You'll Never Walk Alone: The Effect of Moral Support on Performance

Fabrizio Colella, Patricio Dalton, G. Giusti

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

Abstract

This study presents evidence on the role of moral support on performance in a competitive environment. We take advantage of an unusual change in the Argentinean football legislation. In August 2013, as a matter of National security, the Argentinean government forced all the teams of the first division to play their games with only home team supporters. Supporters of the visiting teams were not allowed to be in stadiums during league games. We estimate the effect of this exogenous variation of supporters on team performance, and we find that visiting teams are, on average, about 20% more likely to lose without their supporters. Moreover, we find that the lack of supporters of the visiting
team increased the score differential between the home team and the visitor. The
effect of the ban is stronger for big teams, who have the highest number of supporters when playing away. In addition, we find no evidence of changes of referees' decisions due to the ban, suggesting that the effect on team performance is due to the loss of moral support rather than a change in referees hostility. As placebo test, we run the analysis using contemporaneous cup matches, where the visiting team supporters were allowed to attend. We find no effect of the ban on the cup games, which provides additional empirical support to our findings. Our results offer unique and novel empirical evidence of the importance on moral support on performance.
LanguageEnglish
Place of PublicationTilburg
PublisherCentER, Center for Economic Research
Number of pages30
Volume2018-026
StatePublished - 23 Jul 2018

Publication series

NameCentER Discussion Paper
Volume2018-026

Fingerprint

Referees
Team performance
Stadium
Empirical evidence
Football
National security
Competitive environment
Hostility
Government
Legislation

Keywords

  • support
  • encouragement
  • motivation
  • football
  • team performance
  • non-monetary incentives
  • competitive environments

Cite this

Colella, F., Dalton, P., & Giusti, G. (2018). You'll Never Walk Alone: The Effect of Moral Support on Performance. (CentER Discussion Paper; Vol. 2018-026). Tilburg: CentER, Center for Economic Research.
Colella, Fabrizio ; Dalton, Patricio ; Giusti, G./ You'll Never Walk Alone : The Effect of Moral Support on Performance. Tilburg : CentER, Center for Economic Research, 2018. (CentER Discussion Paper).
@techreport{1dac53ca948348f584b00ea70f06f80b,
title = "You'll Never Walk Alone: The Effect of Moral Support on Performance",
abstract = "This study presents evidence on the role of moral support on performance in a competitive environment. We take advantage of an unusual change in the Argentinean football legislation. In August 2013, as a matter of National security, the Argentinean government forced all the teams of the first division to play their games with only home team supporters. Supporters of the visiting teams were not allowed to be in stadiums during league games. We estimate the effect of this exogenous variation of supporters on team performance, and we find that visiting teams are, on average, about 20{\%} more likely to lose without their supporters. Moreover, we find that the lack of supporters of the visitingteam increased the score differential between the home team and the visitor. Theeffect of the ban is stronger for big teams, who have the highest number of supporters when playing away. In addition, we find no evidence of changes of referees' decisions due to the ban, suggesting that the effect on team performance is due to the loss of moral support rather than a change in referees hostility. As placebo test, we run the analysis using contemporaneous cup matches, where the visiting team supporters were allowed to attend. We find no effect of the ban on the cup games, which provides additional empirical support to our findings. Our results offer unique and novel empirical evidence of the importance on moral support on performance.",
keywords = "support, encouragement, motivation, football, team performance, non-monetary incentives, competitive environments",
author = "Fabrizio Colella and Patricio Dalton and G. Giusti",
year = "2018",
month = "7",
day = "23",
language = "English",
volume = "2018-026",
series = "CentER Discussion Paper",
publisher = "CentER, Center for Economic Research",
type = "WorkingPaper",
institution = "CentER, Center for Economic Research",

}

Colella, F, Dalton, P & Giusti, G 2018 'You'll Never Walk Alone: The Effect of Moral Support on Performance' CentER Discussion Paper, vol. 2018-026, CentER, Center for Economic Research, Tilburg.

You'll Never Walk Alone : The Effect of Moral Support on Performance. / Colella, Fabrizio; Dalton, Patricio; Giusti, G.

Tilburg : CentER, Center for Economic Research, 2018. (CentER Discussion Paper; Vol. 2018-026).

Research output: Working paperDiscussion paperOther research output

TY - UNPB

T1 - You'll Never Walk Alone

T2 - The Effect of Moral Support on Performance

AU - Colella,Fabrizio

AU - Dalton,Patricio

AU - Giusti,G.

PY - 2018/7/23

Y1 - 2018/7/23

N2 - This study presents evidence on the role of moral support on performance in a competitive environment. We take advantage of an unusual change in the Argentinean football legislation. In August 2013, as a matter of National security, the Argentinean government forced all the teams of the first division to play their games with only home team supporters. Supporters of the visiting teams were not allowed to be in stadiums during league games. We estimate the effect of this exogenous variation of supporters on team performance, and we find that visiting teams are, on average, about 20% more likely to lose without their supporters. Moreover, we find that the lack of supporters of the visitingteam increased the score differential between the home team and the visitor. Theeffect of the ban is stronger for big teams, who have the highest number of supporters when playing away. In addition, we find no evidence of changes of referees' decisions due to the ban, suggesting that the effect on team performance is due to the loss of moral support rather than a change in referees hostility. As placebo test, we run the analysis using contemporaneous cup matches, where the visiting team supporters were allowed to attend. We find no effect of the ban on the cup games, which provides additional empirical support to our findings. Our results offer unique and novel empirical evidence of the importance on moral support on performance.

AB - This study presents evidence on the role of moral support on performance in a competitive environment. We take advantage of an unusual change in the Argentinean football legislation. In August 2013, as a matter of National security, the Argentinean government forced all the teams of the first division to play their games with only home team supporters. Supporters of the visiting teams were not allowed to be in stadiums during league games. We estimate the effect of this exogenous variation of supporters on team performance, and we find that visiting teams are, on average, about 20% more likely to lose without their supporters. Moreover, we find that the lack of supporters of the visitingteam increased the score differential between the home team and the visitor. Theeffect of the ban is stronger for big teams, who have the highest number of supporters when playing away. In addition, we find no evidence of changes of referees' decisions due to the ban, suggesting that the effect on team performance is due to the loss of moral support rather than a change in referees hostility. As placebo test, we run the analysis using contemporaneous cup matches, where the visiting team supporters were allowed to attend. We find no effect of the ban on the cup games, which provides additional empirical support to our findings. Our results offer unique and novel empirical evidence of the importance on moral support on performance.

KW - support

KW - encouragement

KW - motivation

KW - football

KW - team performance

KW - non-monetary incentives

KW - competitive environments

M3 - Discussion paper

VL - 2018-026

T3 - CentER Discussion Paper

BT - You'll Never Walk Alone

PB - CentER, Center for Economic Research

CY - Tilburg

ER -

Colella F, Dalton P, Giusti G. You'll Never Walk Alone: The Effect of Moral Support on Performance. Tilburg: CentER, Center for Economic Research. 2018 Jul 23, (CentER Discussion Paper).