauwe, Katarzyna Jaworska, Lilian Carvalho, Karl Ask, Casper Van Zyl, Anita Körner, Sophia Christin Weissgerber, Jordane Boudesseul, Fernando Ruiz-Dodobara, Kay Ritchie, Nicholas Michael Michalak, Khandis Blake, David White, Alasdair Gordon-Finlayson, Michele Anne, Steve Janssen, Kean Mun Lee, Tonje Kvande Nielsen, Christian Tamnes, Janis Zickfeld, Anna Dalla Rosa, Ferenc Kocsor, Luca Kozma, Adam Putz, Patrizio Tressoldi, Michelangelo Vianello, Natalia Irrazabal, Armand Chatard, Samuel Lins, Isabel Pinto, Johannes Lutz, Matus Adamkovic, Peter Babinčák, Gabriel Baník, Ivan Ropovik, Vinet Coetzee, Kim Olivia Peters

^*Corresponding author for this work

Social Psychology

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › Scientific › peer-review

112 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Over the past 10 years, Oosterhof and Todorov’s valence–dominance model has emerged as the most prominent account of how people evaluate faces on social dimensions. In this model, two dimensions (valence and dominance) underpin social judgements of faces. Because this model has primarily been developed and tested in Western regions, it is unclear whether these findings apply to other regions. We addressed this question by replicating Oosterhof and Todorov’s methodology across 11 world regions, 41 countries and 11,570 participants. When we used Oosterhof and Todorov’s original analysis strategy, the valence–dominance model generalized across regions. When we used an alternative methodology to allow for correlated dimensions, we observed much less generalization. Collectively, these results suggest that, while the valence–dominance model generalizes very well across regions when dimensions are forced to be orthogonal, regional differences are revealed when we use different extraction methods and correlate and rotate the dimension reduction solution.

Original language	English
Pages (from-to)	159-169
Journal	Nature Human Behaviour
Volume	5
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/n26dy https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-020-01007-2
Publication status	Published - 2021

Access to Document

SP Brandt to which worlf regions NHB 2021 PostprintAccepted author manuscript, 7.38 MB

Cite this

Jones, B., DeBruine, L. M., Flake, J. K., Liuzza, M. T., Antfolk, J., Arinze, N. C., Ndukaihe, I. L. G., Bloxsom, N., Lewis, S., Foroni, F., Willis, M., Cubillas, C., Vadillo, M., gilead, M., Simchon, A., Saribay, S. A., Owsley, N. C., Calvillo, D., Włodarczyk, A., ... Peters, K. O. (2021). To which world regions does the valence-dominance model of social perception apply? Nature Human Behaviour, 5, 159-169. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/n26dy, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-020-01007-2

@article{b2114ccf8e50460cb4bc84d5e9fcad7f,

title = "To which world regions does the valence-dominance model of social perception apply?",

abstract = "Over the past 10 years, Oosterhof and Todorov{\textquoteright}s valence–dominance model has emerged as the most prominent account of how people evaluate faces on social dimensions. In this model, two dimensions (valence and dominance) underpin social judgements of faces. Because this model has primarily been developed and tested in Western regions, it is unclear whether these findings apply to other regions. We addressed this question by replicating Oosterhof and Todorov{\textquoteright}s methodology across 11 world regions, 41 countries and 11,570 participants. When we used Oosterhof and Todorov{\textquoteright}s original analysis strategy, the valence–dominance model generalized across regions. When we used an alternative methodology to allow for correlated dimensions, we observed much less generalization. Collectively, these results suggest that, while the valence–dominance model generalizes very well across regions when dimensions are forced to be orthogonal, regional differences are revealed when we use different extraction methods and correlate and rotate the dimension reduction solution.",

author = "Benedict Jones and DeBruine, {Lisa Marie} and Flake, {Jessica Kay} and Liuzza, {Marco Tullio} and Jan Antfolk and Arinze, {Nwadiogo Chisom} and Ndukaihe, {Izuchukwu Lawrence Gabriel} and Nicholas Bloxsom and Savannah Lewis and Francesco Foroni and Megan Willis and Carmelo Cubillas and Miguel Vadillo and michael gilead and Almog Simchon and Saribay, {Selahattin Adil} and Owsley, {Nicholas Calbraith} and Dustin Calvillo and Anna W{\l}odarczyk and Yue Qi and Kris Ariyabuddhiphongs and Somboon Jarukasemthawee and Harry Manley and Panita Suavansri and Nattasuda Taephant and Stolier, {Ryan Mayer} and Evans, {Thomas Rhys} and Judson Bonick and Lindemans, {Jan Willem} and Ashworth, {Logan Fox} and Coralie Chevallier and Aycan Kapucu and Aslan Karaaslan and Leong{\'o}mez, {Juan David} and Oscar S{\'a}nchez and {Valderrama Escall{\'o}n}, Eugenio and Milena V{\'a}squez-Am{\'e}zquita and Balazs Aczel and Nandor Hajdu and Peter Szecsi and Michael Andreychik and Erica Musser and Carlota Batres and Chuan-Peng Hu and Qing-Lan Liu and Nicole Legate and Vaughn, {Leigh Ann} and Krystian Barzykowski and Karolina Golik and Irina Schmid and Stefan Stieger and Richard Artner and Mues, {Chiel Kris Karel} and wolf vanpaemel and Zhongqing Jiang and Qi Wu and Gabriela Marcu and Ian Stephen and Jackson Lu and Philipp, {Michael Carl} and Arnal, {Jack Dennis} and Eric Hehman and Sally Xie and William Chopik and Martin Seehuus and Soufian Azouaghe and Abdelkarim Belhaj and Jamal Elouafa and Wilson, {John Paul} and Kruse, {Elliott Tyler} and Marietta Papadatou-Pastou and Alan Barba-Sanchez and {DE LA ROSA GOMEZ}, ANABEL and Isaac Gonz{\'a}lez-Santoyo and Tsuyueh Hsu and Chun-Chia Kung and Wang Hsiao-Hsin and Jonathan Freeman and DongWon Oh and Vidar Schei and Therese Sverdrup and Carmel Levitan and Corey Cook and Priyanka Chandel and Pratibha Kujur and Arti Parganiha and Noorshama Parveen and Pati, {Atanu Kumar} and Sraddha Pradhan and Singh, {Margaret Messiah} and Babita Pande and Jozef Bavolar and Pavol Ka{\v c}m{\'a}r and Ilya Zakharov and Solas, {Sara {\'A}lvarez} and Ernest Baskin and Martin Thirkettle and Kathleen Schmidt and Cody Christopherson and Jordan Suchow and Jonas Olofsson and Ai-Suan Lee and Jennifer Beaudry and Gogan, {Taylor Diarmuid} and Julian Oldmeadow and Barnaby Dixson and Laura Stevens and Gianni Ribeiro and Brandt, {Mark John} and Karlijn Hoyer and Bastian Jaeger and Dongning Ren and Willem Sleegers and Joeri Wissink and Gwenael Kaminski and Victoria Floerke and Heather Urry and Sau-Chin Chen and Gerit Pfuhl and Zahir Vally and Dana Basnight-Brown and Hans IJzerman and Elisa Sarda and Touhami Badidi and {Van der Linden}, Nicolas and Chrystalle Tan and Vanja Kovic and Colloff, {Melissa Fay} and Heather Flowe and DI Burin and Gwendolyn Gardiner and John Protzko and Christoph Schild and Karolina Scigala and Ingo Zettler and {O'Mara Kunz}, {Erin Marie} and Daniel Storage and Wagemans, {Fieke Maria Antoinet} and Blair Saunders and Miroslav Sirota and Guyan Sloane and Lima, {Tiago Jess{\'e} Souza} and Kim Uittenhove and Evie Vergauwe and Katarzyna Jaworska and Lilian Carvalho and Karl Ask and {Van Zyl}, Casper and Anita K{\"o}rner and Weissgerber, {Sophia Christin} and Jordane Boudesseul and Fernando Ruiz-Dodobara and Kay Ritchie and Michalak, {Nicholas Michael} and Khandis Blake and David White and Alasdair Gordon-Finlayson and Michele Anne and Steve Janssen and Lee, {Kean Mun} and Nielsen, {Tonje Kvande} and Christian Tamnes and Janis Zickfeld and {Dalla Rosa}, Anna and Ferenc Kocsor and Luca Kozma and Adam Putz and Patrizio Tressoldi and Michelangelo Vianello and Natalia Irrazabal and Armand Chatard and Samuel Lins and Isabel Pinto and Johannes Lutz and Matus Adamkovic and Peter Babin{\v c}{\'a}k and Gabriel Ban{\'i}k and Ivan Ropovik and Vinet Coetzee and Peters, {Kim Olivia}",

year = "2021",

doi = "10.31234/osf.io/n26dy",

language = "English",

volume = "5",

pages = "159--169",

journal = "Nature Human Behaviour",

issn = "2397-3374",

publisher = "Nature Publishing Group",

}

Jones, B, DeBruine, LM, Flake, JK, Liuzza, MT, Antfolk, J, Arinze, NC, Ndukaihe, ILG, Bloxsom, N, Lewis, S, Foroni, F, Willis, M, Cubillas, C, Vadillo, M, gilead, M, Simchon, A, Saribay, SA, Owsley, NC, Calvillo, D, Włodarczyk, A, Qi, Y, Ariyabuddhiphongs, K, Jarukasemthawee, S, Manley, H, Suavansri, P, Taephant, N, Stolier, RM, Evans, TR, Bonick, J, Lindemans, JW, Ashworth, LF, Chevallier, C, Kapucu, A, Karaaslan, A, Leongómez, JD, Sánchez, O, Valderrama Escallón, E, Vásquez-Amézquita, M, Aczel, B, Hajdu, N, Szecsi, P, Andreychik, M, Musser, E, Batres, C, Hu, C-P, Liu, Q-L, Legate, N, Vaughn, LA, Barzykowski, K, Golik, K, Schmid, I, Stieger, S, Artner, R, Mues, CKK, vanpaemel, W, Jiang, Z, Wu, Q, Marcu, G, Stephen, I, Lu, J, Philipp, MC, Arnal, JD, Hehman, E, Xie, S, Chopik, W, Seehuus, M, Azouaghe, S, Belhaj, A, Elouafa, J, Wilson, JP, Kruse, ET, Papadatou-Pastou, M, Barba-Sanchez, A, DE LA ROSA GOMEZ, ANABEL, González-Santoyo, I, Hsu, T, Kung, C-C, Hsiao-Hsin, W, Freeman, J, Oh, D, Schei, V, Sverdrup, T, Levitan, C, Cook, C, Chandel, P, Kujur, P, Parganiha, A, Parveen, N, Pati, AK, Pradhan, S, Singh, MM, Pande, B, Bavolar, J, Kačmár, P, Zakharov, I, Solas, SÁ, Baskin, E, Thirkettle, M, Schmidt, K, Christopherson, C, Suchow, J, Olofsson, J, Lee, A-S, Beaudry, J, Gogan, TD, Oldmeadow, J, Dixson, B, Stevens, L, Ribeiro, G, Brandt, MJ, Hoyer, K, Jaeger, B, Ren, D, Sleegers, W, Wissink, J, Kaminski, G, Floerke, V, Urry, H, Chen, S-C, Pfuhl, G, Vally, Z, Basnight-Brown, D, IJzerman, H, Sarda, E, Badidi, T, Van der Linden, N, Tan, C, Kovic, V, Colloff, MF, Flowe, H, Burin, DI, Gardiner, G, Protzko, J, Schild, C, Scigala, K, Zettler, I, O'Mara Kunz, EM, Storage, D, Wagemans, FMA, Saunders, B, Sirota, M, Sloane, G, Lima, TJS, Uittenhove, K, Vergauwe, E, Jaworska, K, Carvalho, L, Ask, K, Van Zyl, C, Körner, A, Weissgerber, SC, Boudesseul, J, Ruiz-Dodobara, F, Ritchie, K, Michalak, NM, Blake, K, White, D, Gordon-Finlayson, A, Anne, M, Janssen, S, Lee, KM, Nielsen, TK, Tamnes, C, Zickfeld, J, Dalla Rosa, A, Kocsor, F, Kozma, L, Putz, A, Tressoldi, P, Vianello, M, Irrazabal, N, Chatard, A, Lins, S, Pinto, I, Lutz, J, Adamkovic, M, Babinčák, P, Baník, G, Ropovik, I, Coetzee, V & Peters, KO 2021, 'To which world regions does the valence-dominance model of social perception apply?', Nature Human Behaviour, vol. 5, pp. 159-169. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/n26dy, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-020-01007-2