Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race

Jonathan Beckwith, Kostia Bergman, Michael Carson, Tobias Doerr, Lisa Geller, Robin Pierce, Sheldon Krimsky, Carol Martin, Marina Santiago, Amy Vashlishan Murray, Celestine Warren, Chad Zichterman

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

Abstract

Teaching the topic of genetics in relationship to ancestry and race generates many questions, and requires a teaching strategy that encourages perspective-based exploration and discussion. We have developed a set of dialogues for discussing the complex science of genetics, ancestry, and race that is contextualized in real human interactions and that contends with the social and ethical implications of this science. This article provides some brief historical and scientific context for these dialogues, describes their development, and relates how we have used them in different ways to engage diverse groups of science learners. The dialogue series can be incorporated into classroom or informal science education settings. After listening to or performing the dialogues and participating in a discussion, students will: (1) recognize misunderstandings about the relationship between DNA and race; (2) describe how DNA testing services assign geographic ancestry; (3) explain how scientific findings have been used historically to promote institutionalized racism and the role personal biases can play in science; (4) identify situations in their own life that have affected their understanding of genetics and race; and (5) discuss the potential consequences of the racialization of medicine as well as other fallacies about the connection of science and race.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)525-537
Number of pages13
JournalThe American Biology Teacher
Volume79
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

dialogue
science
scientific findings
DNA
teaching strategy
racism
Medicine
medicine
Education
classroom
trend
Teaching
interaction
education
Group
student

Cite this

Beckwith, J., Bergman, K., Carson, M., Doerr, T., Geller, L., Pierce, R., ... Zichterman, C. (2017). Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race. The American Biology Teacher, 79(7), 525-537. https://doi.org/10.1525/abt.2017.79.7.525
Beckwith, Jonathan ; Bergman, Kostia ; Carson, Michael ; Doerr, Tobias ; Geller, Lisa ; Pierce, Robin ; Krimsky, Sheldon ; Martin, Carol ; Santiago, Marina ; Vashlishan Murray, Amy ; Warren, Celestine ; Zichterman, Chad. / Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race. In: The American Biology Teacher. 2017 ; Vol. 79, No. 7. pp. 525-537.
@article{ded9855c86844a059b631485ef411332,
title = "Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race",
abstract = "Teaching the topic of genetics in relationship to ancestry and race generates many questions, and requires a teaching strategy that encourages perspective-based exploration and discussion. We have developed a set of dialogues for discussing the complex science of genetics, ancestry, and race that is contextualized in real human interactions and that contends with the social and ethical implications of this science. This article provides some brief historical and scientific context for these dialogues, describes their development, and relates how we have used them in different ways to engage diverse groups of science learners. The dialogue series can be incorporated into classroom or informal science education settings. After listening to or performing the dialogues and participating in a discussion, students will: (1) recognize misunderstandings about the relationship between DNA and race; (2) describe how DNA testing services assign geographic ancestry; (3) explain how scientific findings have been used historically to promote institutionalized racism and the role personal biases can play in science; (4) identify situations in their own life that have affected their understanding of genetics and race; and (5) discuss the potential consequences of the racialization of medicine as well as other fallacies about the connection of science and race.",
author = "Jonathan Beckwith and Kostia Bergman and Michael Carson and Tobias Doerr and Lisa Geller and Robin Pierce and Sheldon Krimsky and Carol Martin and Marina Santiago and {Vashlishan Murray}, Amy and Celestine Warren and Chad Zichterman",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1525/abt.2017.79.7.525",
language = "English",
volume = "79",
pages = "525--537",
journal = "The American Biology Teacher",
issn = "0002-7685",
publisher = "National Association of Biology Teachers, Inc",
number = "7",

}

Beckwith, J, Bergman, K, Carson, M, Doerr, T, Geller, L, Pierce, R, Krimsky, S, Martin, C, Santiago, M, Vashlishan Murray, A, Warren, C & Zichterman, C 2017, 'Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race' The American Biology Teacher, vol. 79, no. 7, pp. 525-537. https://doi.org/10.1525/abt.2017.79.7.525

Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race. / Beckwith, Jonathan; Bergman, Kostia; Carson, Michael; Doerr, Tobias; Geller, Lisa; Pierce, Robin; Krimsky, Sheldon; Martin, Carol; Santiago, Marina; Vashlishan Murray, Amy; Warren, Celestine; Zichterman, Chad.

In: The American Biology Teacher, Vol. 79, No. 7, 09.2017, p. 525-537.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleScientificpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Using dialogues to explore genetics, ancestry, and race

AU - Beckwith, Jonathan

AU - Bergman, Kostia

AU - Carson, Michael

AU - Doerr, Tobias

AU - Geller, Lisa

AU - Pierce, Robin

AU - Krimsky, Sheldon

AU - Martin, Carol

AU - Santiago, Marina

AU - Vashlishan Murray, Amy

AU - Warren, Celestine

AU - Zichterman, Chad

PY - 2017/9

Y1 - 2017/9

N2 - Teaching the topic of genetics in relationship to ancestry and race generates many questions, and requires a teaching strategy that encourages perspective-based exploration and discussion. We have developed a set of dialogues for discussing the complex science of genetics, ancestry, and race that is contextualized in real human interactions and that contends with the social and ethical implications of this science. This article provides some brief historical and scientific context for these dialogues, describes their development, and relates how we have used them in different ways to engage diverse groups of science learners. The dialogue series can be incorporated into classroom or informal science education settings. After listening to or performing the dialogues and participating in a discussion, students will: (1) recognize misunderstandings about the relationship between DNA and race; (2) describe how DNA testing services assign geographic ancestry; (3) explain how scientific findings have been used historically to promote institutionalized racism and the role personal biases can play in science; (4) identify situations in their own life that have affected their understanding of genetics and race; and (5) discuss the potential consequences of the racialization of medicine as well as other fallacies about the connection of science and race.

AB - Teaching the topic of genetics in relationship to ancestry and race generates many questions, and requires a teaching strategy that encourages perspective-based exploration and discussion. We have developed a set of dialogues for discussing the complex science of genetics, ancestry, and race that is contextualized in real human interactions and that contends with the social and ethical implications of this science. This article provides some brief historical and scientific context for these dialogues, describes their development, and relates how we have used them in different ways to engage diverse groups of science learners. The dialogue series can be incorporated into classroom or informal science education settings. After listening to or performing the dialogues and participating in a discussion, students will: (1) recognize misunderstandings about the relationship between DNA and race; (2) describe how DNA testing services assign geographic ancestry; (3) explain how scientific findings have been used historically to promote institutionalized racism and the role personal biases can play in science; (4) identify situations in their own life that have affected their understanding of genetics and race; and (5) discuss the potential consequences of the racialization of medicine as well as other fallacies about the connection of science and race.

U2 - 10.1525/abt.2017.79.7.525

DO - 10.1525/abt.2017.79.7.525

M3 - Article

VL - 79

SP - 525

EP - 537

JO - The American Biology Teacher

JF - The American Biology Teacher

SN - 0002-7685

IS - 7

ER -