Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers

H.P. van Dalen, K. Henkens

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

1030 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Demotion – a reduction of an employee’s rank and salary - is often mentioned by managers and policy makers as a measure to increase the employability of older workers, but in practice demotion is rarely applied. This paper takes a fresh look at the question of demotion by first employing a survey among European employers and second the use of a survey and a vignette study among managers in the Netherlands (N = 355). The European survey shows that although demotion is not often applied a considerable percentage contemplates the application in the near future, especially those employers who encounter work staff aging. The vignette study offers insight in their stated preferences with respect to demotion for a particular employee, described by a number of possible causes of underperformance. The key question is whether these causes refer to internal or external causes and causes which the employee can or cannot control. By using background characteristics on the manager, obtained through survey questions, we can assess whether the decision to demote is also affected the expectations of managers on the wider consequences of making demotion standard practice. Internal causes such as not willing to participate in training, and not being motivated to work increase the likelihood of demotion, whereas external causes (financial situation of the firm) are of little importance. However, even when an employee scores low points on all possible causes, demotion still is hesitantly considered. Much of this hesitation is connected to the perceived negative externalities which managers expect to materialize once demotion becomes standard practice
Original languageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherDepartment of Economics
Number of pages28
Volume2015-025
Publication statusPublished - 7 Apr 2015

Publication series

NameCentER Discussion Paper
Volume2015-025

Fingerprint

manager
worker
cause
employee
employer
financial situation
employability
salary
Netherlands
staff
firm

Keywords

  • older workers
  • demotion
  • productivity
  • wages

Cite this

van Dalen, H. P., & Henkens, K. (2015). Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers. (CentER Discussion Paper; Vol. 2015-025). Tilburg: Department of Economics.
van Dalen, H.P. ; Henkens, K. / Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers. Tilburg : Department of Economics, 2015. (CentER Discussion Paper).
@techreport{cef69d5ebcc24082b9fa0d569fe41efd,
title = "Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers",
abstract = "Demotion – a reduction of an employee’s rank and salary - is often mentioned by managers and policy makers as a measure to increase the employability of older workers, but in practice demotion is rarely applied. This paper takes a fresh look at the question of demotion by first employing a survey among European employers and second the use of a survey and a vignette study among managers in the Netherlands (N = 355). The European survey shows that although demotion is not often applied a considerable percentage contemplates the application in the near future, especially those employers who encounter work staff aging. The vignette study offers insight in their stated preferences with respect to demotion for a particular employee, described by a number of possible causes of underperformance. The key question is whether these causes refer to internal or external causes and causes which the employee can or cannot control. By using background characteristics on the manager, obtained through survey questions, we can assess whether the decision to demote is also affected the expectations of managers on the wider consequences of making demotion standard practice. Internal causes such as not willing to participate in training, and not being motivated to work increase the likelihood of demotion, whereas external causes (financial situation of the firm) are of little importance. However, even when an employee scores low points on all possible causes, demotion still is hesitantly considered. Much of this hesitation is connected to the perceived negative externalities which managers expect to materialize once demotion becomes standard practice",
keywords = "older workers, demotion, productivity, wages",
author = "{van Dalen}, H.P. and K. Henkens",
year = "2015",
month = "4",
day = "7",
language = "English",
volume = "2015-025",
series = "CentER Discussion Paper",
publisher = "Department of Economics",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "Department of Economics",

}

van Dalen, HP & Henkens, K 2015 'Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers' CentER Discussion Paper, vol. 2015-025, Department of Economics, Tilburg.

Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers. / van Dalen, H.P.; Henkens, K.

Tilburg : Department of Economics, 2015. (CentER Discussion Paper; Vol. 2015-025).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers

AU - van Dalen, H.P.

AU - Henkens, K.

PY - 2015/4/7

Y1 - 2015/4/7

N2 - Demotion – a reduction of an employee’s rank and salary - is often mentioned by managers and policy makers as a measure to increase the employability of older workers, but in practice demotion is rarely applied. This paper takes a fresh look at the question of demotion by first employing a survey among European employers and second the use of a survey and a vignette study among managers in the Netherlands (N = 355). The European survey shows that although demotion is not often applied a considerable percentage contemplates the application in the near future, especially those employers who encounter work staff aging. The vignette study offers insight in their stated preferences with respect to demotion for a particular employee, described by a number of possible causes of underperformance. The key question is whether these causes refer to internal or external causes and causes which the employee can or cannot control. By using background characteristics on the manager, obtained through survey questions, we can assess whether the decision to demote is also affected the expectations of managers on the wider consequences of making demotion standard practice. Internal causes such as not willing to participate in training, and not being motivated to work increase the likelihood of demotion, whereas external causes (financial situation of the firm) are of little importance. However, even when an employee scores low points on all possible causes, demotion still is hesitantly considered. Much of this hesitation is connected to the perceived negative externalities which managers expect to materialize once demotion becomes standard practice

AB - Demotion – a reduction of an employee’s rank and salary - is often mentioned by managers and policy makers as a measure to increase the employability of older workers, but in practice demotion is rarely applied. This paper takes a fresh look at the question of demotion by first employing a survey among European employers and second the use of a survey and a vignette study among managers in the Netherlands (N = 355). The European survey shows that although demotion is not often applied a considerable percentage contemplates the application in the near future, especially those employers who encounter work staff aging. The vignette study offers insight in their stated preferences with respect to demotion for a particular employee, described by a number of possible causes of underperformance. The key question is whether these causes refer to internal or external causes and causes which the employee can or cannot control. By using background characteristics on the manager, obtained through survey questions, we can assess whether the decision to demote is also affected the expectations of managers on the wider consequences of making demotion standard practice. Internal causes such as not willing to participate in training, and not being motivated to work increase the likelihood of demotion, whereas external causes (financial situation of the firm) are of little importance. However, even when an employee scores low points on all possible causes, demotion still is hesitantly considered. Much of this hesitation is connected to the perceived negative externalities which managers expect to materialize once demotion becomes standard practice

KW - older workers

KW - demotion

KW - productivity

KW - wages

M3 - Discussion paper

VL - 2015-025

T3 - CentER Discussion Paper

BT - Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers

PB - Department of Economics

CY - Tilburg

ER -

van Dalen HP, Henkens K. Why Demotion of Older Workers is a No-Go Area for Managers. Tilburg: Department of Economics. 2015 Apr 7. (CentER Discussion Paper).