Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT)

J. Voeten, J.A.C. de Haan, N. Roome, G.A. de Groot

Research output: Working paperOther research output

87 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

There is increasing evidence that innovation offers perspectives for poverty alleviation in small producers’ contexts in developing countries. However, innovations sometimes imply additional harmful environmental and social consequences, which are not in line with broader poverty alleviation and sustainable development notions. In this paper, we explore the question how small producers in northern Vietnam, as innovators in a cluster context, innovate and take broader societal considerations into account in the innovation process. We found that traditional institutional theories show a number of shortcomings for our analysis into the multifaceted meta-textual societal process towards responsible innovation.

Instead, we applied Actor‐Network Theory (ANT) which describes the shaping of the human interaction in detail providing a better understanding why in some networks innovatorsbehave opportunistically while in others they acknowledge responsibility for harmful innovation outcomes. The ANT lens reveals the role of informal institutions in innovations systems and the role of materiality in network development. Lastly, ANT demonstrates how the creation and falling apart of actor networks is essential in the dynamics of a five‐stage model of the responsible innovation societal process. We conclude with factors and conditions steering the societal process and emerging questions concerning power, allowing human and non-human actants into the network, and the issue whether a network in the responsible innovation zone is also desirable in terms of economic competitiveness.
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationManchester
PublisherUniversity of Manchester
Number of pages26
ISBN (Print)9781905469697
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Publication series

NameActor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series
PublisherCentre for Development Informatics
Volume6/2013

Fingerprint

Actor-network theory
Innovation
Poverty alleviation
Developing countries
Materiality
Sustainable development
Innovators
Institutional theory
Competitiveness
Economics
Actor-network
Network development
Innovation process
Innovation system
Factors
Responsibility
Informal institutions
Interaction

Cite this

Voeten, J., de Haan, J. A. C., Roome, N., & de Groot, G. A. (2013). Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT). (Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series; Vol. 6/2013). Manchester: University of Manchester.
Voeten, J. ; de Haan, J.A.C. ; Roome, N. ; de Groot, G.A. / Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT). Manchester : University of Manchester, 2013. (Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series).
@techreport{a3894ec1943d4709bd8d549589e10b59,
title = "Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT)",
abstract = "There is increasing evidence that innovation offers perspectives for poverty alleviation in small producers’ contexts in developing countries. However, innovations sometimes imply additional harmful environmental and social consequences, which are not in line with broader poverty alleviation and sustainable development notions. In this paper, we explore the question how small producers in northern Vietnam, as innovators in a cluster context, innovate and take broader societal considerations into account in the innovation process. We found that traditional institutional theories show a number of shortcomings for our analysis into the multifaceted meta-textual societal process towards responsible innovation. Instead, we applied Actor‐Network Theory (ANT) which describes the shaping of the human interaction in detail providing a better understanding why in some networks innovatorsbehave opportunistically while in others they acknowledge responsibility for harmful innovation outcomes. The ANT lens reveals the role of informal institutions in innovations systems and the role of materiality in network development. Lastly, ANT demonstrates how the creation and falling apart of actor networks is essential in the dynamics of a five‐stage model of the responsible innovation societal process. We conclude with factors and conditions steering the societal process and emerging questions concerning power, allowing human and non-human actants into the network, and the issue whether a network in the responsible innovation zone is also desirable in terms of economic competitiveness.",
author = "J. Voeten and {de Haan}, J.A.C. and N. Roome and {de Groot}, G.A.",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781905469697",
series = "Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series",
publisher = "University of Manchester",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "University of Manchester",

}

Voeten, J, de Haan, JAC, Roome, N & de Groot, GA 2013 'Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT)' Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series, vol. 6/2013, University of Manchester, Manchester.

Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT). / Voeten, J.; de Haan, J.A.C.; Roome, N.; de Groot, G.A.

Manchester : University of Manchester, 2013. (Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series; Vol. 6/2013).

Research output: Working paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT)

AU - Voeten, J.

AU - de Haan, J.A.C.

AU - Roome, N.

AU - de Groot, G.A.

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - There is increasing evidence that innovation offers perspectives for poverty alleviation in small producers’ contexts in developing countries. However, innovations sometimes imply additional harmful environmental and social consequences, which are not in line with broader poverty alleviation and sustainable development notions. In this paper, we explore the question how small producers in northern Vietnam, as innovators in a cluster context, innovate and take broader societal considerations into account in the innovation process. We found that traditional institutional theories show a number of shortcomings for our analysis into the multifaceted meta-textual societal process towards responsible innovation. Instead, we applied Actor‐Network Theory (ANT) which describes the shaping of the human interaction in detail providing a better understanding why in some networks innovatorsbehave opportunistically while in others they acknowledge responsibility for harmful innovation outcomes. The ANT lens reveals the role of informal institutions in innovations systems and the role of materiality in network development. Lastly, ANT demonstrates how the creation and falling apart of actor networks is essential in the dynamics of a five‐stage model of the responsible innovation societal process. We conclude with factors and conditions steering the societal process and emerging questions concerning power, allowing human and non-human actants into the network, and the issue whether a network in the responsible innovation zone is also desirable in terms of economic competitiveness.

AB - There is increasing evidence that innovation offers perspectives for poverty alleviation in small producers’ contexts in developing countries. However, innovations sometimes imply additional harmful environmental and social consequences, which are not in line with broader poverty alleviation and sustainable development notions. In this paper, we explore the question how small producers in northern Vietnam, as innovators in a cluster context, innovate and take broader societal considerations into account in the innovation process. We found that traditional institutional theories show a number of shortcomings for our analysis into the multifaceted meta-textual societal process towards responsible innovation. Instead, we applied Actor‐Network Theory (ANT) which describes the shaping of the human interaction in detail providing a better understanding why in some networks innovatorsbehave opportunistically while in others they acknowledge responsibility for harmful innovation outcomes. The ANT lens reveals the role of informal institutions in innovations systems and the role of materiality in network development. Lastly, ANT demonstrates how the creation and falling apart of actor networks is essential in the dynamics of a five‐stage model of the responsible innovation societal process. We conclude with factors and conditions steering the societal process and emerging questions concerning power, allowing human and non-human actants into the network, and the issue whether a network in the responsible innovation zone is also desirable in terms of economic competitiveness.

M3 - Working paper

SN - 9781905469697

T3 - Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series

BT - Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT)

PB - University of Manchester

CY - Manchester

ER -

Voeten J, de Haan JAC, Roome N, de Groot GA. Understanding Responsible Innovation in Small Producers’ Clusters in  Vietnam through Actor Network Theory (ANT). Manchester: University of Manchester. 2013. (Actor-Network Theory for Development: Working Paper Series).